PWR-410 · Lesson 12 of 12 · 35 min
Second class problem practice
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
The last session of the term was a rehearsal. Grazyna had set Pilar a practice paper of nine problems drawn from the eleven lessons, eight calculations and one essay question,, to be done in three and a half hours, with the formulas from memory and a calculator. Okonkwo sat the first two problems with her for practice of his own. Afterwards Grazyna marked the paper in red, not for the answers, which were mostly right, but for the way the answers were set out. "Whoever marks your work, an examiner or the engineer who checks your calculation for a capital project, has a pile of others to get through," she said. "Make it easy for them to give you the marks."
This lesson describes the examinations and credentials at this level, explains how to plan study and how to answer calculation, essay and multiple-choice questions, and works through a practice paper covering the course.
The examinations
Ohio's licenses stop at stationary steam engineer, which Pilar already holds, so the next step for her is a national credential. The National Institute for the Uniform Licensing of Power Engineers (NIULPE), based in Pittsburgh, certifies power engineers by grade, and its Power Engineer 2nd Class syllabus groups 60 topics in six areas: code calculations and legislation; thermodynamics and metallurgy; boilers and water treatment; prime movers; combustion and plant systems; and electricity and refrigeration. NIULPE recommends that candidates complete a recognized power engineering course covering the syllabus, and its examination arrangements and experience requirements are set by NIULPE itself, so candidates confirm them directly before applying. Some employers, and some states and cities with graded licenses, recognize such credentials; Massachusetts, for example, licenses engineers from fourth class up to first class.
For Pilar, the credential mattered less as a license than as evidence of knowledge: Grazyna was preparing her to serve as assistant chief, and the second class syllabus covers what an assistant chief needs, from code calculations to plant economics.
Canadian provinces examine the same second class content under the syllabus of the Standardization of Power Engineer Examinations Committee (SOPEEC), in six papers, and Canadian textbooks written for that syllabus are widely used for study in the United States as well.
| Syllabus area | Main subjects (NIULPE 2nd Class and SOPEEC Second Class) |
|---|---|
| Code calculations and legislation | Code calculations for boilers and pressure vessels, legislation, plant management, applied mechanics |
| Thermodynamics and metallurgy | Heat transfer, gas and steam thermodynamics, cycles, metallurgy, testing of materials |
| Boilers and water treatment | Boiler design and operation, pumps, water treatment |
| Prime movers | Steam and gas turbines, condensers, engines, lubrication, piping, drawing |
| Combustion and plant systems | Fuel and steam systems, control and instrumentation, combustion, environmental control |
| Electricity and refrigeration | AC and DC machines, transformers, protection, compression, refrigeration |
Planning the work
At Second Class, most candidates study part-time while working shifts, over a year or more. A plan that works has three parts for each subject: first study, reading the material and working the examples until each step makes sense; problem practice, solving many problems without looking at the solutions; and review, returning to the subject weeks later and solving problems again under time. Pilar kept a single binder of formulas, each with its units and a one-line note of when it applies, and a list of her own mistakes, which Grazyna said was worth more than any textbook.
Problem practice must include mixed problems, because in the examination nothing tells the candidate which lesson a problem came from. The paper below mixes them deliberately.
Answering calculation and essay questions
A calculation answer should show, in order: what is given and what is required; a sketch where it helps, such as a T-s diagram, a free-body diagram or a flow schematic; the formula in symbols before numbers are substituted; the substitution with units; the result with units and a sensible number of figures; and a brief check, such as whether a quality is between zero and one or an efficiency below the Carnot limit. Marks are given for method, so a correct method with an arithmetic slip earns most of them, while a bare number that is wrong earns none.
Essay questions on operation and equipment are marked for content and organization. A good answer begins with a direct statement, then gives the reasons or steps in a logical order, often numbered, with a labeled sketch, and ends with any safety or regulatory point that applies. It does not pad. Five complete answers are worth more than seven partial ones, so candidates should budget their time, roughly 40 minutes a question on a three-and-a-half-hour paper with five to answer, and move on when the time is up.
Multiple-choice papers test breadth. Read the stem carefully, especially words such as *not*, *least* or *most likely*; work numerical questions out rather than guessing from the options; eliminate options that are clearly wrong; and answer every question, since a blank earns nothing.
A practice paper
The problems below are the paper Grazyna set. Steam properties are from IAPWS-IF97, as throughout the course.
Worked problem
Problem 1: an ideal reheat cycle
Steam enters the high-pressure turbine at 1,200 psia and 900 °F, expands to 230 psia, is reheated to 900 °F and expands to a condenser at 1.2 psia. Find the ideal cycle efficiency and the exhaust quality.
Show solution
- h₁ = 1,440.9 Btu/lb, s₁ = 1.5882. At 230 psia, s = 1.5882: h₂ = 1,248.7 Btu/lb (470 °F, superheated).
- h₃ = 1,476.2 Btu/lb, s₃ = 1.7899. At 1.2 psia: x₄ = 0.905, h₄ = 1,010.3 Btu/lb. Pump: w_p = 3.6 Btu/lb, h_fw = 79.5 Btu/lb.
- \[w_t = (1{,}440.9 - 1{,}248.7) + (1{,}476.2 - 1{,}010.3) = 658.1 \text{ Btu/lb}\]
- \[q_{in} = (1{,}440.9 - 79.5) + (1{,}476.2 - 1{,}248.7) = 1{,}588.9 \text{ Btu/lb}, \qquad \eta = \frac{658.1 - 3.6}{1{,}588.9} = 0.412\]
Answer: η = 0.412, x = 0.905. Check: below the Carnot limit of 1 − 567.4 ÷ 1,359.7 = 0.583.
Worked problem
Problem 2: a regenerative gas turbine
A gas turbine has a pressure ratio of 8, air in at 59 °F, turbine inlet at 2,012 °F, η_c = 0.85 and η_t = 0.88. Find the simple-cycle efficiency, and the efficiency with a regenerator of effectiveness 0.75 (c_p = 0.240 Btu/lb·°F, k = 1.4).
Show solution
- \[T_2 = 554.1\ ^\circ\text{F}, \qquad T_4 = 1{,}037.7\ ^\circ\text{F}\]
- \[w_c = 118.8, \quad w_t = 233.8, \quad w_{net} = 115.0 \text{ Btu/lb}, \quad \eta = \frac{115.0}{0.240 \times (2{,}012 - 554.1)} = 0.329\]
- \[T_x = 554.1 + 0.75 \times (1{,}037.7 - 554.1) = 916.8\ ^\circ\text{F}, \quad q_{in} = 262.9 \text{ Btu/lb}, \quad \eta = \frac{115.0}{262.9} = 0.438\]
Answer: 0.329 simple, 0.438 with the regenerator.
Worked problem
Problem 3: sizing a counterflow exchanger
Hot water at 23,800 lb/h is cooled from 194 °F to 122 °F by cold water at 31,700 lb/h entering at 68 °F, in counterflow (c_p = 1.0 Btu/lb·°F). With U = 264 Btu/h·ft²·°F, find the duty, the cold outlet temperature, the LMTD and the area.
Show solution
- \[Q = 23{,}800 \times 72 = 1{,}713{,}600 \text{ Btu/h}, \qquad T_{c,out} = 68 + \frac{1{,}713{,}600}{31{,}700} = 122.1\ ^\circ\text{F}\]
- \[\Delta T_{lm} = \frac{72 - 54}{\ln(72/54)} = 62.54\ ^\circ\text{F}, \qquad A = \frac{1{,}713{,}600}{264 \times 62.54} = 103.8 \text{ ft}^2\]
Answer: 104 ft². Check: the cold water leaves at about 122 °F, at the hot outlet temperature, with no temperature cross.
Worked problem
Problem 4: a project's economics
A heat recovery project costs 1.5 million dollars and saves 260,000 dollars a year for 15 years. Find its simple payback, its NPV at 8 in 100 and its approximate IRR.
Show solution
- \[\text{payback} = \frac{1{,}500{,}000}{260{,}000} = 5.8 \text{ years}\]
- \[\frac{1 - 1.08^{-15}}{0.08} = 8.559 \;\Rightarrow\; NPV = 260{,}000 \times 8.559 - 1{,}500{,}000 = 725{,}000 \text{ dollars}\]
- \[IRR \approx 0.153\]
Answer: Worth doing at an 8 in 100 cost of capital: NPV about 725,000 dollars, IRR about 15 in 100.
Worked problem
Problem 5: a shaft
A shaft transmits 40 hp at 1,450 r/min and carries a bending moment of 2,650 lb·in. With an allowable shear stress of 6,000 psi, find the minimum diameter by the maximum shear stress theory.
Show solution
- \[T = \frac{63{,}025 \times 40}{1{,}450} = 1{,}739 \text{ lb·in}, \qquad T_e = \sqrt{2{,}650^2 + 1{,}739^2} = 3{,}169 \text{ lb·in}\]
- \[d = \sqrt[3]{\frac{16 \times 3{,}169}{\pi \times 6{,}000}} = 1.391 \text{ in}\]
Answer: 1.39 in minimum; choose the next standard size, 1-1/2 in.
Worked problem
Problem 6: power factor correction
A 480 V plant load of 500 kW runs at 0.78 power factor. Find the capacitor kvar needed for 0.95, and the line current before and after.
Show solution
- \[Q_C = 500 \times (\tan 38.7^\circ - \tan 18.2^\circ) = 500 \times (0.802 - 0.329) = 236.8 \text{ kvar}\]
- \[I = \frac{500{,}000}{\sqrt{3} \times 480 \times 0.78} = 771.0 \text{ A} \;\rightarrow\; \frac{500{,}000}{\sqrt{3} \times 480 \times 0.95} = 633.1 \text{ A}\]
Answer: About 237 kvar, in steps; the current falls by 18 in 100.
Worked problem
Problem 7: a chiller cycle
An ideal vapor-compression cycle must provide 100 tons of cooling. Given h₁ = 107 Btu/lb, h₂ = 119.5 Btu/lb and h₃ = h₄ = 46 Btu/lb, find the refrigerant flow, the ideal compressor power, the COP and the heat rejected.
Show solution
- \[q_L = 107 - 46 = 61 \text{ Btu/lb}, \qquad \dot m = \frac{1{,}200{,}000}{61} = 19{,}670 \text{ lb/h}\]
- \[P = 19{,}670 \times 12.5 = 245{,}900 \text{ Btu/h} = 72.1 \text{ kW}, \qquad COP = \frac{61}{12.5} = 4.88, \qquad Q_H = 1{,}445{,}900 \text{ Btu/h}\]
Answer: COP about 4.9; the heat rejected is the cooling plus the compressor power.
Worked problem
Problem 8: heat rate
A plant burns 493 MMBtu/h of gas (LHV) and delivers 55 MW net. Find its net heat rate and efficiency on the LHV, and on the HHV with HHV ÷ LHV = 1.106.
Show solution
- \[HR = \frac{493{,}000{,}000 \text{ Btu/h}}{55{,}000 \text{ kW}} = 8{,}964 \text{ Btu/kWh}, \qquad \eta = \frac{3{,}412}{8{,}964} = 0.381\]
- \[HR_{HHV} = 8{,}964 \times 1.106 = 9{,}914 \text{ Btu/kWh}, \qquad \eta_{HHV} = 0.344\]
Answer: State the basis with every heat rate.
What the marking showed
Pilar's practice paper earned 86 of a possible 100 by Grazyna's marking. She lost marks in three places, each a lesson worth writing down. In problem 1 she forgot to subtract the pump work until the check; the efficiency barely changed, but the method did. In problem 2 she used the compressor outlet temperature, not the regenerator outlet, in the first draft of the heat input, and caught it only because the efficiency came out higher than the regenerative value she remembered from lesson 3. And in problem 8 she gave a heat rate without stating its basis, which Grazyna said an examiner would mark as incomplete even though the number was right.
Her plan, agreed with Grazyna, was to keep working through the course material over the winter, to begin on the PWR-420 material in the new year, and to apply for the NIULPE examination in 2027, once she had confirmed its current arrangements with NIULPE. Okonkwo, who had solved problems 1 and 2 correctly, said only that he now understood why the Third Class course had spent so long on steam tables.
An essay question and a model answer
The paper ended with one essay-style question, of the kind set on the operating side of the examinations. Grazyna wrote out the answer she would have given, so Pilar could compare its shape with her own.
Worked problem
Problem 9: a closed feedwater heater's rising terminal temperature difference
A plant's high-pressure closed feedwater heater shows a terminal temperature difference that has risen over a month from its normal value to about three times normal, at steady load. List the likely causes, the checks you would make, and the effect on the plant if nothing is done.
Show solution
- **Likely causes.** (1) Noncondensable gases accumulating in the shell because the vent is blocked or throttled; (2) a high shell water level flooding part of the tube bundle, from a faulty level controller, a sticking drain valve or a tube leak; (3) fouling or deposits on the tubes; (4) a partly open bypass or a passing partition plate in the water box, so some feedwater bypasses the tubes.
- **Checks.** Compare the shell pressure with the saturation pressure for the measured shell temperature (air raises the total pressure above the steam's saturation pressure); check the level gauge against the level transmitter and the drain valve position; compare the drain cooler approach with normal; check the feedwater flow balance and the water box temperatures; and, if a tube leak is suspected, isolate and test the heater on the next opportunity.
- **Effects.** The feedwater reaches the boiler colder, so more fuel is burned for the same steam; less steam is bled, so more passes the later turbine stages; and if the cause is a high level, there is a risk of water induction into the turbine through the extraction line.
- **Safety point.** High-level alarms and extraction non-return valves must be tested and in service while the cause is found.
Answer: Direct statement, reasons in order, checks, effects, and the safety point last: the shape Grazyna wanted in every essay answer.
Pilar's own answer had listed the same causes but no checks. "The examiner wants to know what you would do on shift," Grazyna said. "Causes are textbook. Checks are what an engineer brings."
Common mistakes
MistakeWriting only the final number.
InsteadShow given, required, formula, substitution with units, result and a check; method earns most of the marks.
MistakeSpending too long on one question.
InsteadBudget about 40 minutes a question on an essay paper and move on.
MistakeLeaving multiple-choice questions blank.
InsteadAnswer every question; eliminate wrong options first.
MistakeStudying each subject once and moving on.
InsteadReturn to each subject for problem practice and timed review.
MistakeQuoting results without their basis or units.
InsteadState units and bases such as gross or net, HHV or LHV, every time.
Summary and key terms
- NIULPE Power Engineer 2nd Class: six syllabus areas and 60 topics; confirm examination arrangements with NIULPE.
- Ohio's highest license is stationary steam engineer; graded-license states and many employers recognize higher grades.
- Plan first study, problem practice and timed review for every subject.
- Set out calculations as given, required, sketch, formula, substitution, result and check.
- Answer essay questions directly and in order, with sketches and the safety or regulatory point.
- Mixed practice papers under time reveal the gaps that subject-by-subject study hides.
- NIULPE
- The National Institute for the Uniform Licensing of Power Engineers, which certifies power engineers by grade in the United States.
- Stationary steam engineer
- Ohio's highest steam engineer license.
- Qualifying experience
- Documented operating time in a plant of the required class, needed for a certificate.
- Essay paper
- An examination answered in written calculations and explanations rather than by selecting options.
- Check
- A quick test of a result, such as comparing an efficiency with the Carnot limit or a quality with the range zero to one.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
On a 3.5-hour paper with five questions to answer, roughly how long should each take, allowing 20 minutes for reading and checking?
Show answer
About 38 minutes.
What is the highest steam engineer license that Ohio issues?
Show answer
Stationary steam engineer.
An ideal cycle result gives an efficiency of 0.61 between 900 °F and 115 °F. What is wrong?
Show answer
It exceeds the Carnot limit of 0.577; there is an error.
A turbine exhaust quality is calculated as 1.04 at 1.5 psia. What does that mean?
Show answer
The exhaust is superheated, not wet; find its temperature from the superheat region.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.