ROOF-330 · Lesson 12 of 12 · 24 min

Case study: a reroofing bid

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

Hugo Maranda needed the Parkdale Arena wing re-roof price by the middle of November, because the city's capital budget requests for 2027 were due before the end of the month. On Monday, November 9, Glen spread the Parkdale file across the office table: the October 22 survey notes from Sabine and Rory, Ahmed's moisture survey report, the cores, Theo's drawings for the east coping that Hugo had already accepted, and the 1997 drawings from the city's archive. "This is the one that pays for the winter," Glen told Rory. "You did the survey. Now you're going to help me price it. On Wednesday night you check my takeoff, and on Friday it goes out the door." This lesson follows that bid from the scope to the price, using everything in the course. Every price in it is a sample for teaching.

The roof and the findings

The facts came from earlier visits and reports:

  • Building: the arena's one-storey wing of dressing rooms, offices and a skate shop, built in 1997, 7.6 m tall, with a steel deck on open-web steel joists.
  • Roof: 46.0 by 30.0 m, 1,380 m², with a parapet 300 mm high all round; four drains; six plumbing vents; two exhaust fan curbs and one rooftop unit curb.
  • Existing assembly: 1.14 mm EPDM, loose-laid and ballasted at about 51.2 kg/m², over two layers of 38 mm polyiso, loose-laid on the deck, with no vapour retarder.
  • Condition: membrane 29 years old; torn flashing and bridging along the east parapet, with leaks into the dressing rooms below; scoured ballast at the north-east corner; a clogged drain; about 300 m² of wet insulation, a little over a fifth of the roof, confirmed by five wet cores out of eight.
  • Already sold: a new prefinished steel coping on the east parapet, to be installed by Theo late in November, which the re-roof would have to keep.

Choosing the scope

Lessons 4 and 5 described the decision: the wet fifth of the roof ruled out a recover, the thin old insulation, missing vapour retarder and 29-year-old membrane made a partial tear-off poor value, so Glen priced a full tear-off. The new system he chose was one his maker's representative had already approved for similar buildings, and that met the wind and fire requirements:

From the deck up: a 15.9 mm gypsum thermal barrier board fastened to the steel deck; a self-adhered vapour retarder; two layers of 100 mm polyiso, the bottom layer fastened and the top layer adhered in low-rise foam; a 12.7 mm cover board adhered in foam; and an adhered 1.5 mm white TPO membrane. The assembly would be a CSA A123.21-tested assembly for the wind loads at the site, as ROOF-220 described, and the new insulation would bring the roof up to the energy levels in SB-10 for Hamilton's climate zone, as ROOF-310 described.

The new roof would be about 125 mm thicker than the old one. With the parapet only 300 mm high, the flashing height would drop below the minimum, so the scope included new wood blocking on all the parapet tops, raising them by 140 mm, with a new coping on the north, south and west sides and the new east coping removed and reinstalled. The scope also included new drain inserts with clamping rings, new pipe boots, new curb flashings, and crickets behind the wide curbs.

Glen listed what the bid did not include: structural repairs; deck replacement, priced instead at a unit price per square metre of deck if any was found rotted or rusted through; work on the rooftop units beyond lifting and resetting them, which the city's mechanical contractor would do; and any asbestos work, though the 1997 materials made that unlikely. A quick note in the file reminded him to confirm with the city's building department that raising the parapets with blocking needed a permit, and to allow for one.

The takeoff

Lesson 8 worked out the main quantities: 1,380 m² of roof, 152 m of perimeter, and 124 m² of parapet flashing membrane. The rest came from the survey notes and the drawings: four drains, six vents, three curbs, and 122 m of new coping on three sides with 30 m of east coping to reinstall. Waste allowances were 5 in 100 on insulation and boards and 10 in 100 on the vapour retarder and the field membrane. On Wednesday night, Rory checked every quantity against the sketch, found that Glen had counted the rooftop unit curb twice in his first draft, and initialled the sheet when the corrected count matched.

A roof plan of the Parkdale Arena wing, 46 by 30 m, with the parapet all round, four drains with crickets between them, six vents, two exhaust fan curbs and one rooftop unit curb, the wet areas from the moisture survey shaded at the north-east corner and along the east parapet, and the crane position and material landing area marked.
The Parkdale roof plan used for the takeoff.

Materials

Parkdale materials (sample prices, rounded to the dollar).
MaterialQuantitySample unit price (dollars)Amount (dollars)
Gypsum thermal barrier board, 15.9 mm1,449 m²9.5013,766
Self-adhered vapour retarder1,518 m²7.8011,840
Polyiso, two layers of 100 mm2,898 m²24.0069,552
Cover board, 12.7 mm1,449 m²11.0015,939
TPO 1.5 mm, field and flashings1,642 m²14.5023,809
Fasteners, plates, foam and bonding adhesives1,380 m²12.0016,560
Wood blocking on parapets152 m18.002,736
Prefinished steel coping, new (north, south, west)122 m48.005,856
Drain inserts and clamping rings4650.002,600
Pipe boots, curb flashings, sealants, accessories1 lot3,500.003,500
Materials total166,158

The material prices came from Ridgecap's supplier quotes for the week, and Glen marked the estimate valid for 60 days, because insulation prices had been moving.

Labour

Parkdale labour from Ridgecap's production rates (sample rates).
TaskQuantityProduction rateHours
Remove ballast, tear off to the deck1,380 m²0.12 h/m²165.6
Thermal barrier, vapour retarder, insulation, cover board1,380 m²0.18 h/m²248.4
Adhere TPO field sheets, weld seams1,380 m²0.10 h/m²138.0
Parapet flashings152 m0.60 h/m91.2
Drains44.0 h each16.0
Vents61.5 h each9.0
Curbs (2 exhaust fans, 1 rooftop unit)36.0 h each18.0
Parapet blocking152 m0.25 h/m38.0
Coping, new and reinstalled152 m0.30 h/m45.6
Total769.8

Worked problem

Labour cost

Ridgecap's sample blended burdened rate for a commercial crew is 78 dollars an hour. What is the labour cost of 769.8 hours, and how many crew-days is it for Dana's crew of eight on 8-hour days?

Show solution
  1. Labour cost = 769.8 × 78 = 60,044 dollars.
  2. Crew-days = 769.8 ÷ 64 = 12.0 days.

Answer: About twelve working days, which Dana would plan as three weeks with weather, as lesson 11 showed.

Equipment and other direct costs

Equipment and other direct costs (sample figures).
ItemAmount (dollars)
Crane, 3 days (ballast off, materials up, rooftop unit lift)7,200
Ballast stone to an aggregate recycler, 70.7 t1,768
Debris bins, 87,600
Guardrail and safety equipment rental4,500
Total21,068

The maker's warranty fee and the building permit, if one was needed, were added in Glen's final version once confirmed; this lesson leaves them out to keep the arithmetic clear.

Overhead, profit and the price

Worked problem

From direct cost to bid

Ridgecap's overhead for 2026 works out to 12 in 100 of direct cost, and Glen added profit at 8 in 100 of cost plus overhead. Find the direct cost, the price and the price per unit area.

Show solution
  1. Direct cost = 166,158 + 60,044 + 21,068 = 247,270 dollars.
  2. Overhead = 247,270 × 0.12 = 29,672 dollars; cost plus overhead = 276,942 dollars.
  3. Profit = 276,942 × 0.08 = 22,155 dollars.
  4. Price = 276,942 + 22,155 = 299,097 dollars.
  5. Per square metre = 299,097 ÷ 1,380 = 217 dollars.

Answer: A price of about 299,100 dollars, plus HST, or about 217 dollars a square metre. Overhead and profit together are about 17 in 100 of the price: a markup of about 21 in 100 on cost, as lesson 9 explained.

A horizontal bar dividing the Parkdale price into its parts: materials about 56 parts in 100, labour about 20, equipment and disposal about 7, overhead about 10 and profit about 7, with the dollar amounts labelled.
Where the Parkdale price goes (sample figures).

Checking the bid

Before the bid went out, Glen checked it the three ways lesson 9 described. The arithmetic and takeoff had been checked by Rory. The cost per unit area sat in the range of three similar tear-offs Ridgecap had done in the last two years. The scope matched Hugo's request and the survey, and the exclusions were written out. He also checked the risks: the unknown deck, covered by a unit price; the crane's access over the arena's parking lot, which needed the city's approval for the days it would be set up; the schedule, since the dressing rooms below could not be used on wet days during the tear-off; and the 60-day validity of the material prices.

The proposal

A bid is sent as a written proposal. Glen's for Parkdale ran four pages:

  • Scope: the system from the deck up, the parapet raising, the coping, drains, curbs, vents and crickets, the maker's warranty and Ridgecap's two-year workmanship warranty.
  • Price: a lump sum, plus HST, and a unit price for deck replacement.
  • Exclusions and assumptions: structural work, mechanical work beyond lifting units, asbestos work, permits if required, and the assumption of summer work with the arena wing in use.
  • Schedule: about three weeks, proposed for July 2027 when the arena's ice is out.
  • Conditions: price valid 60 days; payment terms; access and crane approvals by the city; daily close-in and protection of the dressing rooms.
  • Attachments: Ahmed's survey summary, a roof plan, and the system data sheets.

Glen e-mailed the proposal to Hugo on Friday, November 13, 2026, with a copy of the moisture survey and a one-page summary of why he recommended a full tear-off rather than a repair or a partial tear-off. Whether the city funds it in the 2027 capital budget, and whether it tenders the work publicly, will be decided early in 2027; if it goes ahead, the work is planned for July 2027. Meanwhile, Theo's east coping goes on later in November, and Nadine has added Parkdale to her spring 2027 inspection list.

The Parkdale bid used every lesson in this course: the inspection and the moisture survey to know the roof, the repair-or-replace and recover-or-tear-off decisions to choose the scope, the takeoff and estimate to price it, the warranty to protect the owner, and the crew plan to show it could be built in three weeks. That is the work of a journeyperson who can run a job, not just build one.

Public tenders

Many public owners, such as cities, school boards and hospitals, buy roofing through a public tender. The owner's consultant prepares drawings and a specification; the tender is advertised; contractors submit sealed bids on the owner's form by a set closing time, often with a bid bond or deposit and proof of insurance and safety programs; and the contract usually goes to the lowest bid that complies with the tender's requirements. Tenders are unforgiving: a bid that arrives a minute late, is missing a required form, or changes the tender's terms can be rejected however good its price. Glen keeps a checklist for every tender and has a second person check the forms before the bid is sealed.

If the city decides to tender the Parkdale work rather than award it from Glen's budget price, Martin or another consultant would probably write the specification, and Glen's proposal would become the owner's budget figure, not a bid. Ridgecap would then bid against other roofers on the consultant's documents. That is normal, and Glen does not resent it: a good budget price helps the owner set the right budget, and a contractor that helped with it understands the job better than anyone when the tender comes out.

Worked problem

Checking the bid against the budget

Suppose the city sets its budget at Glen's figure of 299,100 dollars and adds a contingency of 10 in 100 for unknowns. What is the city's budget line for the Parkdale roof?

Show solution
  1. Contingency = 299,100 × 0.10 = 29,910 dollars.
  2. Budget line = 299,100 + 29,910 = 329,010 dollars, plus HST.

Answer: The owner's contingency is the owner's, not the contractor's: it covers deck repairs at the unit price, permits and other unknowns. A realistic budget price, honestly built, is what lets the city fund the job properly the first time.

Common mistakes

  • MistakePricing a tear-off without knowing how much of the roof is wet.

    InsteadSurvey and core first; the findings decide the scope.

  • MistakeForgetting that new insulation raises the roof at the parapets.

    InsteadCheck flashing heights and price raising the parapets.

  • MistakeLeaving unknowns out of the price.

    InsteadCover them with unit prices, allowances or clear exclusions.

  • MistakeSending a bid without checking it.

    InsteadCheck the takeoff, the cost per unit against similar jobs, and the scope.

  • MistakeSending a price with no conditions.

    InsteadState validity, schedule, access, exclusions and payment terms.

Summary and key terms

  • The bid started from the findings: age, wet fraction, details, structure and what was already sold.
  • Wet insulation, thin old insulation, no vapour retarder and an old membrane led to a full tear-off.
  • New insulation raised the roof, so the parapets had to be raised and the copings reset.
  • Direct cost on the sample figures was about 247,000 dollars and the price about 299,000 dollars plus HST.
  • Risks were handled with a unit price for deck, written exclusions, conditions and a validity period.
  • The proposal gave scope, price, exclusions, schedule, conditions and the survey behind the recommendation.
Lump sum
A single fixed price for the whole scope of work.
Scope of work
The work a price includes, described in the proposal.
Validity period
How long a price stays open for acceptance.
Tender
A formal public request for bids, often used by cities and other public owners.
Proposal
The written offer that sets out scope, price, exclusions, schedule and conditions.
Capital budget request
An owner's request for funds for a large project in a coming year.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. Materials are 120,000, labour 50,000 and equipment 15,000 dollars. Overhead is 12 in 100 and profit 8 in 100. What is the price?

    Show answer

    185,000 × 1.12 = 207,200; × 1.08 = 223,776 dollars.

  2. A tear-off is estimated at 640 hours for a crew of eight on 8-hour days. How many working days?

    Show answer

    640 ÷ 64 = 10 days.

  3. A new roof is 125 mm thicker and the parapet is 300 mm above the old roof. How much flashing height is left without blocking?

    Show answer

    175 mm, below the usual 200 mm minimum.

  4. Why include a unit price for deck replacement?

    Show answer

    Nobody can know how much deck is damaged until the roof is off.

  5. Name four things the Parkdale proposal stated besides the price.

    Show answer

    Scope, exclusions, schedule, conditions, validity, attachments.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz