PWR-410 · Lesson 10 of 12 · 31 min
Advanced mechanics and machine design
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
When boiler 2's forced draft fan motor was replaced in August, Fenella's crew had the fan's shaft and bearings out on the shop floor for a day, and someone had asked why the shaft was the size it was. Nobody at Cantwell had the original design calculation. At the tenth session Grazyna set Pilar the problem of checking it from first principles, then went on to the questions a Second Class engineer meets when machines are bought, modified or investigated after a failure: combined stresses, fatigue, thick cylinders, gears, bearing life, critical speeds and the energy stored in a turbine rotor.
This lesson covers shafts under combined bending and torsion, fatigue and the Goodman relation, stress concentration, thick-walled cylinders, thermal stress, gear trains and their losses, belt drives, rolling bearing life, shaft critical speeds and rotor kinetic energy, at the level of Second Class applied mechanics.
Shafts under combined loads
A shaft carrying a pulley, gear or fan wheel is loaded in torsion by the power it transmits and in bending by the weight and forces of what it carries. The torque follows from the power and speed:
Torsion produces shear stress, greatest at the surface: τ = 16T ÷ πd³ for a solid shaft. Bending produces normal stress, also greatest at the surface: σ = 32M ÷ πd³. The two combine. For ductile steels, the maximum shear stress theory gives an equivalent torque, and the maximum normal stress theory, sometimes used for brittle materials and in older practice, an equivalent bending moment:
Worked problem
Checking the forced draft fan shaft
Boiler 2's fan is driven at 1,775 r/min by its new 60 hp motor. The fan wheel weighs 400 lb and overhangs the outboard bearing by 12 in (assumed for the check). With an allowable shear stress of 6,000 psi and an allowable normal stress of 12,000 psi (typical values for a shaft steel with a keyway and shock allowance), find the torque, the bending moment at the bearing and the minimum shaft diameter.
Show solution
- \[T = \frac{63{,}025 \times 60}{1{,}775} = 2{,}130 \text{ lb·in}, \qquad M = 400 \times 12 = 4{,}800 \text{ lb·in}\]
- \[T_e = \sqrt{4{,}800^2 + 2{,}130^2} = 5{,}252 \text{ lb·in}, \qquad M_e = \tfrac{1}{2}(4{,}800 + 5{,}252) = 5{,}026 \text{ lb·in}\]
- \[d = \sqrt[3]{\frac{16 \times 5{,}252}{\pi \times 6{,}000}} = 1.646 \text{ in}, \qquad d = \sqrt[3]{\frac{32 \times 5{,}026}{\pi \times 12{,}000}} = 1.622 \text{ in}\]
Answer: About 1.65 in minimum; the next standard size up, 1-7/8 or 2 in, would be chosen, and the actual shaft, measured on the shop floor at 2 in at the bearing, has a comfortable margin. The bending moment from the overhung wheel, not the torque, governs.
Fatigue
A rotating shaft under a steady bending load sees a fully reversed bending stress every revolution: tension at the bottom, then compression as that point comes to the top. At 1,775 r/min, that is nearly a billion cycles a year. Metals fail under repeated stress at levels well below their static strength, by fatigue: a crack starts at a point of high local stress, usually at the surface, grows a little with each cycle, and finally the remaining section breaks suddenly. Fatigue fracture surfaces show smooth beach marks spreading from the origin and a rough final fracture zone.
Steels have an endurance limit, a stress amplitude below which they can withstand an indefinite number of cycles in laboratory tests, roughly half the ultimate tensile strength for polished specimens (typical). Real parts have lower endurance limits because of surface finish, size, temperature, reliability and, above all, stress concentrations: keyways, shoulders, holes, threads and press fits raise the local stress by a stress concentration factor, often 1.5 to 3 (typical). Most shaft failures start at a keyway end, a sharp shoulder fillet or the edge of a fitted component.
When a part carries a steady mean stress σ_m as well as an alternating stress σ_a, the Goodman relation gives a conservative safety factor n against fatigue:
Worked problem
A Goodman check
A shaft section has a corrected endurance limit of 29,000 psi and an ultimate strength of 87,000 psi. In service it carries an alternating stress of 8,700 psi and a mean stress of 11,600 psi. Find the safety factor.
Show solution
- \[\frac{8{,}700}{29{,}000} + \frac{11{,}600}{87{,}000} = 0.300 + 0.133 = 0.433 \;\Rightarrow\; n = 2.31\]
Answer: A factor of about 2.3. The alternating stress uses most of the margin, which is typical: in rotating machinery, the reversed bending stress, multiplied by the stress concentration, is what designers watch.
In plant operation, fatigue explains why misalignment and unbalance matter so much: they add alternating loads to shafts, couplings and bearings every revolution. It also explains thermal fatigue in boiler drums, headers and turbine casings, where each start and stop is one cycle of thermal stress, and why the start-up rate limits of PWR-320 and PWR-330 protect the life of thick components.
Thick-walled cylinders
The thin-wall formula σ = pr ÷ t from PWR-310 assumes that the hoop stress is uniform through the wall, which is close enough when the wall is thin compared with the radius. In thick cylinders, such as high-pressure headers, hydraulic cylinders, valve bodies and turbine casings, the hoop stress is highest at the bore and falls toward the outside. Lamé's equations give the stresses for internal pressure p in a cylinder of inner radius rᵢ and outer radius r₀:
Worked problem
A thick cylinder
A hydraulic cylinder has a bore of 2 in and an outside diameter of 4 in and carries an internal pressure of 4,350 psi. Find the hoop stress at the bore and at the outside, and compare them with the thin-wall estimate based on the mean radius.
Show solution
- \[\sigma_{\theta,i} = 4{,}350 \times \frac{2^2 + 1^2}{2^2 - 1^2} = 7{,}250 \text{ psi}, \qquad \sigma_{\theta,o} = 4{,}350 \times \frac{2 \times 1}{3} = 2{,}900 \text{ psi}\]
- \[\text{thin wall: } \sigma = \frac{4{,}350 \times 1.5}{1} = 6{,}525 \text{ psi}\]
Answer: The bore stress is 11 in 100 higher than the thin-wall estimate and two and a half times the outside stress. Pressure equipment codes use formulas that account for thick-wall effects where they matter; the code formulas, not textbook ones, must be used for design and for any calculation of a coded vessel or pipe.
Thermal stress arises when a part's thermal expansion is restrained. For a bar fully restrained against expansion, σ = EαΔT. For steel, with E about 29 million psi and α about 6.5 × 10⁻⁶ per °F (typical), a temperature change of 180 °F produces about 33,900 psi, more than the yield strength of many carbon steels. That is why steam lines have expansion loops and anchors, as PWR-210 described for the tunnel, why thick parts must be warmed slowly, and why a cold slug of water entering a hot header can crack it.
Gears and gear trains
Gears transmit power between shafts at a fixed speed ratio. For a simple pair, the speed ratio is the inverse of the ratio of the numbers of teeth: N₁ ÷ N₂ = Z₂ ÷ Z₁. In a train of gears, the overall ratio is the product of the ratios of each pair. Torque changes in the opposite direction to speed: a speed reducer multiplies torque, less its losses. A well-made helical gear stage transmits about 0.98 to 0.99 of its input power (typical); the rest becomes heat in the oil.
Worked problem
Keswold's load gear
Keswold's gas turbine shaft turns at about 5,100 r/min (Keswold's maker data) and drives its generator at 3,600 r/min through a reduction gear of about 0.985 efficiency. At 45 MW at the generator, find the ratio, the torque on each shaft and the heat the gear rejects to its oil.
Show solution
- \[\text{ratio} = \frac{5{,}100}{3{,}600} = 1.417\]
- \[T_{gen} = \frac{60{,}350 \text{ hp} \times 5{,}252}{3{,}600} = 88{,}000 \text{ lb·ft}, \qquad T_{GT} = \frac{(60{,}350 / 0.985) \times 5{,}252}{5{,}100} = 63{,}100 \text{ lb·ft}\]
- \[\text{loss} = \frac{45{,}000}{0.985} - 45{,}000 = 685 \text{ kW}\]
Answer: Almost 700 kW of heat goes into the gear's lubricating oil, more than four times the steam turbine's bearing losses. Gear oil temperature and gear vibration are watched as closely as the turbine's.
Gear failures are mostly due to lubrication and loading: pitting from surface fatigue, scuffing when the oil film breaks down under heavy load and high sliding speed, wear from contaminated oil, and tooth breakage from overload or fatigue at the tooth root. Gear tooth meshing frequency, the number of teeth times the shaft speed, and its harmonics appear clearly in a vibration spectrum, and sidebands around them at shaft speed reveal a damaged or eccentric gear.
Belt drives
Belts transmit power by friction. The ratio of the tensions on the tight and slack sides is limited by the friction coefficient μ and the angle of wrap θ on the smaller pulley; for a V-belt with groove angle 2β, the wedge action increases the effective friction:
Too little tension lets the belt slip, glaze and overheat; too much overloads the shaft and bearings in bending, the most common cause of early motor bearing failure on belted fans. Belts are tensioned to the maker's deflection or frequency method and rechecked after the first hours of running, when new belts stretch. Pulleys must be aligned, and a set of belts is replaced together so that all carry their share.
Rolling bearing life
Rolling bearings fail eventually by rolling contact fatigue, even when perfectly lubricated and clean. Their life is stated statistically. The basic rating life L₁₀ is the life that 90 in 100 of a large group of identical bearings will reach or exceed, in millions of revolutions:
where C is the bearing's basic dynamic load rating from the maker's catalog, P the equivalent dynamic load, and p = 3 for ball bearings and 10/3 for roller bearings. The life is very sensitive to load: doubling the load on a ball bearing reduces its life to an eighth. The standard method is ISO 281, which also gives a modified rating life that accounts for lubrication and contamination.
Worked problem
Bearing life on the fan
A ball bearing on the fan shaft has C = 13,940 lbf and carries an equivalent load of 900 lbf at 1,775 r/min. Find its L₁₀ life in hours, and the life if misalignment or over-tension doubled the load.
Show solution
- \[L_{10} = \left(\frac{13{,}940}{900}\right)^3 = 3{,}716 \text{ million rev}, \qquad L_{10h} = \frac{3{,}716 \times 10^6}{60 \times 1{,}775} = 34{,}890 \text{ h}\]
- \[P = 1{,}800 \text{ lbf}: \;\; L_{10h} = \frac{34{,}890}{8} = 4{,}360 \text{ h}\]
Answer: About four years of continuous running at the design load, but only about six months at double the load. In practice, most rolling bearings fail from lubrication problems, contamination, misalignment or poor fitting long before their fatigue life, which is why PWR-230's lubrication and alignment practices matter as much as the bearing selected.
Critical speeds
Every shaft carrying masses has natural frequencies of lateral vibration. When the running speed coincides with one of them, the critical speed, small unbalance forces produce large vibration. For a shaft with a single mass, the first critical speed can be estimated from the static deflection δ of the shaft under the weight of the mass:
A static deflection of 0.002 in gives a critical speed of about 4,200 r/min, well above the fan's 1,775 r/min. For several masses, Dunkerley's or Rayleigh's methods combine the effects, and for large turbine and generator rotors the critical speeds are calculated by the maker with detailed rotor-dynamic models including the bearing oil films. Machines that run below their first critical speed have stiff shafts; large turbines and generators often run above one or more criticals with flexible shafts, and pass through them quickly during start-up, as PWR-320 described for Keswold's critical speed bands.
Energy stored in rotors
A rotating rotor stores kinetic energy KE = ½Jω², where J is its mass moment of inertia. The energy explains why turbines must be tripped and isolated quickly when the generator breaker opens, why overspeed is so dangerous, and how a generator helps hold the grid's frequency.
Worked problem
Keswold's steam turbine generator rotor
The rotor train of Keswold's steam turbine and generator has WR² ≈ 35,600 lb·ft² (PWR-320) and runs at 3,600 r/min. Find its kinetic energy, the energy at an overspeed of 110 in 100, and the inertia constant H, the kinetic energy divided by the generator's 22.5 MVA rating.
Show solution
- \[KE = \frac{WR^2\,\omega^2}{2 g} = \frac{35{,}600 \times 377.0^2}{2 \times 32.174} = 78.6 \times 10^6 \text{ ft·lbf} = 106.6 \text{ MJ}\]
- \[KE_{110} = 106.6 \times 1.10^2 = 129.0 \text{ MJ}, \qquad H = \frac{106.6}{22.5} = 4.74 \text{ s}\]
Answer: More than 100 MJ, the energy of about 55 lb of high explosive. Stresses in the rotor rise with the square of speed, so a rotor that bursts from overspeed releases its energy as fragments that can pass through the casing. Overspeed trips are tested, as Okonkwo saw at Keswold, for that reason.
Pilar's notebook from the session listed what she now checked when a machine came apart for repair: the shaft size against the loads, the fillet radii and keyway ends for fatigue cracks, bearing fits and the load the bearings had actually carried, and the alignment record. "Most failures are designed in or installed in," Grazyna said. "Very few are bad luck."
Common mistakes
MistakeSizing a shaft for torque alone.
InsteadCombine bending and torsion; on overhung loads, bending usually governs.
MistakeUsing static strength to judge a rotating shaft.
InsteadRotating bending is fully reversed; use fatigue strength and stress concentrations.
MistakeApplying the thin-wall formula to thick parts.
InsteadUse Lamé's equations for thick cylinders, and the code formulas for coded equipment.
MistakeOver-tensioning belts to stop slip.
InsteadExcess tension overloads bearings; tension to the maker's method and fix the cause of slip.
MistakeTreating L₁₀ life as the life every bearing will reach.
InsteadIt is the life 90 in 100 reach; load, lubrication and contamination change it greatly.
Summary and key terms
- Combined bending and torsion: T_e = √(M² + T²) and M_e = ½(M + T_e) give shaft sizes.
- Rotating shafts see reversed bending; fatigue, stress concentrations and the Goodman relation govern them.
- Thick cylinders have their highest hoop stress at the bore, from Lamé's equations; restrained expansion causes thermal stress EαΔT.
- Gear trains multiply torque by the speed ratio less losses; gear losses heat the oil.
- Bearing life L₁₀ = (C/P)^p million revolutions; doubling a ball bearing's load cuts its life eightfold.
- Critical speed rises with shaft stiffness; rotor kinetic energy ½Jω² explains the danger of overspeed.
- Equivalent torque
- The single torque producing the same maximum shear stress as combined bending and torsion.
- Fatigue
- Failure under repeated stress at levels below the static strength.
- Endurance limit
- The stress amplitude below which a steel withstands an indefinite number of cycles.
- Stress concentration factor
- The ratio of the peak local stress at a notch or change of section to the nominal stress.
- Goodman relation
- A criterion combining alternating and mean stress to find a fatigue safety factor.
- Lamé equations
- Equations for the stresses in a thick-walled cylinder under pressure.
- Basic rating life
- The life in revolutions that 90 in 100 of a group of identical bearings will reach.
- Critical speed
- A rotating speed equal to a natural frequency of a shaft and its masses.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
Find the torque on a shaft transmitting 100 hp at 1,480 r/min.
Show answer
63,025 × 100 ÷ 1,480 = 4,258 lb·in.
A shaft carries M = 7,000 lb·in and T = 5,250 lb·in. Find T_e.
Show answer
√(7,000² + 5,250²) = 8,750 lb·in.
A roller bearing has C = 20,000 lbf and carries P = 3,333 lbf. Find L₁₀ in millions of revolutions.
Show answer
6^(10/3) = 393.
A restrained steel bar (E = 29 × 10⁶ psi, α = 6.5 × 10⁻⁶ per °F) is heated 90 °F. Find the stress.
Show answer
16,970 psi.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.