BAS-330 · Lesson 12 of 12 · 25 min

An energy retrofit through the control system

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

On Friday, November 13, Prakash re-seated the coupling on room 108's reheat valve before 9:00, and by noon the box's discharge air was within a degree of the supply air for the first time in weeks. At about 4:30 that afternoon, back at the office, Declan put his draft of the Ninefield Tower retro-commissioning proposal on the table and asked Callie to check it with him, line by line. The proposal would go to Ilona Vescovi in early December, the work would be done in the spring of 2027, and the year after that would show whether it had worked. "Everything you have learned on Thursdays is in here," he said. "If any of it is wrong, now is when we find out."

This lesson follows the proposal from the data to the measures, the estimates, the M&V plan and the risks, as a worked example of an energy retrofit carried out mostly through the control system.

Step 1: what the data said

Declan's starting point was the analysis from the autumn: the bills, PM-1's 15-minute data since August, the trends Quillon had set up, and what Callie, Prakash and Sophie had found on site.

Findings that shaped the Ninefield proposal.
FindingEvidenceLesson
Site EUI 68.7 kBtu/ft², ENERGY STAR score 522025 bills, Portfolio ManagerLessons 1 and 10
Night and weekend base load about 150 kW, 30 in 100 of electricityPM-1 15-minute dataLesson 1
Monthly peaks set by coincident starts at 6:00 (820 kW July, 760 kW January)Bills and PM-1 dataLessons 2 and 6
All equipment on a fixed 6:00 start for 7:00 occupancySchedules on the front endLesson 4
Fixed duct static setpoints on both penthouse air handlersPrograms and trendsLesson 5
One air handler's supply air setpoint lowered to 50 °FProgram and trendsLesson 5
Secondary pumps near 52 Hz all day; three-way valves; low delta-T 6.3 °FTrends, valve surveyLesson 5
Chilled water meter reading about 28 in 100 lowPortable meter comparison in SeptemberLesson 3
Outdoor air dampers on one air handler open during warm-upTrends of damper command and mixed air temperatureLesson 4
Occupancy sensors on every floor from the 2019 lighting controls, not used by HVACLighting gateway point listLesson 4

Callie noticed that almost every finding had been made by someone looking at data that already existed. Only two, the low chilled water meter and the warm-up dampers, had needed a site visit to confirm.

Step 2: the base load

The base load was the largest opportunity, so Declan had spent a night in the building in October with the front end on a laptop, as he had described in the first session. He had found that the base load was made up of the elevators, emergency lighting, two tenants' server closets with their own cooling, the garage and toilet exhaust fans, the podium's retail refrigeration, and a handful of things that should not have been on: two rooftop unit supply fans running continuously because their old controllers had lost their schedules, a corridor lighting zone overridden on, and perimeter fan-powered box fans running all night on three floors because their unoccupied mode had been programmed wrongly in 1998.

Worked problem

The base load measure

Declan estimated that fixing the schedules and modes would bring the average base from 150 kW to about 125 kW, more conservatively than the 110 kW used as an illustration in lesson 1. What is the annual saving?

Show solution
  1. Unoccupied hours: 108 a week × 52 = 5,616 h.
  2. Saving: (150 − 125) × 5,616 = 140,400 kWh.

Answer: About 140,400 kWh a year, the largest single measure in the proposal, for the cost of a few days of programming and checking. The new rooftop unit controllers going in during December would fix the first part.

Step 3: the measures

Each measure in the proposal had a description, the sequence change, an estimate with its method, and the M&V option. Declan summarized them in one table.

Measures in the Ninefield retro-commissioning proposal.
MeasureControl changeElectricity savedEstimate method
1. Night and weekend base loadFix schedules, unoccupied modes, overrides140,400 kWh25 kW × unoccupied hours
2. Duct static pressure resetTrim and respond on both penthouse air handlers21,800 kWhFan power at reduced pressure (lesson 5)
3. Supply air temperatureRestore 55 °F and add trim and respond reset30,000 kWhReheat and cooling avoided
4. Chilled water pumpingTwo-way valves, remote DP sensor, DP reset15,600 kWhPump kW at reduced speed, derated from cube law
5. Optimal startAdaptive start with earliest and latest limits, staggered18,000 kWhRun hours saved on mild mornings
6. Occupied standbyUse lighting occupancy sensors for HVAC setback by zone20,000 kWhSetback hours from lighting sensor data
7. Outdoor air in warm-upClose dampers until occupancy; repair actuatorGas 2,120 thermsOutdoor air heating hours
8. Demand controlStaggered starts and predictive demand limitDemand only120 kW winter, 60 kW summer

The total electricity saving was 245,800 kWh, about 8.8 in 100 of the 2,800,000 kWh annual use. Declan had not simply added up the measures' best cases. He had deliberately estimated each one conservatively, and noted that some interact: the static pressure reset saves a little less once occupied standby has reduced airflow to empty zones, and the supply air temperature reset slightly increases fan airflow. For a package of interacting measures, the total from whole-building M&V is the number that counts, and individual estimates are for planning.

Two items were in the proposal without savings attached: the magnetic chilled water flow meter with matched temperature sensors, which would let the plant's efficiency be measured properly for the first time, and tagging the 1998 tower points so that the fault detection platform could be added later.

Step 4: what it is worth

Worked problem

The annual saving in money

Using sample rates of 0.09 dollars per kWh for energy and its per-kWh charges, 1.10 dollars per therm for gas, and 9.80 dollars per kW per month for demand, value the measures. The demand reductions are 120 kW for four winter months and 60 kW for five summer months.

Show solution
  1. Electricity: 245,800 × 0.09 = 22,122 dollars.
  2. Gas: 2,120 × 1.10 = 2,332 dollars.
  3. Demand, winter: 120 × 9.80 × 4 = 4,704 dollars; summer: 60 × 9.80 × 5 = 2,940 dollars.
  4. Total: 22,122 + 2,332 + 4,704 + 2,940 = 32,098 dollars a year.

Answer: About 32,100 dollars a year at the sample rates. The proposal would use the rates on Ninefield's current tariff and supply contract and state the date of the rates used.

Worked problem

Simple payback

Quillon's price for the work, including the two-way valves, the flow meter, programming, tagging, testing and the first year of M&V, was 124,000 dollars. What is the simple payback?

Show solution
  1. Payback = 124,000 ÷ 32,098 = 3.9 years.

Answer: About 3.9 years, which Ilona's owners would consider reasonable. Simple payback ignores the time value of money and the measures' life; for a decision, an owner may also want the net present value over the life of the measures.

\[\text{simple payback} = \frac{\text{installed cost}}{\text{annual saving}}\]
A horizontal bar chart of the estimated annual electricity saving for each measure in the Ninefield proposal, in thousands of kWh: night and weekend base load 140.4, supply air temperature 30.0, static pressure reset 21.8, occupied standby 20.0, optimal start 18.0, chilled water pumping 15.6. A total bar reads 245.8, about 8.8 in 100 of annual electricity. Notes beside the chart give the gas saving from closing outdoor air in warm-up and the demand reductions in winter and summer.
Estimated savings by measure. The night and weekend base load is more than half of the total.

Callie added one line to the summary that Declan liked: emissions. At the sample factors from lesson 11, the electricity saving avoids about 98 t of CO₂e a year and the gas saving about 11 t, about 110 t in all, which Ilona could report alongside the Portfolio Manager results.

Step 5: the M&V plan

Declan's M&V section followed the outline from lesson 9.

The M&V plan in the Ninefield proposal.
ItemPlan
Whole-building savingsOption C on electricity, using a model of 15-minute utility interval data against hourly outdoor temperature, separate for occupied and unoccupied hours; and on gas, using monthly bills against heating degree-days
Measure-level checksOption B on fan and pump drive kW for measures 2 and 4; Option A for optimal start using run hours
Baseline periodSeptember 2025 to August 2026, with the building's conditions recorded: occupancy by floor, hours, tenants, setpoints
Installation periodSpring 2027, excluded from both periods
Reporting periodTwelve months starting the month after the work is accepted
AdjustmentsWeather in the model; any non-routine adjustment above 1 in 100 of the baseline agreed in writing with Ilona
PricingSavings valued at the tariff in force during the reporting period
ReportingMonthly one-page report and call; annual M&V report at the end of the reporting year

Callie checked the statistics on the gas baseline herself from the numbers in lesson 9: R² of 0.99 and a CV(RMSE) of 7.7 in 100, within the commonly cited Guideline 14 limit for monthly models. The electricity model would be built from interval data during the winter, before the work started, so that its accuracy could be stated in the final proposal.

Step 6: the sequences and the testing

Every measure was a sequence change, and every sequence change needed testing. Sophie had already drafted most of the sequences in BAS-230's sessions: the static pressure and supply air resets, the hydronic DP reset with its remote sensor and fallback, the restart inhibit from BAS-220, the occupied standby rules. The proposal referred to the sequence document rather than repeating it, and added a testing section based on BAS-220's test plan approach: each sequence tested on the bench where possible, then functionally in the building, with trends to show it working before and after.

An extract from the proposed functional test record, as a plain listing.
Functional test record (extract), measure 2: duct static pressure reset
  Test 1  All zones satisfied, requests = 0
          Expect: setpoint trims 0.05 in. w.c. every 2 min down to SPmin
  Test 2  Force 4 zones to request (I = 2)
          Expect: setpoint rises 0.12 in. w.c. per step, limited to 0.13 in. w.c.
  Test 3  Remove requests
          Expect: setpoint trims back; no hunting of fan speed
  Test 4  Fail the duct static sensor
          Expect: fan holds last speed, alarm, operator notified
  Trend for 7 days after acceptance:
          setpoint, fan speed, fan kW, requests, worst zone damper position

Testing the rogue zones came first. The static pressure reset would only work if no box requested constantly, so the proposal included a week of trending zone requests before the reset was enabled, and a budget to fix the boxes that requested all the time. Callie recognized room 108's lesson: fix the zone, not the setpoint.

Step 7: risks and how to handle them

Risks Declan listed, and the plan for each.
RiskEffectHow the proposal handles it
Rogue zones defeat the resetsLittle fan or pump savingTrend requests first; budget to fix the worst boxes
Tenants complain after setback or standby changesSettings reversed, savings lostTell tenants in advance; comfort KPI on the monthly report; after-hours request timers
The hot zone behind the lowered supply air setpoint returnsPressure to lower it againFind and fix the zone before raising the setpoint
Changes in occupancy during the reporting yearSavings hidden or exaggeratedRecord baseline conditions; non-routine adjustments agreed in writing
Savings fade after the first yearLost savingsMonthly KPIs and audit trail review under the service contract
Chiller plant interactions with the valve conversionUnexpected flow or delta-T behaviorCoordinate with Tarrant Chiller Service; test at low load in spring

"Most of these are about people, not equipment," Callie said. Declan agreed. A controls retrofit saves energy in the programs, but it keeps saving only if the people in the building understand what changed and why, and if someone keeps looking at the data. That was why the proposal ended with the monthly report, the training for Ilona's building operator, and the service visits, not with the payback.

Step 8: the timeline

The planned timeline. Everything after November 13, 2026 is a plan.
WhenWhat
Friday, November 13, 2026Draft reviewed by Declan and Callie
Early December 2026Proposal sent to Ilona; rooftop units 2 to 4 replaced under the existing order
Winter 2026 to 2027Electricity baseline model built; zone requests trended; rogue boxes listed
Spring 2027Retro-commissioning work, sequences tested and accepted
Following 12 monthsReporting period, monthly reports, annual M&V report

As Callie packed up, Declan handed her one more page: the room 108 rule, written up for the AHU-2 replacement proposal that would go to Gus in early December, with her name in the credits. "The rule you wrote on Thursday," he said, "is now part of two proposals. That is how energy work goes. You find one leaking valve, and then you go looking for all of them."

Bringing the course together

How the course lessons appear in the case study.
LessonWhere it appears in the proposal
1. How buildings use energyEUI, base load and load profile
2. Bills and demand chargesValuing energy, gas and demand separately
3. MeteringPM-1, drive kW, the new chilled water meter
4. Scheduling and optimal startMeasures 1, 5, 6 and 7
5. ResetsMeasures 2, 3 and 4
6. Demand limitingMeasure 8
7 and 8. Fault detection and analyticsTagging, future platform, the room 108 rule
9. M&VThe M&V plan
10. Codes and benchmarkingENERGY STAR score and reporting
11. DecarbonizationEmissions reporting; heat recovery for the longer term

Common mistakes

  • MistakeAdding up best-case savings for each measure.

    InsteadEstimate conservatively and remember that measures interact; whole-building M&V gives the real total.

  • MistakeValuing all savings at one blended price.

    InsteadValue energy, gas and demand separately at the current tariff.

  • MistakeEnabling resets before fixing rogue zones.

    InsteadTrend requests first and fix the boxes that request constantly.

  • MistakeLeaving the M&V plan until after the work.

    InsteadAgree the plan before the work starts.

  • MistakeTreating the payback as the end of the project.

    InsteadPlan monthly reporting, training and service so savings persist.

Summary and key terms

  • An energy retrofit through the controls starts with data the building already has.
  • Night and weekend base load is often the largest and cheapest opportunity.
  • Each measure needs a sequence change, an estimate with its method, a test and an M&V option.
  • Value electricity, gas and demand separately; show payback and emissions.
  • Whole-building M&V with interval data shows the total; measure-level M&V shows each measure.
  • Most risks to savings are about people and persistence, not equipment.
  • A good proposal ends with reporting, training and service, not with the payback.
Retro-commissioning
Commissioning an existing building to restore and improve its operation.
Measure
One specific change expected to save energy or cost.
Interaction
The effect one measure has on the savings of another.
Simple payback
Installed cost divided by annual saving.
Net present value
The value today of future savings minus costs, allowing for the time value of money.
Functional test
A test showing that a sequence works as specified in the real building.
Acceptance
The point at which the owner agrees the work is complete and working.
Persistence
The continuation of savings over time.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. A measure costs 30,000 dollars and saves 12,000 dollars a year. What is the simple payback?

    Show answer

    2.5 years.

  2. Base load falls from 140 to 120 kW over 5,616 unoccupied hours. What is the saving?

    Show answer

    20 × 5,616 = 112,320 kWh.

  3. Why did Declan use whole-building M&V for the package?

    Show answer

    The measures interact and the total is large enough to see on the main meter.

  4. Why trend zone requests before enabling a reset?

    Show answer

    To find and fix rogue zones that would hold the setpoint at maximum.

  5. Name two ways the proposal protects savings after the first year.

    Show answer

    Monthly KPIs and report, audit trail review, operator training, service visits.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz