INS-230 · Lesson 4 of 12 · 20 min

Asbestos regulations in Canada

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

At the fourth session, on Wednesday, October 7, Mei put a single slide on the screen with four boxes: federal, provincial, owner and employer. "Every rule we follow about asbestos comes from one of these," she said. "The federal government decides whether asbestos can be sold. The province decides how workers are protected. The owner has to tell us what is in the building. And the employer, which is Coldstream, has to make sure none of you breathes it." This lesson sets out the main laws that govern asbestos for an insulator working in Ontario, what they require, and how they fit together.

You do not need to memorize section numbers. You do need to know which rules apply, what they expect of you and of the people around you, and where to look when a question comes up. Your safety coordinator and supervisor will have the current text.

Who makes the rules in Canada

In Canada, responsibility is divided between the federal government and the provinces. The federal government controls products and trade: the Prohibition of Asbestos and Products Containing Asbestos Regulations, which came into force on December 30, 2018, prohibit the import, sale, use and manufacture of asbestos and of products containing asbestos, with a few narrow exceptions. The federal government also sets occupational health and safety rules for federally regulated workplaces, such as ports, shipping and some utilities, and federal rules govern the transport of asbestos waste.

Most workplaces, including construction projects, fall under provincial law. In Ontario that is the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA) and its regulations, enforced by inspectors of the Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development. Other provinces have similar rules with different details, so a worker who moves between provinces must learn the local version.

A diagram of the rules that govern asbestos work, arranged in levels: national rules on products and trade at the top, worker protection rules in the middle, and the duties of the owner, the employer and the worker at the bottom, with arrows showing how information flows from the owner to contractors and workers.
How the main asbestos rules fit together.

Ontario's asbestos regulation

Asbestos is a designated substance under the OHSA. For construction projects, buildings and repair operations, the detailed rules are in Ontario Regulation 278/05, Designated Substance: Asbestos on Construction Projects and in Buildings and Repair Operations. Its main elements are:

  • Definitions. A material is asbestos-containing material (ACM) if it contains 0.5 parts in 100 or more asbestos by dry weight. Friable material is material that can be crumbled, pulverized or powdered by hand pressure when dry.
  • Types of operation. All work that may disturb ACM is classified as a Type 1, Type 2 or Type 3 operation, from lowest to highest risk. The type decides the precautions, the training, the respirators and whether the Ministry must be notified (lesson 7).
  • Owner's duties. Before a project, an owner must find out whether ACM may be handled, disturbed or removed, and must tell the contractors. In buildings that contain ACM, the owner must keep a record of where it is, keep it up to date, inform occupants and workers, and inspect the material periodically (lesson 5).
  • Procedures and equipment. The regulation sets out the measures for each type of operation: wetting, enclosures, ventilation, protective clothing, respirators, decontamination, waste handling and clean-up.
  • Ministry notice. Before a Type 3 operation, and before certain larger Type 2 glove bag removals, the employer or constructor must notify a Ministry inspector orally and in writing.
  • Training. Every worker in a Type 1, 2 or 3 operation must be instructed by a competent person. Workers and supervisors in Type 3 operations must also complete a Ministry-approved asbestos abatement training program and hold the matching certificate.
  • Clearance and records. Type 3 work areas must pass a clearance air test: no sample may exceed 0.01 fibres per cubic centimetre. Employers must report on workers in Type 2 and Type 3 operations to the Provincial Physician.

Ontario's occupational exposure limit for asbestos is 0.1 fibres per cubic centimetre of air, measured as an eight-hour time-weighted average. As lesson 3 explained, this is a legal maximum, not a safe level.

Other Ontario rules that matter

The OHSA itself contains duties that apply to asbestos as to every hazard. Section 30 requires the owner of a project to prepare a list of the designated substances present at the project site and to include it in the tender documents, so that contractors know what they are bidding on. Contractors must in turn give the list to their subcontractors. Clause 25(2)(h) requires every employer to take every precaution reasonable in the circumstances for the protection of a worker.

Designated substances in workplaces other than construction projects and buildings, such as some manufacturing plants, are covered by Ontario Regulation 490/09. Asbestos waste must be packaged, labelled, transported and disposed of under Ontario's environmental rules for waste management, at sites approved to receive it. WHMIS rules apply to hazardous products used at work, such as encapsulants and cleaning products used in abatement.

Building owners who are also employers, such as a hospital, must protect their own maintenance staff under the same regulation. That is why hospitals and plants usually have an asbestos management program, with a designated person who keeps the record of asbestos in the building and controls who may work on it.

What the rules expect of you

The rules put most of the duties on owners, constructors and employers, but workers have duties too, and the rules only work if everyone does their part.

  • Work in the way the training and procedures require, and use the protective equipment provided.
  • Report hazards, including suspect material that is not on the survey, to your supervisor at once.
  • Do not disturb material you are not trained and authorized to work on.
  • Do not remove or defeat controls, signs, barriers or enclosures.
  • Attend the training, fit testing and, where required, medical examinations.

Ontario workers also have the right to refuse work they believe is likely to endanger them, under section 43 of the OHSA. Lesson 6 explains how that right works and how it relates to simply stopping work on suspect material.

Time-weighted averages

Exposure limits are written as time-weighted averages (TWAs). A TWA averages the concentration over a working day, weighting each concentration by the time it lasted. The formula is:

\[\text{TWA} = \frac{C_1 t_1 + C_2 t_2 + \dots + C_n t_n}{8\ \text{h}}\]

where each C is a concentration measured over a period of t hours. Any time not sampled counts as zero only if there was truly no exposure during it; otherwise it must be estimated or sampled. Consultants and safety coordinators do these calculations, but an insulator who understands them can read an air monitoring report and ask the right questions.

Worked problem

Checking a day's exposure against the limit

During a Type 2 removal by an abatement contractor near the Coldstream crew's work area, a consultant's personal air sampling on one abatement worker gave 0.05 f/cc for 2 hours, 0.15 f/cc for 3 hours and 0.02 f/cc for 3 hours. What was the worker's eight-hour TWA, and how does it compare with Ontario's limit of 0.1 f/cc?

Show solution
  1. Add the products: 0.05 × 2 = 0.10; 0.15 × 3 = 0.45; 0.02 × 3 = 0.06.
  2. Total = 0.10 + 0.45 + 0.06 = 0.61 f/cc·h.
  3. TWA = 0.61 ÷ 8 = 0.076 f/cc.
  4. Compare: 0.076 is below 0.1, but the three-hour period at 0.15 f/cc was above the limit, which shows why respirators were required during the removal.

Answer: The TWA was about 0.076 f/cc, below the limit of 0.1 f/cc. The worker was protected by a respirator, which is required for this work whatever the TWA turns out to be.

Air sampling for asbestos is normally analysed by phase contrast microscopy, which counts all fibres of a certain size on a filter. It does not tell asbestos fibres from other fibres, so results can overstate asbestos exposure when other fibres are present. Where that matters, transmission electron microscopy can identify asbestos fibres specifically.

Inspections and enforcement

Ministry inspectors visit construction projects, often without notice, and may also come when a Type 3 notice is received, when a complaint is made or after an incident. An inspector can ask to see the designated substance list and report, training records, respirator fit test records and the procedures for asbestos work, and can interview workers. If the rules are not being followed, the inspector can issue orders to comply, including orders to stop work until a hazard is corrected. Contraventions can lead to prosecution and substantial fines for corporations and for individuals, including supervisors.

Ontario's OHSA also gives the joint health and safety committee, or the health and safety representative on smaller sites, a role in asbestos work: members inspect the workplace, receive information about hazards, and must be involved when a worker refuses unsafe work. On a large construction project, the committee may ask to see the designated substance report and the asbestos procedures.

Where the rules can differ

Not every job in Canada falls under Ontario's rules. Other provinces have their own regulations with different details, such as different classifications of asbestos work or different training requirements, so a worker who travels for a job must learn the local version. Some workplaces, such as certain federally regulated marine, port and interprovincial transport operations, fall under the Canada Labour Code and its occupational health and safety regulations, which have their own asbestos provisions. Coldstream's winter work on laid-up Great Lakes freighters can raise this question, and Mei confirms which rules apply before each such job.

What this means for a contractor's paperwork

For an insulation contractor, the rules translate into a set of documents that should be in place before work starts in any older building or plant:

  • The owner's designated substance list and report for the work area, read and understood by the foreperson.
  • A written procedure for what the crew will do if it finds suspect material, including who to call.
  • Training records showing each worker's asbestos awareness training and any other hazardous materials training.
  • Respirator program records: health screening, training and fit tests for each worker.
  • Information from the abatement contractor about any asbestos work scheduled near the crew.
  • Copies of clearance results for any area the crew will enter after abatement.

Raj Sandhu keeps a checklist of these documents for every Coldstream job in an older building. "If one of them is missing," he says, "we don't start until it isn't."

How the rules developed

Ontario's asbestos rules grew out of decades of evidence and public pressure. In the early 1980s, a provincial Royal Commission examined the health and safety issues arising from the use of asbestos in Ontario, and its 1984 report shaped the regulations that followed. A regulation specifically for asbestos on construction projects and in buildings and repair operations was made in the mid-1980s, and Ontario Regulation 278/05 replaced it in 2005 with the current system of Type 1, 2 and 3 operations, training requirements and clearance testing. The regulation has been amended since, most recently in 2019.

The federal ban came later. Canada was once one of the world's largest producers of asbestos, and the last mines closed only in 2011. The federal government announced a comprehensive ban in 2016, and the Prohibition of Asbestos and Products Containing Asbestos Regulations followed in 2018.

Knowing this history helps explain the rules' structure. Each requirement, from the survey before work to the clearance after it, answers a way in which workers were harmed in the past: by not knowing asbestos was present, by working in uncontrolled dust, by carrying it home, or by returning to areas that had not been cleaned.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeThinking the ban means asbestos rules no longer apply to existing buildings.

    InsteadThe product bans stop new use; the worker protection rules apply whenever existing asbestos may be disturbed.

  • MistakeTreating the limit as an amount you are allowed to breathe.

    InsteadKeep exposure as low as possible; the limit is a legal maximum, not a safe level.

  • MistakeAssuming the owner's list covers everything.

    InsteadSurveys and lists can miss hidden material; report anything that does not match.

  • MistakeLeaving the rules to the abatement contractor.

    InsteadEvery employer and worker on the site has duties, including stopping and reporting.

  • MistakeAveraging a high short-term result into a TWA and ignoring it.

    InsteadHigh short periods matter; they show when protection is essential.

Summary and key terms

  • In Canada, federal rules ban asbestos products, and provincial rules, in Ontario the OHSA and O. Reg. 278/05, protect workers.
  • In Ontario, ACM is material with 0.5 parts in 100 or more asbestos by dry weight; the exposure limit is 0.1 f/cc as an eight-hour TWA.
  • Work is classed as Type 1, 2 or 3, which sets the precautions, training, respirators and notice requirements.
  • Owners must identify asbestos and tell contractors; section 30 of the OHSA requires a list of designated substances in tender documents.
  • Type 3 work needs certified workers and supervisors, notice to the Ministry and a clearance air test of 0.01 f/cc.
  • Exposure limits are time-weighted averages; high short periods still matter.
Designated substance
A substance named under the OHSA for which special regulations apply, such as asbestos, silica and lead.
Asbestos-containing material (ACM)
In Ontario, material with 0.5 parts in 100 or more asbestos by dry weight.
Type 1, 2 and 3 operations
Ontario's classes of asbestos work, from lowest to highest risk.
Clearance air test
Air sampling after asbestos work to confirm the area is clean; in Ontario no sample may exceed 0.01 f/cc.
Time-weighted average (TWA)
An average concentration over a working day, weighted by the time spent at each level.
Phase contrast microscopy (PCM)
A method that counts all fibres of a set size on an air sample filter.
Asbestos work report
A report on each worker in Type 2 or 3 operations sent to Ontario's Provincial Physician.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. Which level of government bans asbestos products in Canada, and which protects workers on Ontario construction projects?

    Show answer

    The federal government bans the products; the province, through the OHSA and O. Reg. 278/05, protects workers.

  2. What asbestos content makes a material ACM in Ontario?

    Show answer

    0.5 parts in 100 or more by dry weight.

  3. What does section 30 of the OHSA require of a project owner?

    Show answer

    A list of designated substances present at the project, included in the tender documents.

  4. A worker's sampling shows 0.12 f/cc for 4 hours and 0.03 f/cc for 4 hours. What is the TWA?

    Show answer

    (0.48 + 0.12) ÷ 8 = 0.075 f/cc.

  5. What clearance level must every air sample meet after a Type 3 operation?

    Show answer

    No more than 0.01 fibres per cubic centimetre.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz