ROOF-340 · Lesson 4 of 12 · 24 min

Review: materials and building science

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

Dana's materials review started with a box. She had collected one sample of everything Ridgecap used: a shingle, a roll end of SBS cap sheet, a square of APP, a strip of TPO, a strip of EPDM, a cut of PVC, a piece of polyiso, a piece of extruded polystyrene, a cover board, a scrap of galvanized steel, aluminium, copper and lead, a handful of fasteners and a can of primer. She tipped it out on the table and gave each of them ten items. "Tell me what it is, what it's made of, what it's for, and one thing that can go wrong with it."

This lesson reviews ROOF-120 and the building science in ROOF-310: what a roof assembly must do, slopes and areas, decks, heat, air and moisture, the main material families, metals, fasteners and wind. Many questions on the exam that look like questions about one system are really questions about these principles: why a vapour retarder goes on the warm side, why two metals should not touch, why a fastener must reach a certain depth.

What a roof must do

Every roof assembly has the same jobs: shed water, resist wind, control heat, air and vapour, carry loads, resist fire, and last. When a roof fails, it is because one of these jobs was not done, and a good diagnosis starts by asking which one. A leak at a parapet is a water-shedding failure at a detail; blisters in a membrane often point to moisture or air trapped during installation; condensation under a deck points to air and vapour control; a blow-off at a corner is a wind failure, usually of the attachment rather than the membrane.

Slope, area and squares

Slope is written in several ways, and exam questions move between them. Steep-slope roofs are usually described as a rise in 12 (also as a rise in 12 in Canada, from the imperial habit, even when the rest of the job is metric); low-slope roofs as a ratio such as 1 in 50, or a rise per foot such as 1/4 in per foot. The same slope can also be given as a number in 100 or an angle.

Common roof slopes in different forms.
SlopeAs a ratioIn 100Angle
1/4 in 121 in 482.11.2°
1 in 501 in 502.01.1°
2 in 121 in 616.79.5°
4 in 121 in 333.318.4°
5 in 121 in 2.441.722.6°
8 in 121 in 1.566.733.7°
12 in 121 in 110045°

Plan area is the area of the roof seen from above. The actual roof area of a sloped roof is larger, and it is found by multiplying the plan area by the pitch factor, which is the length of the sloped surface for each unit of horizontal run: √(rise² + run²) ÷ run. For 4 in 12 the factor is 1.054; for 6 in 12, 1.118; for 8 in 12, 1.202; for 12 in 12, 1.414. Roofing materials are sold and estimated by the square, which is 100 ft² of roof, about 9.29 m².

Worked problem

From plan area to squares

A gable roof at 6 in 12 has a plan area of 112 m², including overhangs. What is the roof area, and how many squares is it before waste?

Show solution
  1. Pitch factor for 6 in 12 = √(36 + 144) ÷ 12 = √180 ÷ 12 = 1.118.
  2. Roof area = 112 × 1.118 = 125.2 m².
  3. Squares = 125.2 ÷ 9.29 = 13.5 squares.

Answer: About 125 m², or 13.5 squares before waste.

Decks

The deck carries the roof and everything on it to the structure. Wood decks are plywood or OSB panels, or old board sheathing, fastened to rafters or trusses with gaps at panel edges for movement and with panel edges supported. Steel decks are fluted sheets fastened to joists, with insulation spanning the flutes, and they need fasteners long enough to engage the top flange. Concrete decks, cast in place or precast, are heavy, take adhered and ballasted systems well, and must be dry enough before roofing; their moisture is a common cause of trouble under a new membrane. Before any roof goes on, the roofer inspects the deck and refuses to cover one that is wet, damaged, uneven or unfastened, because the roof will only be as good as what it sits on.

Heat

Heat moves by conduction through materials, by convection with moving air, and by radiation across spaces. Insulation slows conduction. Its resistance is given as RSI in metric units and R in imperial units; RSI × 5.678 = R. The resistances of layers in series add up, and the heat flow through an assembly is the area times the temperature difference divided by the total resistance.

Worked problem

Heat loss through a roof

The Carrick Street roof is 760 m². Its new insulation is 100 mm of polyiso at RSI 0.0395 per millimetre (from its long-term thermal resistance), and the other layers add about RSI 0.35. How much heat does the roof lose when it is 20 °C inside and −20 °C outside?

Show solution
  1. Polyiso = 100 × 0.0395 = 3.95.
  2. Total RSI = 3.95 + 0.35 = 4.30.
  3. U = 1 ÷ 4.30 = 0.233 W/m²·K.
  4. Temperature difference = 20 − (−20) = 40 K.
  5. Heat loss = 0.233 × 760 × 40 = 7,070 W.

Answer: About 7.1 kW. Doubling the insulation would roughly halve it.

Exam questions about insulation also test the properties behind the numbers: polyiso loses some of its value at low temperatures and as it ages, which is why designers use its long-term value and some use lower values for cold climates; extruded polystyrene resists water and is used in protected membrane roofs; expanded polystyrene is cheaper per unit of resistance but must be protected from solvents and hot asphalt; mineral wool is non-combustible; cover boards protect the insulation and give the membrane a firm surface.

Air, vapour and condensation

Moisture moves into roofs by two routes. Diffusion moves water vapour slowly through materials from the warm, humid side to the cold, dry side. Air leakage carries much more moisture through gaps and holes. That is why an air barrier, which stops air movement, often matters more than a vapour retarder, which slows diffusion, although in roofs one membrane often does both. In a heated building in a cold climate, the vapour retarder goes on the warm side of the insulation, so that it stays above the dew point.

Condensation happens where a surface is colder than the dew point of the air touching it. To find whether an assembly is at risk, the temperature at each layer is worked out from the share of the total resistance each layer has, and compared with the dew point of the indoor air.

A section through a steel deck roof with a vapour retarder on the deck, two layers of polyiso, a cover board and a membrane. A temperature line drops from 20 °C inside to −20 °C outside, mostly across the insulation. A dashed line marks an indoor dew point of 7 °C, and the vapour retarder sits on the warm side where its temperature is about 19 °C.
The vapour retarder stays warm because it is on the warm side of the insulation.

In attics over insulated ceilings, the defence against condensation and ice dams is a tight ceiling and balanced ventilation. The Ontario code's usual minimum is 1 unit of net free vent area for every 300 units of insulated ceiling area, increased to 1 in 150 in some cases, with the vents divided between low and high. Eave protection keeps water from ice dams out of the roof: the Ontario code's usual requirement is a membrane from the edge to at least 900 mm up the slope and at least 300 mm inside the inner face of the wall, with an exemption in milder areas.

Materials

Material families and what the exam asks about them.
FamilyKey facts for the exam
AsphaltGraded by softening point (types I to IV for built-up roofing); applied at its equiviscous temperature, well below its flash point
Built-up roofingFelts and asphalt in three or four plies, with a flood coat and gravel or a cap sheet
SBS modified bitumenRubber-like modifier, flexible in cold; torch, hot-mopped, cold-applied or self-adhered
APP modified bitumenPlastic modifier, stiffer, resists heat and sun; usually torch-applied
EPDMThermoset rubber; seams taped with primer; very durable, black or white
TPOThermoplastic; heat-welded seams; usually white; reinforced with a scrim
PVCThermoplastic with plasticizers; heat-welded; resists grease and chemicals; must be kept away from asphalt and some foams
Asphalt shinglesGlass-mat, asphalt and granules; strip or laminated; rated for wind and impact

Compatibility is a common exam theme: PVC is damaged by contact with asphalt and some polystyrene; EPDM is damaged by petroleum products and some adhesives; hot asphalt and solvents can melt expanded polystyrene. The maker's instructions always list what a membrane must be separated from, and how.

Metals and movement

Two metals in contact in the presence of water form a galvanic cell, and the less noble metal corrodes. In roofing, the classic problems are copper above galvanized steel or aluminium, so that runoff from the copper attacks the metal below, and steel fasteners in copper or aluminium. The answer is to use the same metal, or metals close together in the galvanic series, or to separate them, and to arrange water flow from the less noble metal to the more noble one, not the other way.

Metals expand and contract with temperature. The change in length is ΔL = α × L × ΔT, where α is the metal's coefficient of expansion. Aluminium moves about twice as much as steel, and long pieces of sheet metal need joints, cleats and slotted fastening that let them move.

Worked problem

Expansion of an aluminium coping

A 3.0 m length of aluminium coping goes from −30 °C on a winter night to 60 °C in summer sun. With α = 23 × 10⁻⁶ per °C, how much does it change in length?

Show solution
  1. ΔT = 60 − (−30) = 90 °C.
  2. ΔL = 23 × 10⁻⁶ × 3,000 mm × 90 = 6.21 mm.

Answer: About 6 mm. Joints must allow that movement, or the coping will buckle or tear its fasteners.

Fasteners and wind

Fasteners must penetrate far enough to hold: shingle nails at least 12 mm into the deck or through it; insulation and membrane screws far enough into a steel deck's top flange, usually about 19 mm past it; fasteners into wood and concrete as the maker's tables say. They must also be the right material for the metal around them and corrosion resistant.

Wind pulls on a roof hardest at the corners, then at the perimeter, and least in the field. Codes and makers divide a roof into these zones and require more attachment in the perimeter and corners. In Ontario, membrane roof assemblies are tested to CSA A123.21 for dynamic wind uplift, and the installed roof must match the tested assembly: the same deck, the same boards, the same fasteners in the same pattern. Lesson 7 reviews zones and fastener counts.

Exam-style questions explained

Question. A new roof over a heated building has condensation forming under the deck in winter. Which is the most likely cause? (A) The membrane is too thin; (B) warm, moist indoor air is leaking into the assembly through gaps in the air barrier; (C) the insulation is too thick; (D) the roof is white. Answer: B. Air leakage carries far more moisture than diffusion, and gaps at walls and penetrations are the usual path.

Question. Copper flashings are installed on a roof that drains into galvanized steel gutters. What is the concern? (A) None, because the metals do not touch; (B) the copper will corrode; (C) runoff from the copper will corrode the galvanized gutters; (D) the gutters will be too heavy. Answer: C. Water carries copper ions onto the less noble zinc coating, which then corrodes even though the metals never touch. Exam questions on galvanic corrosion turn on the direction of the water, so read the arrangement carefully.

Question. Which change of units is correct? (A) RSI 3.52 = R-20; (B) R-20 = RSI 113.6; (C) RSI 1 = R-1; (D) R-5.7 = RSI 5.7. Answer: A. RSI × 5.678 = R.

Question. A roof is 4 in 12. What is that as a ratio? (A) 1 in 4; (B) 1 in 3; (C) 1 in 12; (D) 4 in 100. Answer: B. 12 ÷ 4 = 3.

Reading the maker's instructions

Many questions in the materials area are answered by the same documents on every job: the manufacturer's product data sheet, its installation instructions and its safety data sheet. The data sheet gives the material's properties and standards; the installation instructions give temperatures, laps, fastening and compatibility; the safety data sheet gives the hazards and protection. A roofer who has read those three documents for each of the main systems will recognize most of the facts the exam asks for, because the industry's standard practice is written into them.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeUsing plan area to order materials for a sloped roof.

    InsteadMultiply plan area by the pitch factor, then add waste.

  • MistakePutting the vapour retarder on the cold side of the insulation in a heated building.

    InsteadKeep it on the warm side, so it stays above the dew point.

  • MistakeTreating all membranes as compatible with asphalt and solvents.

    InsteadCheck the maker's list; PVC and EPDM in particular must be separated.

  • MistakeFixing long metal pieces tight at both ends.

    InsteadAllow for movement with joints, cleats and slotted fastening.

  • MistakeChanging a board or fastener because it is close enough.

    InsteadInstall the tested assembly exactly, or get the change approved.

Summary and key terms

  • Every roof sheds water, resists wind, controls heat, air and vapour, carries loads, resists fire and lasts; failures are one of these.
  • Convert slopes between rise in 12, ratios, numbers in 100 and angles; roof area = plan area × pitch factor; a square is 100 ft².
  • Resistances add; heat loss = area × temperature difference ÷ total resistance; RSI × 5.678 = R.
  • Air leakage carries more moisture than diffusion; keep the vapour retarder warm; ventilate attics and protect eaves.
  • Know the membrane families and their compatibility problems.
  • Avoid galvanic couples, allow for thermal movement, drive fasteners deep enough, and attach for wind zones.
Pitch factor
The sloped length per unit of horizontal run; multiplies plan area to give roof area.
Square
A unit of roofing equal to 100 ft² of roof surface.
Dew point
The temperature at which air becomes saturated and water vapour starts to condense.
Equiviscous temperature
The asphalt temperature at which it has the right viscosity for application.
Galvanic corrosion
Corrosion of the less noble of two metals in contact with water present.
Long-term thermal resistance
A rating of foam insulation after accounting for ageing.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. What is the pitch factor for 8 in 12?

    Show answer

    √(64 + 144) ÷ 12 = √208 ÷ 12 = 1.202.

  2. Convert RSI 3.52 to R.

    Show answer

    3.52 × 5.678 = R-20.0.

  3. A plan area of 150 m² is roofed at 4 in 12. What is the roof area?

    Show answer

    150 × 1.054 = 158.1 m².

  4. Which metal should be uphill if copper and galvanized steel must share a roof?

    Show answer

    The galvanized steel, so runoff goes from it to the copper, not the reverse.

  5. Why does air leakage matter more than diffusion?

    Show answer

    Air carries far more moisture through gaps than vapour diffuses through materials.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz