INS-430 · Lesson 3 of 12 · 21 min

Review: safety and hazardous materials

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

The second session, on Sunday, October 25, started with a photo. Mei Zhou had lent Bernie a picture from an incident file: an apprentice on a mobile scaffold, reaching out past the guardrail to band a jacket, one wheel unlocked. Nobody had been hurt. "Find six things wrong," Bernie said. Erik found five. Devon found the sixth, the missing toe board, and was pleased for the rest of the afternoon.

Safety questions appear in every area of the exam, not only in area A. A question about duct liner can turn on silica dust from the cutting, and a question about a cold line in a machinery room can turn on ammonia. This lesson reviews the safety and hazardous materials content of INS-110 and INS-230, together with the common occupational skills of area A: tools, organizing work and mentoring. As in every review lesson, the point is to bring back what was taught, in the form the exam asks for it.

The rules and who must follow them

In Ontario, the Occupational Health and Safety Act sets the duties of employers, supervisors and workers, and the construction regulation, O. Reg. 213/91, sets the detailed rules for construction projects. The worker's duties are short and testable: work in compliance with the Act and regulations, use the protective equipment the employer requires, report hazards and contraventions to the supervisor, and do not remove or disable a protective device. Workers also have three rights that come up in exam questions: the right to know about hazards, the right to participate (through the joint health and safety committee or representative), and the right to refuse unsafe work, with a set procedure for doing so.

Every job starts with a hazard assessment. On Coldstream jobs that is the hazard sheet Bernie fills in before work starts and reviews whenever the work changes. Her saying from INS-110 is the summary: "If you didn't put it on the hazard sheet, it isn't controlled." The controls on the sheet follow the hierarchy of controls: eliminate the hazard, substitute something less hazardous, use engineering controls, use administrative controls, and only then rely on personal protective equipment. Exam questions about the best way to control a hazard almost always want the highest level that is practical.

An inverted triangle of the hierarchy of controls from most to least effective: elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls and personal protective equipment, each with an insulation example beside it.
The hierarchy of controls with insulation examples.

Working at heights and access

Falls are the leading cause of serious injury on construction sites, and insulators spend much of their day at height. In Ontario, a worker must be protected by guardrails or, where that is not practical, by a fall protection system when exposed to a fall of more than 3 m, and at any height over operating machinery, water or hazardous substances. Workers who use fall protection on construction projects must have completed an approved Working at Heights training program; the training is valid for three years. Travel restraint, which keeps the worker from reaching the edge, is preferred over fall arrest, which stops a fall already happening.

The fall arrest calculation from INS-110 is a favourite exam item: the clearance below the anchor must take in the free fall, the deceleration distance of the lanyard, the stretch of the harness and the worker's height below the D-ring, plus a safety margin. A rescue plan must be in place before anyone works in fall arrest, because a worker hanging in a harness can lose consciousness within minutes as blood pools in the legs.

Access equipment has its own short rules. Ladders are set at about one out for every four up, extend 900 mm (3 ft) above a landing, and are used with three points of contact; a ladder is for access and short work, not for a day of jacketing. Rolling scaffolds have their wheels locked, guardrails and toe boards on the platform, and nobody on them when they move. Elevating work platforms are used only by trained operators, with a harness and lanyard clipped to the anchor in a boom-type platform.

Heat, cold and the work environment

Insulators work beside hot pipes and cold ones. A bare steam line at 185 °C (366 °F) burns instantly; even a surface at about 60 °C (140 °F) can burn skin in a few seconds of contact, which is why personal protection insulation is designed to keep surfaces below that level (INS-120, INS-410). Cold surfaces below about −20 °C (−4 °F) can freeze skin to metal. Gloves, sleeves and face protection are matched to the job.

Heat stress is a real risk in boiler houses and on summer roofs. The controls are water, rest in a cooler place, acclimatization for new workers, and a buddy who watches for confusion or a stop in sweating, which are signs of heat stroke, a medical emergency. Noise is another environmental hazard, reviewed with the acoustics material in lesson 9.

Confined spaces such as tanks, vessels, pits and some tunnels need a permit system when they hold or could hold a hazardous atmosphere or other serious hazards. The Kellerton condensate tunnel in INS-410 is a permit confined space at that plant. The key facts for the exam are that the atmosphere is tested before entry and monitored during it, that an attendant stays outside, and that a rescue plan exists before anyone goes in. Hot work such as welding pins or cutting with a torch needs a hot work permit, a fire watch and a cleared area.

Hazardous products: labels and safety data sheets

Under WHMIS 2015, every hazardous product on site comes with a supplier label and a 16-section safety data sheet. Workers must be trained in WHMIS and in the specific products they use. Insulators meet adhesives, mastics, coatings, solvents, foam components and fibrous products. The safety data sheet tells you the hazards, the protective equipment, first aid, safe storage and what to do in a spill.

Asbestos: recognize, stop, report

Asbestos is the hazard that shaped this trade. Insulators of earlier generations installed it, and many died of it: mesothelioma, asbestosis and lung cancer, diseases that appear twenty to fifty years after exposure. Bernie's uncle Gerard, whose story INS-230 told, was one of them. Any pipe covering, block, cement or fitting insulation installed before the 1980s is suspect until the owner's survey or a sample says otherwise. Bernie's line from INS-230 is the rule: "Old mud is guilty until the survey says it isn't."

In Ontario, O. Reg. 278/05 sorts asbestos work into three types by risk. Type 1 work is low risk, such as installing or removing non-friable asbestos-containing material without breaking it up. Type 2 work is medium risk, such as removing a small amount of friable material, including a single fitting cover removed with a glove bag. Type 3 work is high risk, such as removing larger amounts of friable material, and needs an enclosure, negative air pressure and a decontamination facility. Type 3 work and some Type 2 work must be done by workers who hold the asbestos abatement worker certificate, and supervised by holders of the supervisor certificate. Before work starts, the owner must give the constructor and bidders a report listing the asbestos-containing materials in the work area.

Coldstream's own rule is stricter than the law in one way: its crews do no asbestos removal of any kind. Walt's line from INS-230 says it: "We insulate. We don't abate." When Devon found an unlabelled cement cover on a tee at Kellerton (INS-110) and when Tessa found the abandoned aircell line in Mountview's corridor C (INS-230), they did the same four things: stop, keep others away, tell the foreperson, and leave it for the owner's abatement contractor. Mei's summary on the whiteboard was: "Didn't know. Not on the sheet. Stopped. Told others. Called."

Area F of the exam goes further than Coldstream's work, into preparing for and carrying out abatement. Study it from the standard's task list and your in-school material, aiming to recognize the types of work, the controls each needs and who is allowed to do it. The step-by-step procedures are taught in the certified abatement training, which is the place to learn them.

Worked problem

Is the exposure over the limit?

Air sampling during a repair shows a worker exposed to 0.15 fibres per cubic centimetre for 3 hours and 0.02 for the other 5 hours of the shift. What is the eight-hour time-weighted average, and is it over the 0.1 limit?

Show solution
  1. TWA = (0.15 × 3 + 0.02 × 5) ÷ 8.
  2. = (0.45 + 0.10) ÷ 8 = 0.55 ÷ 8 = 0.069 f/cc.
  3. 0.069 is below 0.1, but the three hours at 0.15 show that the work itself needs controls: the average hides a high-exposure task.

Answer: About 0.069 f/cc, below the limit, but the task needs better controls.

Silica, fibres and lead

Crystalline silica comes from cutting, drilling and grinding concrete, masonry and some board products, such as when anchor holes are drilled for firestopping or supports. It causes silicosis and lung cancer. The controls taught in INS-230 are water or shrouded tools with a HEPA vacuum, local exhaust, and respirators where those are not enough, following Ontario's guideline for silica on construction projects. Man-made mineral fibres in glass and mineral wool irritate the skin, eyes and throat; loose clothing, gloves, eye protection and a dust mask for cutting are the usual controls. Refractory ceramic fibres are more hazardous and are handled with tighter controls. Lead is found in old paint on tanks and steel, as on the Kellerton engine room tank in INS-230, and is controlled by avoiding disturbance, by trained workers for any removal, and by hygiene: wash before eating, and leave work clothes at work.

Respirators

A respirator works only if it fits, is the right type and is maintained. Ontario practice follows CSA Z94.4: a written program, medical clearance where needed, training, and a fit test before first use and at least every two years, or whenever the face or the respirator changes. A tight-fitting respirator cannot seal over a beard or stubble, which is why Devon failed his first fit test in INS-230 and passed after shaving, and why Wendell, who wears a beard, uses a loose-fitting hood with a powered air supply.

The assigned protection factor of a half-face air-purifying respirator is 10: used correctly, it keeps the concentration inside at no more than one tenth of the concentration outside. A quantitative fit test measures the actual ratio for one person; Tessa's 12,000 particles a cubic centimetre outside against 80 inside is a fit factor of 150, a pass for a half mask, which needs at least 100.

Area A: tools, work organization and mentoring

The rest of area A is everyday practice. Hand and power tools are inspected before use, guarded, and used for their purpose; a grinder with the guard removed or the wrong disc for its speed is a classic exam distractor. Material is stored dry and off the floor, and staged so that it reaches the work in the right order. Drawings, specifications and the hazard sheet are read before the work starts. And journeypersons are expected to mentor: to demonstrate, watch the apprentice do it, give feedback and check again. Bernie's way of putting it is that mentoring is part of the job, not a favour.

Reporting incidents and first aid

Every injury, near miss and dangerous occurrence is reported to the supervisor at once, however small it seems. In Ontario, a critical injury or a death must be reported to the Ministry of Labour, Immigration, Training and Skills Development immediately, and the scene must not be disturbed except to help the injured or keep others safe; the employer must also report lost-time injuries to the WSIB. Every site has first aid kits and trained first aiders, and every worker should know where they are, where the eyewash station is, and how to call for help on that site, which on a plant site may be a plant number rather than 911.

Near misses deserve the same attention as injuries. The scaffold photo that opened this session was a near miss, and the reason Mei kept it on file was that nobody had been hurt: the lesson was free.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeChoosing personal protective equipment as the first control.

    InsteadWork down the hierarchy: eliminate, substitute and engineer the hazard out before relying on PPE.

  • MistakeUsing fall arrest when travel restraint is possible.

    InsteadKeep the worker from reaching the edge whenever that is practical.

  • MistakeDisturbing an old fitting cover to check what it is.

    InsteadStop, keep others away, tell the foreperson and leave it for the owner's survey and abatement contractor.

  • MistakeTrusting an eight-hour average alone.

    InsteadLook at the task exposures too; a short high-exposure task needs its own controls.

  • MistakeWearing a tight-fitting respirator over stubble.

    InsteadShave, or use a loose-fitting powered hood; a tight mask cannot seal over hair.

Summary and key terms

  • Every job starts with a hazard assessment, and controls follow the hierarchy from elimination to PPE.
  • Fall protection is required above 3 m in Ontario, with Working at Heights training valid for three years; travel restraint is preferred over fall arrest.
  • Surfaces at about 60 °C (140 °F) can burn skin in seconds; confined spaces and hot work need permits.
  • O. Reg. 278/05 sorts asbestos work into Types 1, 2 and 3; certified workers do the higher-risk work. Coldstream crews do no removal.
  • Respirators need a program, training and fit testing; a half mask has a protection factor of 10.
Hierarchy of controls
The order of hazard controls from most to least effective: elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative, PPE.
Travel restraint
A system that keeps a worker from reaching an edge where a fall could happen.
Fall arrest
A system that stops a fall that has already started.
Permit confined space
A confined space that needs a written entry permit because of serious hazards.
Time-weighted average
An exposure averaged over a shift, usually eight hours.
Assigned protection factor
The level of protection a correctly used respirator type is expected to give.
Fit factor
The measured ratio of contaminant outside a respirator to inside it during a fit test.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. What is the first step in controlling a hazard?

    Show answer

    Try to eliminate it; personal protective equipment comes last.

  2. Above what fall height does Ontario require guardrails or fall protection?

    Show answer

    3 m.

  3. You find an old, unlabelled cement cover on a tee. What do you do?

    Show answer

    Stop, keep others away, tell the foreperson, and leave it for the owner's survey and abatement contractor.

  4. A worker is at 0.12 f/cc for 4 h and 0.03 for 4 h. What is the TWA?

    Show answer

    (0.48 + 0.12) ÷ 8 = 0.075 f/cc.

  5. What protection factor does a half-face air-purifying respirator have?

    Show answer

    10.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz