PWR-420 · Lesson 5 of 12 · 25 min
Environmental permits and reporting
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
On November 1, Lorne had written Cantwell's October environmental summary, which recorded a contained diesel weep at the generator fuel filter and nothing else of note (PWR-240). Pilar had read dozens of those summaries without asking where their headings came from. Grazyna handed her the plant's permit binder. "Every line in that summary answers a condition in one of these documents," she said. "A Second Class engineer has to know which ones, and what happens if a line is wrong."
This lesson describes the environmental approvals a combustion plant needs, the emissions it must estimate, monitor and report, and the inventories and greenhouse gas programs that collect the data in each country. It works through annual emission estimates for Cantwell, a potential-to-emit calculation, and a threshold check for each reporting program, and it closes with spills, records and the plant's role when an environmental officer visits.
What needs a permit
Environmental approvals control what a plant may release to air, water and land, and how. For a combustion plant the main concern is air: the boilers, turbines, engines and emergency generators that burn fuel, and minor sources such as tanks and cooling towers. Noise is often regulated with air. Water discharges were covered in lesson 4. Waste rules govern the storage, transport and disposal of used oil, chemical containers, spent resin, ash and other wastes, and some wastes need registration and manifests.
In Ohio, as in most states, new or modified air sources need a state permit to install and operate (PTIO) from Ohio EPA under the state's rules (OAC Chapter 3745-31), unless an exemption or a permit by rule applies, as it may for some small boilers and emergency generators. A larger facility whose emissions exceed the federal major source thresholds also needs a Title V operating permit (OAC Chapter 3745-77), which gathers every applicable requirement for the facility into one federally enforceable document with monitoring, recordkeeping, semiannual monitoring reports and an annual compliance certification signed by a responsible official. Permits also apply the federal New Source Performance Standards (NSPS) and National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) that fit each unit.
Emission standards for boilers
Two kinds of limits apply to boilers. Equipment standards set emission rates for the units themselves: NSPS Subpart Dc applies to steam generating units of 10 to 100 million Btu/h heat input built or modified after June 1989, and for gas-fired units mainly requires records of fuel use, while Subpart Db applies above 100 million Btu/h with NOx limits. For hazardous air pollutants, the Boiler MACT rule (40 CFR 63 Subpart DDDDD) applies to boilers at major sources of HAP, and for gas-fired units mainly requires periodic tune-ups and an energy assessment; the area source rule (Subpart JJJJJJ) does not cover gas-fired boilers. Ambient standards are the National Ambient Air Quality Standards, which the state protects through permit conditions and, for larger projects, modeling.
Cantwell's three steam boilers each have a heat input of about 33.6 million Btu/h at full fire. Its two hot water boilers are smaller. Its standby diesel generator is an emergency engine with limits on non-emergency running hours, and its fuel oil tank is a minor source of volatile organic compounds.
Estimating annual emissions
Most small and medium plants do not measure emissions continuously. They estimate them from fuel use and emission factors, which are average emission rates per unit of fuel or heat input, taken from a recent stack test on the plant's own units where one exists, from the manufacturer's data, or from published factors such as the US EPA's AP-42 compilation. Larger units, and units with emission limits that require it, use continuous emission monitoring systems (CEMS) for NOx, CO, O₂ and sometimes flow, with daily calibration checks and periodic audits (PWR-330).
Worked problem
Cantwell's NOx and CO₂ for 2025
In 2025 Cantwell burned about 360,000 million Btu (MMBtu) of natural gas. Its 2024 stack tests gave an average of about 0.090 lb of NOx per MMBtu of heat input. The CO₂ factor for natural gas is about 53.06 kg per MMBtu. Estimate the year's NOx and CO₂.
Show solution
- \[\text{NO}_x = 360{,}000 \times 0.090 = 32{,}400 \text{ lb} = 16.2 \text{ tons}\]
- \[\text{CO}_2 = 360{,}000 \times 53.06 \text{ kg} \approx 19{,}100 \text{ metric tons}\]
- Both factors are applied to the total heat input for the year.
Answer: Cantwell emitted about 16.2 tons of NOx and 19,100 metric tons of CO₂ in 2025, matching the figure in Lorne's annual summary (PWR-240). The NOx estimate is only as good as the factor: a boiler whose burner drifts out of tune, as boiler 2's rising stack temperature suggested this fall (PWR-330), may be emitting at a different rate from the one tested.
Potential to emit
Permits and federal programs are written around what the equipment could emit, not only what it did last year. The potential to emit (PTE) assumes every unit runs at full capacity all year unless an enforceable permit limit restricts it, and it decides whether a facility is a major source. In an area that meets the air quality standards, a facility that could emit 100 tons a year or more of a criteria pollutant, or 10 tons of one HAP or 25 tons of combined HAPs, is a major source and needs a Title V permit.
Worked problem
Cantwell's potential to emit NOx
Estimate the potential NOx from Cantwell's three steam boilers, each with 33.6 MMBtu/h heat input at full fire, for 8,760 hours a year at 0.090 lb/MMBtu. Is the plant a major source for NOx?
Show solution
- \[Q_{max} = 3 \times 33.6 \times 8{,}760 \approx 883{,}000 \text{ MMBtu}\]
- \[\text{NO}_x = 883{,}000 \times 0.090 \div 2{,}000 \approx 39.7 \text{ tons per year}\]
Answer: The potential is about 40 tons a year, two and a half times the actual and well below the 100-ton major source threshold even with the hot water boilers and the generator added. Cantwell therefore holds a state PTIO rather than a Title V permit. Keswold, with a 45 MW gas turbine and duct burners, is a Title V source and is also covered by the federal acid rain and cross-state programs for electric generating units.
Pollutant inventories
The Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA) requires facilities to report hazardous chemicals they store above threshold quantities on annual Tier II inventory reports to the state, local emergency planning committee and fire department, by March 1 for the previous year. Facilities in listed industries, including electric generating plants that burn coal or oil, with ten or more full-time employees, must also report releases of listed toxic chemicals above their thresholds to the Toxics Release Inventory (TRI) by July 1. Ohio also requires an annual fee emission report from permitted sources.
Cantwell files a Tier II report each year for the chemicals it stores above the thresholds, including its fuel oil, diesel, sulfuric acid in the station batteries and treatment chemicals. Neither plant is in a TRI industry: Cantwell is a heating plant, and the electric utility category covers only generating plants that burn coal or oil, while Keswold burns natural gas.
Greenhouse gas reporting
The US EPA's Greenhouse Gas Reporting Program (40 CFR Part 98) has required facilities in listed source categories, and stationary combustion facilities emitting 25,000 metric tons CO₂e or more a year, to report annually. In September 2025 EPA proposed to end reporting for nearly all source categories, and that proposal was still not final in November 2026. In October 2026 EPA issued an interim final rule moving the deadline for 2025 data from October 30, 2026 to March 10, 2027; that extension was challenged in court, and the deadline for 2026 data remained March 31, 2027. Several states have meanwhile expanded their own reporting rules. A plant engineer has to check the current status each year rather than rely on last year's practice.
Worked problem
Which programs apply?
Using the 2025 figures, does Cantwell have to report to EPA's greenhouse gas program as the rule stood in 2026?
Show solution
- Cantwell emitted about 19,100 metric tons CO₂ (plus small amounts of methane and nitrous oxide).
- Stationary combustion threshold: 25,000 metric tons CO₂e.
- 19,100 < 25,000, so Cantwell is below the threshold.
Answer: Cantwell does not report; its emissions are below the 25,000-ton threshold. Keswold, as an electric generating unit, is in a listed source category and has reported every year, and its staff have followed each change in the deadlines closely.
Spills and unplanned releases
Federal rules require immediate notification to the National Response Center of releases of hazardous substances above their reportable quantities under CERCLA and of extremely hazardous substances under EPCRA, and of oil discharges that cause a sheen on water under the Clean Water Act. Ohio requires spills of oil or hazardous materials that may reach waters of the state, or exceed reportable quantities, to be reported to Ohio EPA's emergency response hotline, generally within 30 minutes of discovery, and the local emergency planning committee and fire department must also be told of reportable releases. Facilities that store more than threshold quantities of oil above ground must also have a Spill Prevention, Control and Countermeasure (SPCC) plan under 40 CFR Part 112. A contained weep inside a containment, like the generator filter on November 1, is not a reportable release, but the plant records it and fixes the cause.
Records, reports and inspections
Every approval requires records, and most environmental enforcement begins with records that are missing or inconsistent. A plant should be able to produce, quickly: the current approval and its amendments; fuel use by unit and month; operating hours of limited units such as the emergency generator; stack test and CEMS reports; maintenance and tune-up records required by the approval or the federal rules; complaint logs; spill records; and copies of every report submitted, with its date and signature. Many plants keep a compliance calendar listing each obligation, its due date and its owner, so that nothing depends on one person's memory.
When an environmental officer visits, the shift engineer is often the first person they meet. The plant should have a short procedure: greet the officer, check identification, call the chief engineer or the person responsible for environmental compliance, accompany the officer, answer factual questions accurately, provide requested documents and keep a list of what was given, take duplicate samples or photographs if the officer takes them, and never guess. Officers in both countries have broad powers of entry and inspection, and obstructing them, or giving them false information, is an offense in its own right.
"The environmental side is where small plants get caught out," Grazyna said. "Not because they pollute, but because nobody updated the emission summary when we replaced the FD fan motor, or nobody logged the generator's test hours. Your monthly summary is our proof that we did what the approval says."
Stack testing
Emission factors from a plant's own units come from stack tests, in which a qualified testing company measures the concentration of each pollutant and the gas flow in the stack while the unit runs at specified loads, using reference methods published by the environmental agency. The approval or permit may require a test at startup and periodically after, and the plant usually wants its own tests after major burner work so that its emission estimates stay honest. Before a test, the plant agrees a test plan with the agency, notifies it of the date so that an observer can attend, and makes sure the unit is in its normal condition: a boiler tuned specially for the test produces a number that does not represent the year.
A stack test measures concentration, usually in parts per million by volume corrected to a reference oxygen level such as 3 in 100 for gas-fired boilers, and the testing company converts it to a mass rate using the measured flow. The correction to a reference oxygen level matters, because diluting the flue gas with extra air lowers the measured concentration without lowering the mass emitted. A concentration limit is therefore always stated with its reference oxygen level.
Emergency generators and minor sources
Standby diesel engines are covered by federal rules for stationary engines, which limit non-emergency running for maintenance and testing to a set number of hours a year, and by the state permit or exemption. The plant must log every run with its date, duration and reason, because those hours are the basis of compliance. Cantwell's monthly generator test, about 140 kW for an hour (PWR-230), uses only a small part of the allowance, but an extended outage like September 20 is also recorded, and the year's total is checked against the limit in the annual summary.
Minor sources still need attention. The fuel oil tank's vents, the cooling tower's drift, the chemical storage area and the ash or waste skip are all sources the approval may name, and odor and noise complaints from neighbors are a common reason for an environmental officer's visit. A plant's complaint log, with the date, the nature of the complaint, what was found and what was done, is often the first thing an officer asks for.
Records of complaints, stack tests and generator hours are kept for the period the approval or permit requires, commonly several years, and they must be retrievable: a record that exists only on a retired employee's computer does not exist as far as an inspector is concerned.
Common mistakes
MistakeUsing last year's actual emissions to decide which rules apply.
InsteadUse the potential to emit, limited only by enforceable conditions.
MistakeRelying on an old emission factor after a burner change.
InsteadRetest or update the factor when equipment or tuning changes.
MistakeAssuming an emissions program's rules are the same as last year.
InsteadCheck thresholds, deadlines and proposals every year.
MistakeTreating a small contained leak as not worth recording.
InsteadRecord every release, contained or not, and fix the cause.
MistakeLeaving reporting deadlines to one person's memory.
InsteadKeep a compliance calendar with owners and due dates.
MistakeGuessing in answer to an environmental officer's question.
InsteadAnswer factually, get the responsible person, and record what was provided.
Summary and key terms
- Ohio plants need a PTIO, and major sources a Title V permit; NSPS Dc and, at HAP major sources, Boiler MACT apply to boilers.
- Annual emissions are estimated from fuel use and emission factors or measured by CEMS; potential to emit assumes full capacity unless enforceably limited.
- EPCRA requires Tier II chemical inventories by March 1 and TRI reports from listed industries by July 1.
- EPA's GHG program applies to combustion sources at 25,000 metric tons, but its future and deadlines were under revision in 2026.
- Releases above reportable quantities go to the National Response Center and Ohio EPA; oil storage may need an SPCC plan.
- Records and a compliance calendar are the plant's proof of compliance; inspections need a prepared, factual response.
- Title V permit
- A federal operating permit for major sources that gathers all applicable air requirements.
- PTIO
- Ohio EPA's permit to install and operate an air contaminant source.
- Emission factor
- An average emission rate per unit of fuel or heat input.
- Potential to emit
- The maximum emissions a source could produce at full capacity, limited only by enforceable conditions.
- Continuous emission monitoring system
- Analyzers that measure stack emissions continuously.
- Tier II report
- The annual EPCRA inventory of hazardous chemicals stored above thresholds.
- SPCC plan
- A plan to prevent and respond to oil discharges, required for larger oil storage.
- Compliance calendar
- A schedule of every environmental obligation, its due date and its owner.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
A plant burns 200,000 MMBtu a year at 0.08 lb NOx per MMBtu. Annual NOx?
Show answer
16,000 lb, or 8.0 tons.
Does a combustion facility emitting 20,000 metric tons CO₂e report to EPA's program?
Show answer
No; the threshold is 25,000 metric tons.
A 20 MMBtu/h boiler runs 8,760 h at 0.09 lb/MMBtu. Potential NOx?
Show answer
About 7.9 tons per year.
By what date is the EPCRA Tier II report due?
Show answer
March 1, for the previous year.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.