IRW-340 · Lesson 10 of 12 · 58 min
Calculation practice
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
Andy saved the last hour of November 8 for numbers. He handed out a sheet of twenty-one problems, every one taken from a calculation the group had met in an earlier course, and gave them forty minutes. Then they went through them one by one. For each problem Andy asked two questions: what is the answer, and what is the wrong answer someone in a hurry would get? "The exam writers know the wrong answers better than you do," he said. "Every distractor on a calculation question is somebody's mistake. Learn the mistakes and the distractors stop working on you."
This lesson is that sheet. Each problem is worked out in full and ends with the trap: the error that produces a tempting wrong answer. Work each one on paper before reading the solution, then compare. The problems use the same values and the same methods as the earlier courses, so a result that differs from the one here is worth tracking down.
A few habits make calculation questions safer. Write the formula before putting numbers in. Keep units with every number and convert before calculating, not after. Estimate the answer roughly first: a sling leg load is always more than the share of the weight and never more than about twice it at sensible angles; a plumbness tolerance on a column is a couple of centimeters, not a couple of meters. If the exact answer is far from the estimate, the mistake is usually a unit or a missed step.
Rigging
Worked problem
1. Two legs at 45 degrees
A 5,300 lb beam is lifted with a two-leg bridle at 45 degrees from horizontal. Find the load per leg.
Show solution
- Share per leg: 5,300 ÷ 2 = 2,650 lb.
- Divide by sin 45° = 0.707: 2,650 ÷ 0.707 = 3,748 lb.
Answer: About 3,750 lb. Trap: dividing by cos 45° gives the same number here by coincidence, so the error goes unnoticed until the angle changes; at 60 degrees the cosine gives a leg load twice the share, which is wrong.
Worked problem
2. Two legs at 30 degrees
The same beam is lifted with the legs at 30 degrees. Find the load per leg.
Show solution
- Share per leg: 2,650 lb.
- Divide by sin 30° = 0.5: 2,650 ÷ 0.5 = 5,300 lb.
Answer: 5,300 lb per leg: each leg carries the whole beam. Trap: assuming a flatter sling is easier on the slings. The flatter the legs, the higher the load in each.
Worked problem
3. Four legs on a rigid load
A rigid precast panel weighing 8,800 lb is lifted with a four-leg bridle at 60 degrees. Find the load to check each leg against.
Show solution
- Assume two legs carry it: 8,800 ÷ 2 = 4,400 lb.
- Divide by sin 60° = 0.866: 4,400 ÷ 0.866 = 5,081 lb.
Answer: About 5,080 lb per leg. Trap: dividing by four legs gives 2,540 lb, half the real load, because a rigid load rocks onto two legs.
Worked problem
4. Choker capacity
A wire rope sling is rated 7,800 lb in a vertical hitch. What is its capacity as a choker?
Show solution
- Choker factor about 0.75.
- 7,800 × 0.75 = 5,850 lb.
Answer: About 5,850 lb, and less if the choke angle is sharp. Trap: using the basket factor of 2.0, which gives 15,600 lb.
Worked problem
5. Basket with angled legs
The same sling is used in a basket hitch with both legs at 60 degrees. What is its capacity?
Show solution
- Basket with vertical legs: 2 × 7,800 = 15,600 lb.
- Times the sling angle factor sin 60° = 0.866: 15,600 × 0.866 = 13,510 lb.
Answer: About 13,510 lb. Trap: doubling the rating without the angle factor.
Weights and cranes
Worked problem
6. A beam's weight
What does a W12x26 beam 30 ft long weigh?
Show solution
- The 26 is the weight in pounds per foot.
- 26 × 30 = 780 lb.
Answer: 780 lb. Trap: multiplying the depth, 12, by the length.
Worked problem
7. A rebar bundle
What does a bundle of 40 bars of #5 at 40 ft weigh?
Show solution
- 40 × 40 = 1,600 ft; 1,600 × 1.043 = 1,668.8 lb.
Answer: 1,668.8 lb. Trap: using the #4 weight of 0.668 lb/ft, which gives 1,068.8 lb.
Worked problem
8. Net capacity and critical lifts
A SAMPLE chart gives 20,600 lb at the working radius. The hook block is 1,500 lb and the rigging 330 lb. The load is 15,400 lb. What share of the net capacity is it?
Show solution
- Net: 20,600 − 1,500 − 330 = 18,770 lb.
- Share: 15,400 ÷ 18,770 = 0.820.
Answer: About 82 in 100, a critical lift under Crossbeam's 75 in 100 rule. Trap: comparing with the gross 20,600 lb gives 75 in 100.
Worked problem
9. Ground bearing under a mat
An outrigger puts 88,000 lb on a 5 ft by 5 ft mat. What is the bearing pressure?
Show solution
- Area: 5 × 5 = 25 ft².
- Pressure: 88,000 ÷ 25 = 3,520 psf.
Answer: 3,520 psf. Trap: dividing by the side length, 5 ft, instead of the area.
Safety and structural steel
Worked problem
10. Fall clearance
A worker uses a 6 ft energy-absorbing lanyard anchored at D-ring height. Deployment is up to 4 ft, harness stretch 1 ft, and the margin 3 ft. What clearance is needed below the working level?
Show solution
- 6 + 4 + 1 + 3 = 14 ft.
Answer: 14 ft. Trap: leaving out the margin or the stretch, giving 11 ft or 13 ft.
Worked problem
11. Plumbness
A column is 28 ft between splices. What is its tolerance at 1 in 500?
Show solution
- 28 × 12 = 336 in; 336 ÷ 500 = 0.672 in.
Answer: 0.672 in. Trap: dividing 28 ft by 500 without converting, giving 0.056, a number that looks like nothing.
Worked problem
12. Turn-of-nut rotation
A 3/4 in bolt is 3 1/2 in long. What rotation does the turn-of-nut method call for?
Show solution
- Length in diameters: 3.5 ÷ 0.75 = 4.7.
- Over 4 and up to 8 diameters: one-half turn.
Answer: One-half turn. Trap: choosing one-third turn because the bolt seems short.
Worked problem
13. Pre-installation verification
The minimum pretension of a 3/4 in A325 bolt is 28 kips. What tension must the calibration device show?
Show solution
- At least 1.05 times the minimum: 1.05 × 28 = 29.4 kips.
Answer: 29.4 kips. Trap: using the minimum pretension itself, which leaves no margin.
Worked problem
14. Concrete strength before erection
Footings are specified at 4,000 psi. What strength must be confirmed before steel is erected on them, at 75 in 100?
Show solution
- 0.75 × 4,000 = 3,000 psi.
Answer: 3,000 psi. Trap: using half the strength.
Reinforcing and post-tensioning
Worked problem
15. Laps in a run
A 100 ft run uses 40 ft stock bars with 26 in laps. How long is the third bar?
Show solution
- Covered by two bars: 40 + (40 − 2.17) = 77.83 ft.
- Remaining plus a lap: 100 − 77.83 + 2.17 = 24.33 ft.
Answer: 24 ft 4 in. Trap: forgetting the last lap, giving 22 ft 2 in.
Worked problem
16. Tendon elongation
A tendon is jacked to 30 kips over 100 ft, with a strand area of 0.153 in² and a typical modulus of 28,500 ksi. Find the expected elongation.
Show solution
- \[\Delta = \frac{30 \times 1200}{0.153 \times 28\,500} = 8.26\ \text{in}\]
Answer: About 8.3 in, acceptable from 7.7 to 8.8 in at ±7 in 100. Trap: entering the length in feet, giving 0.69 in, twelve times too small.
Decking, ornamental and welding
Worked problem
17. A deck bundle
A bundle has 30 sheets of 120 ft² at 1.6 psf. Is it within OSHA's 4,000 lb limit for landing on joists?
Show solution
- 30 × 120 × 1.6 = 5,760 lb.
- Over the limit: 20 sheets weigh 3,840 lb.
Answer: 5,760 lb is over the limit, so land 20 sheets at a time. Trap: using the area of one sheet only.
Worked problem
18. Stair risers
A floor-to-floor height is 169 in and the maximum riser is 7 in. How many risers, and how high?
Show solution
- 169 ÷ 7 = 24.1, rounded up to 25.
- 169 ÷ 25 = 6.76 in.
Answer: 25 risers of 6.76 in. Trap: rounding down to 24, giving 7.04 in, over the limit.
Worked problem
19. Guard openings
A guard panel is 94 in between posts with 21 pickets of 5/8 in bar. What is the clear gap?
Show solution
- (94 − 21 × 0.625) ÷ 22 = 80.875 ÷ 22 = 3.68 in.
Answer: 3.68 in, under the 4 in sphere. Trap: dividing by 21 instead of 22 spaces, or ignoring the bar width.
Worked problem
20. Acetylene cylinders
A heating tip uses 90 ft³/h of acetylene and each cylinder holds 300 ft³. How many cylinders on the manifold?
Show solution
- One cylinder: 300 ÷ 7 = 42.9 ft³/h.
- 90 ÷ 42.9 = 2.1, rounded up to 3.
Answer: Three cylinders. Trap: rounding down to two.
Worked problem
21. Thermal movement
A steel building frame is 160 ft long. How much does it change in length over a temperature change of 72 °F, with a coefficient of 6.5 × 10⁻⁶ per °F?
Show solution
- ΔL = 6.5 × 10⁻⁶ × (160 × 12) in × 72 = 0.90 in.
Answer: About 0.9 in. Trap: using the length in feet and reading 0.075 as inches.
Scoring the sheet
Benno got 17 of the 21 right in forty minutes. He missed numbers 3 (he divided by four legs), 11 (he forgot to convert to millimeters), 15 (he left out the last lap) and 21 (he did not finish). Each mistake went into his error log with the trap written beside it. Jules missed 12 and 18; Shay, a first-year, got 11 right and said the turn-of-nut problem finally made sense. Andy's rule for the group was that a calculation is not finished until the answer has been compared with an estimate, and that rule alone would have caught two of Benno's four errors.
| Problem type | Number of problems | Benno right |
|---|---|---|
| Rigging | 5 | 4 |
| Weights and cranes | 4 | 4 |
| Safety and steel | 5 | 4 |
| Reinforcing and post-tensioning | 2 | 1 |
| Decking, ornamental and welding | 5 | 4 |
| Total | 21 | 17 |
Five more for practice
These five problems are left for the reader. They use the same methods as the worked problems above. Answers are at the end of the list; cover them while working.
- A. A 4,000 lb bundle is lifted on a two-leg bridle at 60 degrees. What is the load per leg?
- B. A W10x49 column is 28 ft long. What does it weigh, before plates?
- C. A bolt is 3 in long and 3/4 in in diameter. What turn-of-nut rotation applies?
- D. A slab mat uses 60 bars of #4 at 30 ft. What does it weigh?
- E. A guard is 72 in between posts with 16 pickets of 5/8 in bar. Does it pass the 4 in sphere rule?
Answers: A. 2,000 ÷ 0.866 = 2,309 lb. B. 49 × 28 = 1,372 lb. C. 3 ÷ 0.75 = 4.0 diameters, so one-third turn. D. 60 × 30 × 0.668 = 1,202.4 lb. E. (72 − 16 × 0.625) ÷ 17 = 3.65 in, so it passes.
How calculation questions are scored
On the exam, a calculation question scores the same as any other question: one mark for the right option, nothing for the work. That means the work on scrap paper is for the candidate, not the examiner. It is still worth writing, because it is the only way to check an answer quickly in the second pass. Andy's sheets always had the formula, the numbers with units, the answer and the estimate, in that order, so a glance at the end of the exam could find a slip.
Calculators are allowed on most trade exams, but the type is controlled; candidates should check the candidate guide and bring the kind it allows. A candidate who has practiced only on a phone calculator may be slow on a basic one, so Benno did his November and December practice on the same simple calculator he would take into the exam.
A last habit from the sheet: when a problem gives more information than it needs, such as a beam's depth when only its mass per length matters, the extra number is often there to tempt a wrong method. Noticing what a problem does not need is part of solving it.
Common mistakes
MistakeCalculating before writing the formula.
InsteadWrite the formula with its units, then substitute.
MistakeConverting units at the end.
InsteadConvert before calculating; a tolerance in millimeters needs a height in millimeters.
MistakeRounding counts down.
InsteadRisers, cylinders, bars and bundles are rounded up to stay within limits.
MistakeSkipping the estimate.
InsteadCompare every answer with a rough estimate; a big difference means a mistake.
MistakeTrusting the first answer that matches an option.
InsteadDistractors are built from common mistakes; check the method, not just the match.
Summary and key terms
- Sling leg load is the share of the weight divided by the sine of the angle from horizontal; rigid loads are checked on two legs.
- Weights come from mass or weight per unit length times length; net crane capacity subtracts all deductions.
- Clearance adds free fall, deceleration, stretch and margin; plumbness is height divided by 500 in the same units.
- Turn-of-nut rotation depends on length in diameters; verification is 1.05 times the minimum pretension.
- Laps add one lap length per joint; elongation is PL ÷ AE in consistent units.
- Round risers and cylinders up; check guard gaps as clear openings.
- Estimate
- A rough answer worked out first to check the exact one.
- Trap
- A common mistake that leads to one of the wrong options.
- Consistent units
- Units chosen so that the formula gives the answer in the unit wanted without hidden conversion factors.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
A 6,600 lb load hangs from two legs at 45 degrees. What is the load per leg?
Show answer
3,300 ÷ 0.707 = 4,667 lb.
A column is 40 ft between splices. What is the 1 in 500 tolerance?
Show answer
0.96 in.
A bolt is 2 1/2 in long and 3/4 in in diameter. What rotation?
Show answer
2.5 ÷ 0.75 = 3.3 diameters: one-third turn.
A floor-to-floor height of 120 in with a 7 in maximum needs how many risers?
Show answer
120 ÷ 7 = 17.1, so 18 risers of 6.67 in.
Footings are specified at 5,000 psi. What strength is needed before erection at 75 in 100?
Show answer
3,750 psi.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.