Fire science, codes and system types review

The first review session is on a Tuesday evening in Bramwell's training room. Gerry has put a whiteboard at the front, Sasha has her flashcards, and Nadia Fortier, now in her second year, has asked to sit in. 'The foundations come first,' Gerry says, 'because every other question leans on them. Why a fire alarm exists, what a fire does in a building, which code makes the building have one, and what kind of system it gets.' This lesson reviews the material from FAT-110: fire science, the codes that require fire alarm systems, and the main system types. Each section gives the key ideas, a worked example and the traps candidates fall into.

Fire science in three ideas

Fire needs fuel, heat and oxygen, and the chemical chain reaction between them; remove any one and the fire goes out. That is the fire tetrahedron, covered in FAT-110 lesson 2. For a fire alarm technician, three ideas matter most. First, smoke spreads faster and farther than flame and kills more people than heat, which is why smoke detection and early warning matter. Second, fires grow, often slowly at first and then very fast, which is why the time between ignition and detection is so important. Third, the products of a fire depend on what burns: modern furnishings with plastics and foams produce more smoke, faster, than the materials of fifty years ago.

Fire growth is often described with the t-squared model from FAT-110 lesson 3: the heat release rate grows with the square of time after ignition, Q = α t², where α depends on how fast the fire grows. Engineers use standard values of α for slow, medium, fast and ultra-fast fires. The model is a simplification, but it shows why detection time matters: a fast fire doubles its time from ignition and quadruples its size.

# t-squared fire growth: time to reach 1 MW for the standard growth rates
import math
alphas = {"slow": 0.00293, "medium": 0.01172, "fast": 0.0469, "ultra-fast": 0.1876}   # kW/s^2
target = 1000.0   # kW
for name, a in alphas.items():
    t = math.sqrt(target / a)
    print(f"{name:<11s} alpha {a:.4f} kW/s2  reaches 1 MW in {t:5.0f} s ({t / 60:4.1f} min)")

slow        alpha 0.0029 kW/s2  reaches 1 MW in   584 s ( 9.7 min)
medium      alpha 0.0117 kW/s2  reaches 1 MW in   292 s ( 4.9 min)
fast        alpha 0.0469 kW/s2  reaches 1 MW in   146 s ( 2.4 min)
ultra-fast  alpha 0.1876 kW/s2  reaches 1 MW in    73 s ( 1.2 min)

An exam question on fire science is rarely a calculation. More often it asks which detector suits a smouldering fire, why smoke detection is required in sleeping areas, or what the products of combustion are. The trap is choosing an answer that is true in general but does not fit the situation described, such as a heat detector for a fire that will smoulder for an hour before it produces much heat.

Which code requires the system

In Canada, the National Building Code decides whether a building needs a fire alarm system and what kind. Part 3 sets the requirements by occupancy and size: for example, assembly, care and treatment and residential occupancies need systems at lower thresholds than offices or warehouses, and high buildings over 36 m, covered by Subsection 3.2.6, need additional measures including voice communication. The National Fire Code covers existing buildings and their maintenance, and it is the NFC that makes building owners inspect and test their systems to CAN/ULC-S536. The provinces adopt these codes, sometimes with changes: Saskatchewan adopts the national codes directly. The building code then refers to the installation standard, CAN/ULC-S524, and requires verification to CAN/ULC-S537. This chain from code to standard is covered in FAT-110 lesson 7 and FAT-220 lesson 2.

The authority having jurisdiction is the organization or person who enforces the code: usually the local building and fire departments. Many exam questions turn on who decides something: whether an alternative is acceptable, whether a test may be deferred, whether a system may be impaired. The answer is usually the authority, often with the owner's responsibility alongside it.

System types

The main system types from FAT-110 lesson 5 are single-stage and two-stage systems, conventional and addressable systems, and stand-alone and networked systems. In a single-stage system, any alarm sounds the alarm signal throughout the building. In a two-stage system, an alarm first sounds an alert signal, and staff have a set time, five minutes under the NBC, to investigate and acknowledge before the alarm signal sounds automatically; a manual station key switch or similar can sound the alarm at once. Two-stage systems are common in Canadian hospitals and some large buildings. Conventional systems report by zone; addressable systems report each device. Voice systems give spoken instructions and are required in high buildings. FAT-210 lesson 7 covers single-stage and two-stage operation in detail.

A trap on two-stage questions is the acknowledge time. The five minutes runs from the alert signal; if the alert is not acknowledged, the alarm signal sounds automatically at the end of it. Acknowledging the alert does not cancel it: staff still have to investigate, and any second alarm or manual activation sounds the alarm at once.

Sprinklers and the fire alarm

Most buildings with fire alarm systems also have sprinklers, and the two must work together. The fire alarm supervises the sprinkler system: a waterflow switch reports an alarm when water flows, and valve supervisory switches report when a control valve is closed. FAT-110 lesson 8 and FAT-120 lesson 8 cover these devices. The two times every candidate should know are that a waterflow alarm must be indicated within 90 seconds of flow equal to one sprinkler, and that a valve supervisory signal must operate within two turns of the handwheel or one-fifth of the travel of the valve. In a sprinklered building, the codes sometimes allow fewer smoke detectors, because the sprinklers act as heat detectors; but smoke detection is still required where people sleep and in specific locations.

Practice set: foundations

Gerry ends the session with six questions written for Sasha and Nadia. Each one is followed by the answer and the reasoning, because the reasoning is what they need to carry into the exam.

Question 1. A fire in an upholstered chair smoulders for 40 minutes before flaming. Which detector type would most likely give the earliest warning? Answer: a photoelectric smoke detector. Smouldering fires produce large, visible particles, which photoelectric detectors sense best; a heat detector would not respond until flaming. The trap answer is ionization, which is better for fast flaming fires.

Question 2. A building owner says the fire alarm system is required by CAN/ULC-S524. Is that right? Answer: no. The building code requires the system; S524 sets how it is installed. The distinction matters because the building code also sets what kind of system, for example single-stage or two-stage, and where the annunciator goes.

Question 3. In a two-stage system, the alert has been acknowledged and staff are investigating. A second smoke detector operates. What happens? Answer: the alarm signal sounds at once. Acknowledgement only stops the automatic transfer from the first alert; any further alarm initiating device sounds the alarm.

Question 4. An eight-storey apartment building is 30 m high. Is it a high building under Subsection 3.2.6? Answer: not by height alone, because the threshold is more than 36 m; but 3.2.6 also applies to some buildings by occupancy and floor height, so the question may give other details. Read them before answering.

Question 5. A sprinkler control valve is closed during a renovation. What signal does the panel show, and what should the owner do? Answer: a supervisory signal. The owner treats it as an impairment: notifies the fire department and the monitoring company, arranges measures such as a fire watch if required, and restores the valve as soon as possible. The trap is calling it a trouble signal.

Question 6. A fire grows as a fast t-squared fire. About how long does it take to reach 1 MW? Answer: about 146 seconds, or just under two and a half minutes, using α of about 0.047 kW/s². The point of the question is not the number but the lesson: a fast fire becomes large within the time it might take someone to notice and decide to act.

Where to look

Sasha copies the table onto the back of her map of the standards. On the exam, knowing where to look is half the answer.

Fire science in one page

Fire science questions on the exams are usually about why a rule exists rather than the physics for its own sake. A short list of ideas covers most of them. Fire needs fuel, heat and oxygen, and the chemical chain reaction that sustains it. A growing fire produces a plume of hot gases that rises, spreads under the ceiling as a ceiling jet, and fills the room from the top down; this is why detectors go on or near ceilings and why stratification in tall spaces can keep smoke from reaching them. Smoldering fires produce larger smoke particles and little heat, which photoelectric detectors see well; flaming fires produce smaller particles and more heat, which ionization and heat detectors respond to. The t-squared model describes how quickly a fire grows: slow, medium, fast and ultrafast fires take about 600, 300, 150 and 75 seconds to reach about 1 MW.

# t-squared fire growth: time to reach 1,055 kW for each growth rate
growth = {"slow": 600, "medium": 300, "fast": 150, "ultrafast": 75}
for name, tg in growth.items():
    alpha = 1055 / tg ** 2
    q_60 = alpha * 60 ** 2
    print(f"{name:>9s}: alpha {alpha:.4f} kW/s2, heat release after 60 s about {q_60:.0f} kW")

     slow: alpha 0.0029 kW/s2, heat release after 60 s about 11 kW
   medium: alpha 0.0117 kW/s2, heat release after 60 s about 42 kW
     fast: alpha 0.0469 kW/s2, heat release after 60 s about 169 kW
ultrafast: alpha 0.1876 kW/s2, heat release after 60 s about 675 kW

The output shows why fast fires leave so little time: an ultrafast fire is already near 700 kW after one minute, while a slow fire is barely past 10 kW. Detection that waits for heat at the ceiling can come too late for a fast fire, which is one reason smoke detection is required in sleeping areas and escape routes.

System types in one table