IRW-230 · Lesson 7 of 12 · 23 min

Openings, edges and fall protection on deck

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

The roof hatch at the Linwood Fire Station was a hole about 900 mm (3 ft) square in the roof framing, framed with small angles between two beams, right beside the stair. When Ilona's crew decked the Linwood roof from Monday, November 9 to Friday, November 13, they laid the deck straight across it. On the morning of Thursday, November 12, the roofer's carpenter arrived with the hatch curb, and only then did Ilona mark out the opening on the deck, cut it with a saw, and stand back while the curb was set and fastened in the same hour. "A hole in a roof is the easiest way to fall through a building," she said at the last deck night two days earlier. "The best hole is the one that isn't cut yet."

Falls are the leading cause of death in the ironworking trade, and deck work puts workers at open edges all day: the building perimeter, the leading edge where new sheets are being laid, the edges of openings for stairs, shafts and equipment, and the gaps around columns. This lesson covers how openings in deck are handled, the requirements for covers, protection at edges and around columns, and the fall protection systems decking crews use, including the controlled decking zone allowed in the United States and why Crossbeam does not use it.

Deck over openings first

The safest way to handle a hole in a floor or roof is to deck over it and cut it out only when whatever fills it, the curb, the equipment, the stair or the shaft wall, is ready to go in. Until then the deck is a continuous surface, and nobody can fall through. Where the framing for a small opening sits below the top of the beams, the steel can often be turned down or the opening framed so that the deck runs straight across.

Crossbeam's rule, written into its erection plans in Ontario, is to deck over every opening that is small enough to deck over, and to cut it out only immediately before it is filled, or to cover it at once with a secured cover. Large openings, such as elevator shafts and stairwells, are protected with guardrails as soon as the deck around them is laid.

Three stages of a roof opening. First, the framed opening with deck laid continuously over it and the outline of the future hole marked. Second, the hole cut out and a cover laid over it, overlapping the edges, fastened down and marked. Third, the equipment curb set in the opening. A separate sketch shows a large shaft opening protected by a guardrail with top rail, mid-rail and toe board.
Deck over openings first; cover or fill them as soon as they are cut.

Covers

Where a hole must be open before it is filled, it is covered. A cover is not a sheet of plywood thrown over a hole. It must be strong enough for everything that may be on it at once, fixed so that it cannot slide or blow away, big enough to overlap the opening on all sides, and marked so that nobody lifts it without knowing what is underneath.

O. Reg. 213/91 allows an opening in a floor, roof or other work surface to be protected either by a guardrail system or by a cover that completely covers the opening, is securely fastened, is adequately identified as covering an opening, and is made of material capable of supporting all loads to which it may be subjected, including a live load of at least 2.4 kN/m². A cover may be removed temporarily for work at the opening only if the workers are protected and warning signs are posted with the word DANGER.

Worked problem

Sizing a cover

A roof drain opening is 900 mm by 900 mm. Crossbeam's covers lap at least 150 mm past every edge. What size is the cover, and what load must it carry at 2.4 kN/m² over its area?

Show solution
  1. Cover size = 900 + 2 × 150 = 1,200 mm each way.
  2. Area = 1.2 × 1.2 = 1.44 m².
  3. Load = 2.4 × 1.44 ≈ 3.46 kN, at least, and more if heavier loads may be placed on it.

Answer: A 1,200 mm square cover able to carry at least 3.46 kN. Crossbeam uses 19 mm plywood with cleats underneath so it cannot slide, screwed to the deck, and spray-painted with the word DANGER and HOLE on top.

Gaps around columns

Deck rarely fits tightly around columns. The gap where the deck stops at a column flange may be large enough for a foot, a tool or a bolt bag to go through, and objects falling through gaps strike workers below. These gaps are closed with wire mesh, plywood or sheet metal fixed to the deck, strong enough to stop a fall and to stop objects falling through, before the deck crew moves on.

Ontario's general rules on openings and on protecting workers from falling objects apply to these gaps, and Crossbeam's plan treats any gap a foot could go through as an opening to be covered.

Perimeter protection

As soon as a floor is decked, its open perimeter is protected. On steel frames, the usual method is perimeter cables, wire rope strung between the columns at guardrail height, with a mid-rail, installed as soon as the deck at that level is down.

O. Reg. 213/91 requires workers exposed to a fall of 3 m or more, or to a fall from other dangerous heights the regulation lists, to be protected, with guardrails as the first choice where they are practicable. Crossbeam's perimeter cables meet the guardrail requirements for height, strength and mid-rails, and its workers hold Ontario's Working at Heights training.

Fall protection for decking crews

The decking crew works where the perimeter is not yet protected and at the leading edge of the deck. Crossbeam protects them with personal fall arrest: full-body harnesses and self-retracting lifelines anchored to horizontal lifelines on the beams or girders, or to beam clamps behind the work. Because the leading edge is a sharp steel edge and the anchor is often at foot level, the lifelines used there must be rated for leading-edge use (Class 2 or leading-edge SRLs, as IRW-110 covered), and the fall clearance below the deck must be checked.

  • The horizontal lifeline or anchor line is installed by the raising gang or the deck crew before decking starts, to the engineer's or manufacturer's design.
  • Every worker on the deck is tied off at all times where there is no guardrail, under Crossbeam's 100 in 100 tie-off rule above 1.8 m (6 ft).
  • Workers do not stand on unfastened sheets to spread the next ones, and they do not reach out over the leading edge to guide a bundle.
  • Temporary roof anchors screwed or welded to the deck are used only if they are rated, installed as their maker requires and approved for the deck thickness and fastening.

The controlled decking zone

US readers will hear about the controlled decking zone, a US federal rule that lets decking crews at the leading edge work without conventional fall protection in a marked zone between certain heights, with strict limits. There is no equivalent in Ontario, where decking crews above 3 m must be protected by guardrails, travel restraint or fall arrest like any other worker. Crossbeam does not use controlled decking zones on any of its jobs, in either country.

Worked problem

Unsecured deck in a zone

Crossbeam's Canadian deck crews do not work in controlled decking zones, but the company limits how much unfastened deck may be on the steel at once. Its rule is no more than one bundle's worth spread ahead of the support fasteners. With 30 sheets of 5.484 m² each, how much deck may be spread but not fully fastened?

Show solution
  1. Area = 30 × 5.484 ≈ 164.5 m².
  2. Even that deck is held by at least two fasteners per sheet as it is laid, under Crossbeam's rule that every sheet is secured on placement.

Answer: About 165 m², and never loose: the support pattern follows close behind.

Protecting the people below

Deck work drops things: banding, screws, cut-offs, studs and ferrules, tools. The areas below active deck work are controlled, with barricades and signs, and nobody works directly below the deck crew. Tools are tethered where practical, small parts are kept in buckets and bags, and cut-offs are collected as they are made. At openings, toe boards on guardrails and covers that stop objects as well as feet do the same job.

Rescue

A worker who falls at a leading edge and is held by an SRL is left hanging beside or below the deck. As IRW-110 covered, suspension in a harness becomes dangerous within minutes, and every decking job has a rescue plan before work starts, usually a boom lift that can reach every part of the deck edge, or a rescue system on the lifeline. Crossbeam's target is to reach a suspended worker within six minutes.

Edges that change during the day

Deck edges move. The leading edge advances with every sheet, an opening appears when a hole is cut, and an edge that was protected in the morning may be open in the afternoon when a guardrail is moved to land a bundle. The foreperson walks the deck at the start of each shift and after every change, and the crew treats any new edge as unprotected until guarded. On Linwood, Ilona's crew moved a section of perimeter cable twice during the week to let the crane land bundles at the east wall, and each time the cable was replaced before the crew stepped back to that edge.

Fall clearance at the leading edge

A worker who falls over the leading edge on a self-retracting lifeline anchored at foot level falls farther than one anchored overhead. The line must pay out from the anchor to the edge before it starts to arrest, the worker swings below the edge, and the lifeline's deceleration distance and the harness stretch add to the drop. Leading-edge SRLs state the clearance they need below the deck edge for a given setback from the anchor, and the deck crew checks that there is that much clear space below, free of beams, equipment or a lower floor. On a single-storey warehouse roof with a high clear height, clearance is rarely a problem; on a multi-storey building with floors about 4.3 m apart, it can be.

Swing is the other leading-edge hazard. A worker who falls at a point well to the side of the anchor swings like a pendulum along the edge and can strike a column or a beam. Anchors are kept roughly in line with the work, and the deck crew moves its anchors or uses a horizontal lifeline so that no worker works far to the side of the anchor point.

Guardrails around large openings

Elevator shafts, stairwells and large equipment openings are too big to deck over. They are protected with guardrails as soon as the deck around them is laid, with a top rail, a mid-rail and a toe board to stop material being kicked into the opening. When a trade must work at the opening, such as an elevator installer or the stair erector, a section of guardrail may be removed only under a written plan, with the workers protected by fall arrest and the area controlled, and the guardrail is replaced as soon as the work stops.

Materials near edges

Material stacked close to an open edge can fall, and a worker reaching for it can follow it. Crossbeam keeps bundles, tools and stacked material back from all open edges and openings by at least the distance its erection plan sets, never stacks material against perimeter cables or guardrails, and secures anything light enough to blow off. Deck banding, cut-offs and empty boxes are cleared from the deck as the crew works.

Weather and edges

Wind, rain, frost and snow make edges more dangerous. Wet or frosted deck is slippery, wind can push a worker off balance at an edge, and snow hides openings and the edges of covers. Crossbeam's wind limits for decking apply to edge work, and in winter the deck is cleared of snow and checked for covers and openings before anyone works on it. On the morning of Friday, November 13, at Linwood, a hard frost had left the roof deck slick, and Ilona's crew waited until the sun had melted it before going back to the east edge to finish the perimeter welds.

Training

Every worker on a deck crew is trained for the work. On both sides of the border, Crossbeam's deck workers complete its fall protection training and the leading-edge SRL and anchor training for the equipment they use, and its competent person inspects the fall protection equipment and the horizontal lifelines before use. New workers, like Shay on his first days with the deck crew at Ashcroft, work beside an experienced hand who checks their tie-off and their footing at the edge until the foreperson is satisfied.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeCutting openings in the deck as soon as it is laid.

    InsteadDeck over openings and cut them only when they are about to be filled, or cover them at once.

  • MistakeLaying loose plywood over a hole.

    InsteadUse a cover strong enough, fastened down and marked.

  • MistakeLeaving gaps around columns.

    InsteadClose them with mesh, plywood or sheet metal strong enough to stop a fall and falling objects.

  • MistakeWorking at the leading edge tied to a non-rated anchor or SRL.

    InsteadUse leading-edge-rated SRLs on approved anchors and check clearance.

  • MistakeAssuming a guardrail is still there.

    InsteadWalk the edges after every change and treat new edges as unprotected.

Summary and key terms

  • Openings are decked over and cut out only when they are about to be filled, or covered at once.
  • Covers in Ontario completely cover the opening, are securely fastened, are identified, and carry at least 2.4 kN/m².
  • Gaps around columns are closed, and perimeters are protected as soon as the deck is down.
  • Decking crews use fall arrest with leading-edge-rated SRLs and are tied off at all times.
  • Ontario has no controlled decking zone, and Crossbeam does not use them.
  • Areas below deck work are controlled, and a rescue plan is in place before work starts.
Opening cover
A secured, marked cover strong enough for the loads on an opening.
Perimeter cable
Wire rope strung at guardrail height around an open floor edge.
Leading edge
The advancing edge of new deck.
Controlled decking zone
A US federal provision allowing limited leading-edge decking without conventional fall protection.
Horizontal lifeline
An engineered line between anchors to which workers tie off.
Toe board
A low barrier at the bottom of a guardrail that stops objects falling off an edge.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. An opening is 600 mm by 600 mm and the cover laps 150 mm past each edge. What size is the cover?

    Show answer

    600 + 300 = 900 mm square.

  2. What live load must an Ontario opening cover carry at least?

    Show answer

    2.4 kN/m².

  3. What is the area of that cover, and the minimum load at 2.4 kN/m²?

    Show answer

    0.81 m²; 2.4 × 0.81 ≈ 1.94 kN.

  4. Does Ontario allow controlled decking zones?

    Show answer

    No; decking crews above 3 m are protected by guardrails, travel restraint or fall arrest.

  5. When is a hole for a roof curb cut?

    Show answer

    Immediately before the curb is set, or covered at once.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz