APP-110 · Lesson 11 of 12 · 27 min

Recycling and disposing of old appliances

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

On Monday, November 9, the back of the shop held five old appliances that Penfold had taken away from customers the week before: a chest freezer from 1992, a refrigerator from 2009, a refrigerator from 2021 with a cracked inner liner, a top-load washer and an electric range. A truck from Quarrington Metal Recovery, the scrap and appliance recycler Penfold uses, was due at two o'clock. "Before anything goes on that truck," Dee told Kiran, "we make it safe and we take out what doesn't belong in a scrap pile. Three of these have refrigerant in them, and one has a little mercury. That's the law and it's the right thing to do."

When a customer replaces an appliance, someone has to deal with the old one. Most of an appliance is steel, copper, aluminum, glass and plastic that can be recycled, but some appliances contain substances that harm the ozone layer or the climate, or are toxic, and must be removed before the rest is shredded or landfilled. Appliance technicians are often the last trained people to handle an old unit. This lesson covers what is inside an old appliance that needs care, the rules on refrigerant before disposal, and how Penfold handles haul-away units.

What is inside an old appliance

Materials in old appliances that need care at disposal.
MaterialWhere it is foundWhy it needs care
RefrigerantSealed systems of refrigerators, freezers, air conditioners, dehumidifiers, heat pump dryersOlder refrigerants such as CFC-12 and HCFC-22 deplete the ozone layer; HFCs such as R-134a are strong greenhouse gases; hydrocarbons are flammable
Foam blowing agentsInsulation foam in refrigerator and freezer wallsOlder foams were blown with CFC-11 or HCFC-141b, which are released when the foam is shredded
Compressor oilRefrigerator and freezer compressorsContains dissolved refrigerant; must not be dumped
MercuryTilt switches for lid or door lamps in some older chest freezers, washers and rangesToxic; switches are removed whole and kept as hazardous waste
PCB capacitorsSome motor capacitors in very old appliances, generally made before 1979Toxic and persistent; handled as hazardous waste
Circuit boards and electronicsControl boards, displays, inverter drivesContain lead and other metals; recycled as electronic waste
Glass, metals, plasticsMost of the applianceRecyclable once the hazardous parts are out

Refrigerants are the main concern. Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) such as CFC-12 were used in household refrigerators until the early to mid 1990s, when they were phased out under the Montreal Protocol because they destroy stratospheric ozone. They were replaced by HFCs, mostly R-134a, which do not harm the ozone layer but are powerful greenhouse gases. Most refrigerators built in recent years use isobutane (R-600a), a hydrocarbon with a very low global warming potential, which is flammable.

Worked problem

The climate effect of one refrigerator

Global warming potential (GWP) compares a gas with carbon dioxide over 100 years. The 2009 refrigerator holds 150 g of R-134a, GWP about 1,430. The 1992 chest freezer holds 250 g of CFC-12, GWP about 10,900. What is each charge equivalent to in carbon dioxide if it escapes?

Show solution
  1. R-134a: 0.150 kg × 1,430 ≈ 215 kg of carbon dioxide equivalent.
  2. CFC-12: 0.250 kg × 10,900 = 2,725 kg of carbon dioxide equivalent.

Answer: About 215 kg and about 2,700 kg. The old freezer's small charge has the warming effect of several tonnes of carbon dioxide, on top of its damage to the ozone layer. Recovering it is worth far more than the scrap value of the freezer.

The rules on refrigerant at disposal

In Ontario, Ontario Regulation 463/10 under the Environmental Protection Act controls ozone-depleting substances and other halocarbons, including the CFCs, HCFCs and HFCs used in refrigerators and air conditioners. Only a person holding an Ozone Depletion Prevention (ODP) certificate may remove, handle or dispose of these refrigerants. Refrigeration equipment that is being disposed of must have its refrigerant recovered by a certified person first, and the regulation requires a notice on the emptied equipment showing that the refrigerant has been removed, with the name of the employer of the person who removed it. Hydrocarbon refrigerants such as R-600a are not halocarbons and are not covered by the regulation, but they are flammable and the manufacturer's and recycler's procedures for them must be followed. Kiran does not have his ODP card yet, so he can watch and help, but Dee does the recovery.

A flow chart of what happens to a haul-away appliance. Units with refrigerant go to recovery by a certified technician, then to labelling or a signed statement, then to the recycler. All units have doors removed and hazardous parts such as mercury switches and old capacitors taken out, then go to the scrap metal recycler. Refrigerant goes to a recovery cylinder and then to a reclaimer.
What happens to an old appliance at Penfold before it leaves the shop.

Worked problem

How much refrigerant must be recovered?

Dee recovers the 2009 refrigerator's R-134a with Penfold's recovery machine. Its plate charge is 150 g, and after recovery the cylinder scale shows 141 g recovered. What fraction of the plate charge is that, and what goes on the refrigerator?

Show solution
  1. Fraction recovered: 141 ÷ 150 = 0.94, or 94 in 100.
  2. Some refrigerant stays dissolved in the compressor oil, so recovery of the full plate charge is not expected.

Answer: 94 in 100 of the plate charge. Dee attaches the empty notice to the refrigerator with Penfold's name, as the regulation requires, and records the recovery in the company's refrigerant log.

Recovered refrigerant goes into a recovery cylinder dedicated to that refrigerant, never mixed with other types. Penfold returns full cylinders to its refrigerant supplier, which sends the refrigerant for reclaiming to new-product purity or for destruction. CFC-12 recovered from the old freezer goes into its own cylinder.

Making old appliances safe

Refrigerant is not the only job. Before an old unit leaves Penfold, a technician:

  • Removes the doors and lids from refrigerators, freezers and other airtight appliances, or the door gaskets and latches, so that a child playing in a scrap yard or a back lane cannot be trapped inside. Many municipalities require this, and Penfold does it on every unit, even those going straight onto a recycler's truck.
  • Cuts off the power cord, so that nobody plugs in a unit that has been declared unsafe.
  • Removes any mercury tilt switch whole, without breaking it, and stores it in a sealed container for household hazardous waste collection.
  • Checks old motor capacitors for PCB markings on very old units, and sets aside any that may contain PCBs as hazardous waste.
  • Drains water from washers and dishwashers, and removes any food from refrigerators.
  • Removes glass shelves that could shatter in handling, and bins them with the glass recycling.

On the 1992 chest freezer, Kiran found the lid lamp switch: a small glass capsule with a bead of mercury inside a plastic housing. He unscrewed the housing, lifted the switch out whole and put it in the labelled mercury container on the shop shelf. Dee recovered the freezer's CFC-12 into its own cylinder. The newest refrigerator, with R-600a, was handled by Dee following the recycler's procedure for hydrocarbon units, away from any ignition source.

Where old appliances go

Several routes take old appliances in Hamilton. Retailers and installers such as Penfold often take the old unit away when a new one is delivered. The City of Hamilton accepts appliances and scrap metal at its waste and recycling facilities, under its own rules for units that contain refrigerant. Scrap metal recyclers such as Quarrington take appliances by the truckload. Whatever the route, a unit with a halocarbon refrigerant must have the refrigerant recovered by a certified person and the empty notice attached before it is scrapped.

Penfold's haul-away charge covers this work. Customers sometimes ask why taking away an old refrigerator costs money when it is full of scrap metal. Dee's answer is the refrigerant, the doors, the hazardous parts, the truck and the time.

Worked problem

Planning a load

Quarrington's truck takes up to 2,000 kg of appliances. Today's load is the chest freezer at 60 kg, two refrigerators at 85 kg and 75 kg, the washer at 55 kg and the range at 65 kg. What is the total, and how much capacity is left?

Show solution
  1. Total: 60 + 85 + 75 + 55 + 65 = 340 kg.
  2. Capacity left: 2,000 − 340 = 1,660 kg.

Answer: 340 kg, leaving 1,660 kg. Quarrington makes several shop stops on the same run, so Penfold's small load fits easily.

Repair, reuse and the customer's choice

Disposal is the last step in an appliance's life, and an appliance technician often helps decide when that step comes. A repair that keeps a sound appliance running for years is usually better for the customer and for the environment than replacing it. But an old refrigerator with a failing compressor and poor efficiency may cost more to run and repair than a new one. Technicians give customers honest information about the repair, its cost and the appliance's condition, and let them decide; APP-410 covers repair-or-replace decisions. When an appliance is replaced, the technician makes sure the old one is disposed of safely.

Foam insulation and modern recycling

Refrigerant is not the only ozone-depleting or climate-warming gas in an old refrigerator. The polyurethane foam insulation in its walls and door was made with a blowing agent, a gas that forms the bubbles and stays trapped in them for the life of the refrigerator. Older refrigerators were blown with CFC-11, later ones with HCFC-141b and then HFCs, and newer ones with hydrocarbons such as cyclopentane. A typical old refrigerator holds more blowing agent in its foam than refrigerant in its sealed system. When the cabinet is shredded in the open, most of that gas escapes.

The best appliance recyclers process refrigerators in sealed plants that recover the blowing agent as the foam is shredded, then separate the steel, aluminum, copper, plastic and foam for recycling. Not every recycler does this; many simply shred the cabinet once the refrigerant is out. Penfold chose Quarrington partly because it sends refrigerator cabinets to a plant that recovers foam gases. Customers who ask what happens to their old refrigerator deserve an honest answer.

Other appliances with refrigerant

Refrigerators and freezers are not the only household appliances with sealed systems. Window and portable air conditioners, dehumidifiers, water coolers, wine coolers, some ice makers and heat pump dryers all contain refrigerant, often R-410A or R-32 in air conditioners and R-134a, R-600a or R-290 in the others. The same rules apply to them: the refrigerant is recovered by a certified person before disposal, and units with flammable refrigerants are handled away from ignition sources. Heat pump dryers are new enough that some recyclers do not expect refrigerant in a dryer, so Penfold marks them clearly.

Records

Penfold keeps a refrigerant log: for every unit recovered, the date, the appliance, its refrigerant type and plate charge, the amount recovered, the technician and the cylinder it went into. The log shows that the company handled refrigerant properly, tracks how much is in each cylinder, and matches the paperwork that goes to the recycler and the refrigerant supplier. When Kiran helped Dee with the three refrigerated units on November 9, he filled in the log while she ran the recovery machine.

Worked problem

Filling a recovery cylinder

Penfold's R-134a recovery cylinder can safely hold up to 12 kg of refrigerant; recovery cylinders must never be filled past their safe limit, usually 80 in 100 of their liquid capacity, because liquid expands as it warms. The log shows 10.9 kg already in it. Today's recovery added 141 g. How much room is left?

Show solution
  1. Today's recovery: 141 g = 0.141 kg.
  2. New total: 10.9 + 0.141 ≈ 11.04 kg.
  3. Room left: 12 − 11.04 ≈ 0.96 kg.

Answer: About 0.96 kg, enough for a few more refrigerators. The cylinder will soon be full and go back to the supplier; a scale, not a guess, decides when.

Explaining it to the customer

Customers often ask whether they can leave an old refrigerator at the curb or take it to a scrap yard themselves. The honest answer depends on the local rules, but the technician can explain what has to happen to it: the refrigerant recovered by a certified person, the doors removed, and the unit taken somewhere that accepts refrigerated appliances. Many customers choose Penfold's haul-away once they understand the work involved, and those who do not at least know how to do it safely.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeVenting refrigerant from an old refrigerator before scrapping it.

    InsteadOnly a person with an ODP card may handle halocarbon refrigerants; recover it and attach the empty notice.

  • MistakeMixing different refrigerants in one recovery cylinder.

    InsteadUse a cylinder dedicated to each refrigerant.

  • MistakeLeaving the doors on an old refrigerator in the yard.

    InsteadRemove doors or lids, or their gaskets and latches, so that nobody can be trapped.

  • MistakeBreaking a mercury switch to get it out.

    InsteadRemove it whole and keep it sealed for hazardous waste collection.

  • MistakeTreating an R-600a refrigerator like any other scrap.

    InsteadIt is flammable; follow the manufacturer's and recycler's procedures away from ignition sources.

  • MistakeTelling a customer haul-away should be free because of the scrap.

    InsteadExplain the refrigerant recovery, hazardous parts, transport and time it pays for.

Summary and key terms

  • Old appliances contain refrigerants, foam blowing agents, oil, sometimes mercury and PCBs, and electronics that need care.
  • CFCs deplete ozone and HFCs warm the climate; even small charges have a large carbon dioxide equivalent.
  • In Ontario, only ODP-certified people may recover halocarbon refrigerants, and emptied equipment carries a notice before disposal.
  • Remove doors, cut cords, take out mercury switches and suspect capacitors, and drain water before scrapping.
  • Recovered refrigerant goes in dedicated cylinders for reclaiming or destruction.
  • Repair keeps sound appliances in service; safe disposal is the technician's last job on an old one.
CFC
Chlorofluorocarbon; an older refrigerant such as CFC-12 that depletes the ozone layer.
HFC
Hydrofluorocarbon; a refrigerant such as R-134a that does not harm ozone but is a strong greenhouse gas.
Global warming potential
A gas's warming effect compared with the same mass of carbon dioxide over 100 years.
Recovery
Removing refrigerant from a system into a cylinder without releasing it.
Reclaiming
Processing recovered refrigerant to new-product purity.
Blowing agent
The gas used to make foam insulation; older foams used CFC-11.
Final processor
The last person in the disposal chain, such as a scrap recycler or landfill.
Mercury tilt switch
A switch with a bead of mercury in a capsule, found in some older lamps and lids.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. What is the carbon dioxide equivalent of 150 g of R-134a with a GWP of 1,430?

    Show answer

    About 215 kg.

  2. Why are refrigerator doors removed before disposal?

    Show answer

    So that a child cannot be trapped inside.

  3. What is done with a mercury tilt switch?

    Show answer

    It is removed whole and kept sealed for hazardous waste.

  4. Why is refrigerant never mixed in one recovery cylinder?

    Show answer

    Mixed refrigerant cannot be reclaimed easily and must be destroyed.

  5. Who may recover halocarbon refrigerant in Ontario?

    Show answer

    A person with an ODP certificate.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz