INS-420 · Lesson 1 of 12 · 22 min

How insulation work is bid

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

On Monday, October 5, 2026, three e-mails arrived in Raj Sandhu's inbox within an hour of each other. Harcourt Mechanical, Vantage Mechanical and Ingleby Mechanical were all bidding the HVAC and plumbing packages on Ridgemount High School, a new two-story school for the Hollins Run Local School District north of the city, and each wanted a price for the thermal insulation. The bid documents had been posted on the Friday: about 300 drawings and a project manual of more than 1,200 pages. Raj forwarded the invitations to Walt Lowery with one line: "Bid closes for us Thursday, November 12. I'm in."

Priya Lam, the third-year apprentice who had been spending some of her evenings in the office that fall, asked whether she could follow the bid from start to finish. Raj agreed, on one condition: she would do part of the takeoff herself and check his. This course follows that bid, along with the jobs Coldstream was running at the same time, to show how insulation work is estimated, planned, run and closed out. It is written for the insulator who is ready to lead a crew, help an estimator or start estimating, and it builds on the materials and methods of the earlier courses, especially INS-310 and INS-410.

This first lesson explains how construction work reaches an insulation contractor, the documents that describe it, the contracts that govern it and the parts of a price. Later lessons take each part in turn: the takeoff in lessons 2 to 4, labor in lesson 5, access in lesson 6, the schedule in lesson 7, the crew in lesson 8, quality in lesson 9, changes in lesson 10, close-out in lesson 11 and the full Ridgemount estimate in lesson 12.

Where insulation work comes from

An insulation contractor rarely works directly for the building owner on new construction. Insulation is usually part of the mechanical work, so the insulator is a subcontractor to the mechanical contractor, who is in turn a subcontractor to the general contractor or construction manager. On plant maintenance work the picture is different: an owner such as Kellerton Foods hires Coldstream directly, often under a standing service agreement with set rates, as INS-410's audit work showed. Coldstream's work mix of about 55 in 100 industrial and 35 in 100 commercial means Raj and Walt bid both kinds of work every month.

Ridgemount followed a common Ohio pattern for public school construction. The school district, as owner, hired an architect, who hired a mechanical engineer, Taversham Engineering, whose project engineer was Saskia Fennick. The district hired a construction manager at risk, Oriel Construction, which bid the work out in trade packages and would hold the trade contracts. The three mechanical contractors bidding the HVAC and plumbing packages each collected prices from insulation, controls, water treatment and other specialty subcontractors, added their own work and submitted a package price to Oriel. The construction manager would recommend the lowest responsive, responsible bidder for each package, and that contractor would then choose an insulation contractor.

A chain of boxes from top to bottom: owner, design team (architect and mechanical engineer) beside it, then general contractor or construction manager, then three mechanical contractors, then Coldstream and other insulation contractors. Arrows show tender documents going down and prices going up.
How Ridgemount's insulation price travels: documents go down the chain, prices come back up.

Because Coldstream's price went to all three mechanical bidders, it had to be the same price to each, built on the same documents. Raj would not know until after the general contractor's close which mechanical contractor, if any, would carry Coldstream. Bidding to every bidder is normal for a subcontractor, and so is the discipline that goes with it: no side deals, no lower price to a favorite customer, and a written quotation that every bidder can rely on.

The tender documents

The tender package is a contract waiting to be signed, and an estimator has to read it that way. For the insulation trade the important parts are:

  • Instructions to bidders and the bid form: the closing time and place, how prices are submitted, which alternates and separate prices are asked for, and whether a bid bond or other security is required.
  • The contract form and its conditions: the standard contract the owner will use, and the supplementary conditions that change it. These set payment terms, holdback or retainage, warranties, insurance and how changes are priced.
  • The project manual's specifications: organized by the MasterFormat numbering that INS-410 lesson 8 described. Insulation for plumbing is usually in Section 22 07 00 or its subsections (22 07 19 for piping), and for HVAC in Section 23 07 00 (23 07 13 for ducts, 23 07 16 for equipment, 23 07 19 for piping). Division 01 sets general requirements that apply to every trade: submittals, schedules, cleaning, closeout and the like.
  • The drawings: mechanical plans, sections, details, schedules and riser diagrams. Lesson 2 covers reading them for takeoff.
  • Addenda: changes and answers issued during the tender. Each addendum forms part of the contract, and the bid form usually requires the bidder to list the addenda it has received.

Raj read the insulation sections first, then Division 01, then the drawings. He kept a running list of questions, and he sent three of them in writing to the engineer through the bidders' question process before questions closed. One asked whether the horizontal storm drains in the ceiling spaces were to be insulated, because the drawings showed it and the specification did not. Addendum 1, issued Friday, October 23, answered it: yes, the horizontal storm piping and the roof drain bodies were to be insulated, and that added about 1,250 ft of pipe to the takeoff.

The habit matters. A bidder who notices a conflict and guesses has two bad outcomes: guess high and lose the job, or guess low and lose money on it. Asking in writing, so the answer goes to every bidder in an addendum, keeps the competition fair and gives the estimator a document to point to later.

The contracts behind the work

Most building work in the United States uses standard contract forms from the American Institute of Architects (AIA) or ConsensusDocs. For a construction manager at risk the owner signs a form such as AIA A133 with the general conditions of AIA A201, and the construction manager signs trade contracts with each package contractor. Between the mechanical contractor and Coldstream the usual form is a subcontract such as AIA A401 or the contractor's own form. A subcontract normally passes the prime contract's terms down the chain, so the insulation contractor is bound by the same specifications, schedule, warranty and change procedures as everyone above it.

Two kinds of Ohio law shape every construction subcontract. The prompt pay rules for private work require a contractor to pay a subcontractor within 10 calendar days of receiving payment for that subcontractor's work, with interest at 18 in 100 a year on late amounts. Public improvement contracts, including public schools, follow separate rules on retainage: 8 in 100 is withheld from progress payments until the project is half complete, and the retained money goes into an escrow account. Federal OSHA rules set the safety duties that lessons 6 and 8 cover. Lesson 11 returns to retainage at closeout.

An estimator does not need to be a lawyer, but should read the payment, holdback or retainage, warranty, insurance, liquidated damages and change clauses before pricing, because each one costs money or carries risk. Raj marks them in yellow on the first read and lists anything unusual in Coldstream's qualifications.

Bonds, insurance and security

Owners and contractors want assurance that a bidder will sign the contract it bid and finish the work. The common tools are:

  • Bid security: a bid bond, or sometimes a certified check, submitted with the bid. If the low bidder refuses to sign the contract, the security pays the owner the difference to the next bidder, up to its limit. A bid bond of 10 in 100 of the bid price is typical.
  • Performance and payment bonds: after award, a performance bond guarantees that the work will be completed, and a labor and material payment bond guarantees that subcontractors and suppliers will be paid. Each is often set at 50 or 100 in 100 of the contract price, as the bid documents require.
  • Insurance: commercial general liability, automobile, and on many sites contractor's equipment and pollution coverage, with certificates naming the owner and contractors as additional insureds.
  • Workers' compensation: proof of coverage through the Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation, which Ohio requires of most employers.

On Ridgemount the insulation subcontract would not need its own bid bond, because the subcontractors' prices go to the mechanical bidders rather than to the owner, but the mechanical subcontract would require Coldstream to provide a performance bond if asked. A bond costs a premium, usually a small fraction of the bonded amount, so Raj added a line to his price for a bond if required.

The parts of a price

However the documents arrive, an insulation price is built from the same parts. Each one is the subject of a later lesson:

The parts of an insulation price and the lessons that cover them.
PartWhat it coversLesson
QuantitiesLengths of pipe by size, thickness and system; fittings and valves; areas of duct and equipment2, 3
MaterialInsulation, jackets, fitting covers, adhesives, mastics, bands, pins, tapes and waste allowances4
Direct laborCrew hours from labor units, adjusted for conditions, times a burdened hourly rate5
Access and equipmentScaffold, lifts, ladders, staging, rentals and the time to move them6
Supervision and job overheadForeperson time that is not on the tools, travel, parking, permits, safety, storage5, 8
Small tools and consumablesKnives, saws, blades, cleaning, tape measures and other items used up on the job4
Company overheadOffice, estimating, yard, shop, vehicles and insurance spread over all jobs12
ProfitThe return for the risk and the investment in the company12

Labor is usually the largest part. On commercial pipe and duct work it is often 55 to 70 in 100 of the selling price, which is why an estimator spends most of the effort on the labor units and the conditions that change them. Material is usually 15 to 30 in 100. Those are typical ranges, and they move with the work: a job of thick cellular glass on a cold system has a much higher material share than a job of glass fiber on small pipe.

A stacked bar showing the parts of the Carrow Park price from bottom to top: labor, material, access, consumables, overhead and profit, with each part labeled with its amount in dollars.
How Raj's original Carrow Park price was built up (sample rates and prices).

Worked problem

Building up a price

Before the Carrow Park arena job in INS-320, Raj estimated 226 crew-hours from Coldstream's labor units. Using a sample burdened rate of 88 dollars an hour, material of 11,200 dollars, access and equipment of 600 dollars, consumables at 3 in 100 of labor, company overhead at 12 in 100 and profit at 8 in 100 on top of that, what was the price?

Show solution
  1. Labor: 226 × 88 = 19,888 dollars.
  2. Consumables: 0.03 × 19,888 = 596.64 dollars.
  3. Direct cost: 19,888 + 11,200 + 600 + 596.64 = 32,284.64 dollars.
  4. Overhead: 0.12 × 32,284.64 = 3,874.16; running total 36,158.80 dollars.
  5. Profit: 0.08 × 36,158.80 = 2,892.70; price 39,051.50 dollars.

Answer: Raj quoted about 39,050 dollars. Labor was 51 in 100 of the price on this job because cellular glass is expensive material.

The burdened rate is more than the wage. It includes the employer's costs that follow every paid hour: vacation and holiday pay, statutory payroll costs, workplace insurance premiums, and for union crews the benefit, pension and training contributions set by the collective agreement. A wage of a certain amount can easily become a burdened cost half as much again. Walt sets Coldstream's burdened rates each year from the payroll records; estimators use them and do not change them.

Qualifications, exclusions and alternates

A quotation is only as clear as its scope. Raj's quotation form has three sections after the price:

  • Inclusions: what the price covers, by specification section and system, and the addenda received. A bidder who reads "per plans and specifications" cannot be sure the insulator saw the same plans.
  • Exclusions: what the price does not cover, such as heat tracing, firestopping (which Coldstream prices separately when asked), asbestos abatement, painting of jackets, removal of existing insulation, or work by other trades that the specification puts in the insulation section by mistake.
  • Qualifications: conditions the price depends on, such as working hours, a number of mobilizations, the owner supplying hoisting, or a price being open for 60 days.

Alternates and separate prices are asked for on the bid form, and they must be priced exactly as described. Ridgemount's bid form asked mechanical bidders for an alternate to replace the glass fiber and PVC jacket on exposed piping in the gymnasium mechanical mezzanine with aluminum jacket, and Raj priced it as an add.

Clear exclusions are not a way to win by leaving things out. A mechanical contractor comparing three insulation quotations will add the missing items back to each one before choosing, and an insulator who excludes too much simply looks expensive. The goal is that every bidder knows exactly what it is buying.

Bid day and after

Bids close at a fixed time, and late bids are rejected. A subcontractor's price has to reach its bidders early enough for them to check it, so Coldstream's quotation went out on Thursday, November 12, at 11:00, a few days before the mechanical bidders' own close. Raj sent the same quotation to all three by e-mail, phoned each estimator to confirm it had arrived, and answered two questions about the alternate by phone. Any clarification he gave one bidder he wrote down and sent to all three.

The rest of the timeline was in the future: package bids to Oriel on Tuesday, November 17, the construction manager's recommendation to the district soon after, and a board decision expected in December. If the contract went ahead, construction would start in the spring of 2027 and the insulation work would fall mostly in 2028.

Whether Coldstream wins or loses, the estimate is kept. Lesson 11 shows how comparing estimated and actual hours at the end of every job keeps the company's labor units honest, and lesson 12 walks through the Ridgemount estimate in full.

Common mistakes

  • MistakePricing from the drawings without reading the specification.

    InsteadRead the insulation sections and Division 01 first; the specification sets thicknesses, materials, jackets and requirements the drawings never show.

  • MistakeGuessing at a conflict between the drawings and the specification.

    InsteadAsk in writing before questions close, so the answer comes to every bidder in an addendum.

  • MistakeGiving one bidder a different price or scope.

    InsteadSend the same written quotation to every bidder and copy any clarification to all of them.

  • MistakeUsing the wage instead of the burdened rate.

    InsteadUse the company's burdened rate, which includes payroll costs, insurance and benefits.

  • MistakeWriting a scope of "per plans and specifications" only.

    InsteadList the sections, systems and addenda included, and state exclusions and qualifications clearly.

Summary and key terms

  • On new construction, insulation is usually a subcontract to the mechanical contractor; on plant work the owner often hires the insulator directly.
  • The tender documents are the instructions to bidders, contract and conditions, specification, drawings and addenda; all of them become the contract.
  • Standard forms (AIA A201 and A401, or ConsensusDocs) and Ohio's prompt pay and public retainage rules shape Ohio subcontracts.
  • A price is built from quantities, material, labor at a burdened rate, access, supervision, consumables, overhead and profit; labor is usually the largest part.
  • A clear quotation lists inclusions, exclusions, qualifications and alternates, and the same quotation goes to every bidder.
Tender documents
The drawings, specification, contract conditions, bid form and addenda issued to bidders.
Addendum
A written change or answer issued during the tender that becomes part of the contract documents.
Subcontract
A contract between a contractor and a specialty contractor for part of the work.
Burdened rate
The hourly labor cost including wages, payroll costs, insurance and benefits.
Bid bond
Security given with a bid that pays the owner if the bidder refuses to sign the contract.
Exclusion
Work that a quotation states it does not cover.
Alternate
A change to the base scope that the bid form asks bidders to price separately.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. Who usually hires the insulation contractor on a new school?

    Show answer

    The mechanical contractor, as a subcontractor under the general contractor or construction manager.

  2. Why did Raj send his storm drain question in writing?

    Show answer

    So the answer would come to all bidders in an addendum and he could rely on it.

  3. What does Addendum 1 add to Ridgemount's insulation scope?

    Show answer

    Horizontal storm piping and roof drain bodies, about 1,250 ft of pipe.

  4. What share of progress payments is withheld on an Ohio public project before it is half complete?

    Show answer

    8 in 100, until the project is half complete.

  5. Why is labor the part of a price an estimator studies most?

    Show answer

    Because it is usually the largest part, often 55 to 70 in 100 of a commercial insulation price.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz