ROOF-210 · Lesson 12 of 12 · 26 min
Case study: a school roof replacement
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
Before Rory ever saw a steep roof, he spent the last five weeks of his first summer on the biggest job Crew 2 did all year: the roof replacement at Cedarbrook Public School, a one-storey school built in 1968 on a quiet residential street. The school board had hired a roof consultant, who had surveyed the roof in the spring, written the specification and tendered the work. Ridgecap won it. The work had to start after the last day of classes and be finished, cleaned up and signed off before the staff came back to set up their classrooms.
This lesson follows the job from the pre-job meeting to the warranty, using every lesson of this course. Its numbers come from Dana's job file, which she lent Rory in November to study from.
The building and the old roof
| Item | Cedarbrook |
|---|---|
| Built | 1968, one storey, masonry walls, steel joists and steel deck |
| Roofs | a classroom wing, 56 m by 22 m (1,232 m²), and a gymnasium, 34 m by 26 m (884 m²), whose roof is about 3.5 m higher |
| Total area | 2,116 m² |
| Old roof | the original four-ply organic felt BUR with gravel, on 38 mm fibreboard over the deck, patched many times |
| Edges | low parapets with metal copings on the wing; a taller parapet round the gym |
| On the roof | 11 rooftop units, 9 exhaust fans, 14 drains, 2 roof hatches and about 30 pipes and vents |
| Consultant's survey | infrared scan and cores in April 2026: wet insulation under about 31 in 100 of the roof, mostly around drains and units |
The consultant's survey also included an asbestos assessment, as the school board's asbestos management program and Ontario's asbestos regulation for construction (O. Reg. 278/05) require before work that could disturb it. The felts were clear, but the old flashing cement at the parapets and curbs contained asbestos. A licensed abatement contractor removed it in the week before Ridgecap started, under its own containment and air monitoring, and the consultant's clearance letter was in Dana's file before anyone from Ridgecap touched the parapets.
The new roof
The consultant's specification called for a full tear-off to the deck and two different membranes:
| Layer | Classroom wing | Gymnasium |
|---|---|---|
| Deck | existing steel; rusted areas replaced | existing steel; rusted areas replaced |
| Vapour retarder | self-adhered, on primed deck | self-adhered, on primed deck |
| Insulation | two layers of polyiso, joints staggered, with tapered crickets between drains | two layers of polyiso |
| Cover board | gypsum-based cover board | gypsum-based cover board |
| Attachment of boards | low-rise foam adhesive in beads | low-rise foam adhesive in beads |
| Membrane | two-ply SBS: base mopped in Type III asphalt, cap torch-applied in the field | hybrid: three glass ply felts mopped in Type III asphalt, with an SBS cap torch-applied in the field |
| Cap surface | white granules | white granules |
| Flameless zones | self-adhered base and cap at least 915 mm (3 ft) from every edge, curb and penetration | the same |
| Flashings | self-adhered two-ply, under new metal copings | the same |
| Walkways | pads from each hatch to every unit | the same |
| Warranty | manufacturer's 20-year system warranty, plus Ridgecap's two-year workmanship warranty | the same |
Why the hybrid on the gym? The gym roof had the heaviest snow drifts against its parapets, the biggest units and the most service traffic, and the board's facilities manager wanted the extra plies of a built-up roof there. The consultant kept the same SBS cap on both roofs so that one manufacturer's warranty covered the whole school.
The pre-job meeting
On Tuesday, June 30, Dana, Anjali and Glen met the consultant, Martin Oyelaran, and the board's project manager, Hélène Viau, at the school. They agreed on:
- Access and staging: the hoist and dumpsters on the east side of the parking lot, the kettle at the far west end, a fenced compound, and a walking route for the custodians away from the hoist.
- Hours: 6:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., with no work on weekends, so the neighbours had quiet evenings.
- Occupancy: the building had custodians and a floor-refinishing crew inside all summer; the daycare a block away was open.
- Fumes: no kettle within 30 m of any air intake on the building or the daycare; the rooftop units shut down and intakes covered over the areas being torched or mopped each day.
- Fire: a hot work permit each day from the board's permit system as well as Ridgecap's; the fire alarm company told every morning; two-hour fire watch; last torch at 1:00 p.m.
- Hold points: deck repairs before vapour retarder; insulation before cover board on the first area; base or plies before cap on each roof; flashings before copings; final inspection.
- Rain: tear off only what could be dried in the same day, with water cut-offs every night.
The plan and the quantities
Glen's estimate had worked out the main quantities, and Dana checked them before ordering.
Worked problem
Felt, base and asphalt
The gym (884 m²) gets three glass plies of 1 m felt with a 316 mm exposure; rolls are 50 m². The wing (1,232 m²) gets SBS base rolls with 18.36 m² net each. All moppings are 1.2 kg/m²: three on the gym, one under the wing base. Add 5 per cent to felt, base and asphalt. Kegs are 45 kg.
Show solution
- Felt factor = 1,000 ÷ 316 = 3.16; felt = 884 × 3.16 × 1.05 = 2,933 m²; rolls = 2,933 ÷ 50 = 58.7, so 59.
- Wing base rolls = 1,232 ÷ 18.36 × 1.05 = 70.5, so 71.
- Asphalt = 884 × 3 × 1.2 + 1,232 × 1.2 = 3,182 + 1,478 = 4,661 kg.
- Kegs = 4,661 ÷ 45 × 1.05 = 108.8, so 109 kegs, about 4.9 tonnes.
Answer: 59 rolls of glass felt, 71 SBS base rolls and about 109 kegs of Type III asphalt, enough for five or six kettle loads.
Worked problem
Cap sheets: torch field and flameless bands
Flameless bands 0.915 m wide run round both roofs, with 60 m² more at curbs and penetrations. Cap rolls of both kinds cover 7.26 m² net. Add 5 per cent to the torch caps and 10 per cent to the SA caps.
Show solution
- Gym band = 2 × 0.915 × (34 + 26) − 4 × 0.915² = 109.8 − 3.3 = 106.5 m².
- Wing band = 2 × 0.915 × (56 + 22) − 3.3 = 142.7 − 3.3 = 139.4 m².
- All bands = 106.5 + 139.4 + 60 = 305.9 m²; torch field = 2,116 − 305.9 = 1,810.1 m².
- Torch caps = 1,810.1 ÷ 7.26 × 1.05 = 261.8, so 262 rolls. SA caps = 305.9 ÷ 7.26 × 1.10 = 46.3, so 47 rolls.
Answer: 262 torch-grade and 47 self-adhered white cap rolls, plus SA base for the bands and SA flashing rolls.
The schedule followed from the production rates Ridgecap had recorded on earlier jobs: about 150 m² a day of tear-off, deck prep, vapour retarder, insulation and cover board, with the base or plies following on the same area the next morning, and about 240 m² of torched cap a day once the bands were in.
| Week | Plan |
|---|---|
| July 6 to 10 | set up hoist, kettle compound and barricades; start tear-off and dry-in on the gym, low edge first |
| July 13 to 17 | finish gym dry-in; three plies on the gym; start the wing tear-off |
| July 20 to 24 | wing dry-in and base; gym flameless bands and flashings; start gym cap |
| July 27 to 31 | wing bands and flashings; wing cap; copings |
| August 3 to 7 | walkways, punch list, final inspection, clean-up, closeout |
The Civic Holiday on Monday, August 3, was a Ridgecap holiday, so the last week had four days.
What happened
Rory's notebook from those weeks, which he reread in November, is full of the things this course is about.
- Week 1. The tear-off on the gym showed the survey had been optimistic: wet fibreboard ran farther from the drains than the cores had shown. Martin walked it with Dana each afternoon and marked the extra areas; because the whole roof was being removed anyway, the extra wet board changed only the dumpster count, not the price. Under the drains, three areas of steel deck had rusted through, about 9 m² in all. They were a hold point: the general contractor's ironworker replaced them, and Martin inspected before any vapour retarder went down.
- Week 1 and 2. Marco ran the kettle at the far west end of the lot, more than 30 m from every intake, with the cylinders at 3 m and the extinguishers in place. He logged temperatures every 15 minutes; the EVT window on the Type III label was 196 to 224 °C (385 to 435 °F), and his kettle stayed well below the label's limit. On the second Thursday, the daycare's director called about the smell; Marco moved the kettle's lid side and the lugger route so the wind carried fumes away from the street, and there were no more calls.
- Week 2. The gym plies went down shingled in one pass, three plies with the 316 mm exposure, broomed into the hot asphalt. Rory carried felt and learned to watch the mop line. A test cut on July 16 showed three plies everywhere and interply moppings that passed (lesson 11).
- Week 3. On Wednesday, July 22, a line of thunderstorms arrived at 1:30 p.m., an hour earlier than forecast. Every dried-in area had its water cut-off finished by noon, as the daily routine required, and nothing leaked. The crew lost the afternoon and the next morning to drying.
- Weeks 3 and 4. Two days reached a humidex of 40. Anjali's heat plan moved the start to 6:00, added shade at the hoist and water on the roof, and rotated the kettle attendant and torch applicators every hour. On those days the last torch was moved up to noon, with the fire watch still two hours.
- Week 4. At 2:40 p.m. on Monday, July 27, during the fire watch, Rory's infrared scan found a spot at 48 °C (118 °F) on the face of a gym unit curb, where everything around it read about 35 °C (95 °F). Dana opened the flashing: behind it, a piece of the old fibreboard cant left at the corner of the curb was smouldering. An applicator had torched a field lap close to the inner edge of the flameless band, and the heat had found a gap at the curb corner that the band covered but had not sealed underneath. The crew soaked the char with the extinguisher, removed the old cant and the damaged flashing, and rebuilt the corner. Anjali stopped all torching for the rest of the day, retrained the crew the next morning on keeping the flame back from the band edge, and added a step to the daily checklist: look under every band edge for gaps before the torch crew starts. The fire watch had done exactly what it was for.
- Week 5. The copings went on over the flashings after Martin's flashing hold point. Walkway pads were adhered from each hatch to every unit. The final inspection, with Martin and the manufacturer's representative, produced a punch list of nine items, mostly granule touch-up and a few T-joints, finished on August 6.
Worked problem
How the schedule worked out
The plan was 24 working days. Rain cost one and a half days, and the fire stop cost half a day. The extra wet board and deck work cost about one day. Did the job finish on time?
Show solution
- Lost time = 1.5 + 0.5 + 1 = 3 days.
- Days needed = 24 + 3 = 27, three more than the 24 available.
- Dana recovered them by adding a second torch crew for four days in weeks 4 and 5, and the punch list was finished on August 6, one day before the deadline.
Answer: Yes, by one day. The time was recovered by planning extra crew, not by skipping the rules: the last-torch time and the fire watch never moved.
Quality control on the job
Dana's job file showed what the QC records looked like at the end of a large job:
- A daily report for each of the working days: weather, dew point, areas completed, crew, materials used and any problems.
- Kettle logs: temperatures every 15 minutes, every day the kettle ran.
- Hot work permits and fire watch logs for every torch day, including the July 27 report.
- Test cut and lab results for the gym plies.
- Photos of every hold point: deck repairs, vapour retarder laps, insulation joints, plies, base laps, bands, flashings, drain rings off and on.
- Roll lot numbers for every membrane delivery.
- The punch lists, signed off.
The closeout
On Friday, August 7, Hélène Viau, the facilities manager and the head custodian walked the roof with Dana and Martin. The roof was clean, the drains clear and the domes on. Dana handed over the closeout package: the manufacturer's 20-year warranty application, Ridgecap's workmanship warranty, the as-built roof plan showing the drains, crickets and walkway routes, the product data, the maintenance guide and a list of who to call. The custodian asked if he could put his own vent through the roof for a new kitchen fan. "Call us first," Dana said. "Every hole in this roof voids somebody's warranty unless the right person flashes it."
The warranty was issued in September after the consultant's final report. On the following Monday, August 10, Rory moved to Crew 5 and started three months of shingles.
What Rory took from it
| Lesson | Where it showed up at Cedarbrook |
|---|---|
| 1 Low-slope systems | reading the whole assembly from deck to surfacing; the reasons for the hybrid on the gym |
| 2 Built-up roofing | three glass plies shingled at the right exposure; felt quantities |
| 3 Hot asphalt and kettles | kettle location, temperature logs, fumes and the daycare call |
| 4 Cold-applied systems | primers and adhesives at the bands and details |
| 5 Modified bitumen | SBS base and caps, laps and offsets, roll counts |
| 6 Torch safety | flameless bands, last torch, fire watch, the July 27 smoulder |
| 7 Self-adhered membranes | vapour retarder, bands and flashings |
| 8 Base sheets and securement | every layer attached; foam adhesive patterns; mopped base |
| 9 Surfacing | white granule cap for reflectivity; walkway pads |
| 10 Membrane flashings | curb heights, corners, drains and copings |
| 11 Quality control | hold points, test cuts, records and the punch list |
"Plan the roof before you climb it," Dana had said in April. In November, reading his own notes from the summer, Rory understood that she had meant this: a school roof replaced in five weeks without a leak, a fire or an injury, because the hidden steps were planned, checked and written down.
Common mistakes
MistakeTearing off more than can be dried in the same day.
InsteadTear off only what the crew can dry in, and finish water cut-offs before the forecast weather arrives.
MistakeMoving the last-torch time to make up a schedule.
InsteadRecover time with more crew; never shorten the fire watch or torch later in the day.
MistakeStarting work on a school roof without the asbestos information.
InsteadGet the owner's asbestos survey and clearance before disturbing old flashing and cement.
MistakeTreating a warm spot on a fire watch scan as sun.
InsteadOpen it and check; a warm spot near a flashing can be a smouldering fire.
MistakeLeaving the owner without instructions.
InsteadHand over a closeout package and tell them to call before anyone cuts into the roof.
Summary and key terms
- A school re-roof is a fixed-window job with occupants and neighbours, so access, fumes, fire and hours are planned at the pre-job meeting.
- The consultant's survey, asbestos assessment and specification define the work; extra wet areas and deck repairs are handled through hold points.
- Quantities come from felt factors, net roll coverage, flameless band areas and mopping rates.
- Hot work rules held even under schedule pressure; lost time was recovered with extra crew.
- The fire watch found a smouldering curb corner, which led to a new daily check under band edges.
- QC records, inspections and the closeout package lead to the warranty.
- Pre-job meeting
- A meeting of owner, consultant, contractor and manufacturer to agree on how the work will be done.
- Hybrid roof
- A roof with built-up roofing plies and a modified bitumen cap sheet.
- Abatement contractor
- A licensed contractor who removes asbestos and other hazardous materials.
- Dry-in
- Making a newly opened area of roof watertight before the end of the day.
- As-built plan
- A drawing showing how the roof was actually built, with drains, crickets and walkways.
- Workmanship warranty
- The roofer's own warranty covering its installation for a set period.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
A crew tears off and dries in 150 m² a day. How many days for 1,232 m²?
Show answer
1,232 ÷ 150 = 8.2, so 9 days.
Cap rolls cover 7.26 m² net. How many rolls, with 5 per cent waste, for 500 m²?
Show answer
500 ÷ 7.26 × 1.05 = 72.3, so 73 rolls.
Why did the job keep the last torch at 1:00 p.m. even when behind schedule?
Show answer
So the two-hour fire watch could be completed within the shift; time was recovered with extra crew instead.
What did the July 27 smoulder lead to?
Show answer
A new daily check for gaps under the edges of the flameless bands before torching.
Name three items in a closeout package.
Show answer
Manufacturer's warranty, workmanship warranty, as-built plan, product data, maintenance guide.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.