PWR-210 · Lesson 9 of 12 · 27 min
Combustion calculations
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
On Friday, October 23, 2026, Pilar Quenneville pushed the probe of the plant's portable flue gas analyzer into the test port on boiler 1's breeching and waited for the numbers to settle. "Three point oh oxygen, carbon monoxide twenty parts per million, stack 188 °C," she read out, and Tamar Ellingsen wrote them in the combustion log. "Fine," Pilar said. "Now tell me what those numbers mean. How much air is that burner using, how much of it is extra, and how much of the gas we paid for is going into steam?"
This lesson covers the chemistry of burning natural gas, the air needed for complete combustion, excess air and how to find it from a flue gas oxygen reading, higher and lower heating values, and how to calculate boiler efficiency by the input-output method. PWR-120 introduced combustion and burners; this lesson puts numbers on them.
The chemistry of combustion
Combustion is a rapid chemical reaction between a fuel and oxygen that releases heat. Natural gas is mostly methane, CH₄, with smaller amounts of ethane, propane, nitrogen and carbon dioxide. When methane burns completely, its carbon joins with oxygen to form carbon dioxide, and its hydrogen joins with oxygen to form water vapour.
The equation is balanced: one carbon atom, four hydrogen atoms and four oxygen atoms on each side. Read in molecules, or in volumes of gas, it says that each volume of methane needs exactly two volumes of oxygen. If there is not enough oxygen, some carbon forms carbon monoxide, CO, a poisonous gas that also wastes fuel, because burning carbon only as far as CO releases less than a third of the heat available from burning it to CO₂.
Combustion needs three things together: fuel, oxygen and enough heat to start and sustain the reaction. Good burners also provide the "three Ts": enough time for the reaction to finish, a high enough temperature, and enough turbulence to mix the fuel and air thoroughly.
Stoichiometric air
The exact amount of air that supplies just enough oxygen for complete combustion, with none left over, is the stoichiometric or theoretical air. Air is about 21 parts in 100 oxygen by volume and about 23.2 parts in 100 by mass; nearly all the rest is nitrogen, which passes through the flame and leaves with the flue gas.
Worked problem
Theoretical air for methane
How much air, by volume and by mass, is needed to burn one unit of methane completely?
Show solution
- By volume, each volume of methane needs 2 volumes of oxygen, and air is 0.21 oxygen:
- \[\text{air} = \frac{2}{0.21} \approx 9.52 \text{ volumes of air per volume of methane}\]
- By mass, using molar masses CH₄ = 16 and O₂ = 32, 16 kg of methane needs 64 kg of oxygen. Air is 0.232 oxygen by mass:
- \[\text{air} = \frac{64}{0.232} \approx 275.9 \text{ kg for 16 kg of methane}\]
- Per kilogram of methane:
- \[\frac{275.9}{16} \approx 17.24 \text{ kg of air per kg of methane}\]
Answer: About 9.5 cubic metres of air for each cubic metre of methane, or about 17.2 kg of air for each kilogram. Burning natural gas needs nearly ten times its own volume of air, which is why the forced draft fan is one of the largest motors in the plant.
Real natural gas contains small amounts of heavier hydrocarbons that need a little more air, and inert gases that need none, so the gas supplier's analysis gives a slightly different figure. For examination and plant estimates, methane is a good stand-in.
Excess air
No burner mixes fuel and air perfectly. To make sure every bit of fuel finds its oxygen, burners are set to supply more than the theoretical air. The extra is the excess air, usually stated as a fraction of the theoretical air. Too little excess air risks incomplete combustion, carbon monoxide, soot and, at worst, an explosive accumulation of unburned fuel. Too much excess air wastes heat, because every extra kilogram of air is heated from room temperature to stack temperature and carried out of the stack.
Excess air is found from the oxygen left in the flue gas. Any oxygen in the flue gas came in with the excess air, since the theoretical air's oxygen was all used up. Measured on a dry basis, a convenient approximation for natural gas is:
Here O₂ is the flue gas oxygen reading in parts per 100 by volume, dry, and 20.9 is the oxygen content of dry air on the same scale.
Worked problem
Excess air from an oxygen reading
Boiler 1 shows 3.0 parts in 100 oxygen in the flue gas. What is the excess air? What would it be at 2.0 and at 5.0?
Show solution
- At 3.0:
- \[\frac{3.0}{20.9 - 3.0} = \frac{3.0}{17.9} \approx 0.168\]
- At 2.0:
- \[\frac{2.0}{18.9} \approx 0.106\]
- At 5.0:
- \[\frac{5.0}{15.9} \approx 0.314\]
Answer: About 17 parts in 100 of excess air at 3.0 oxygen, about 11 at 2.0 and about 31 at 5.0. Pilar's reading is typical of a well-tuned gas burner at moderate load. Each burner has its own best setting, found during tuning by the service technician, which gives low carbon monoxide with the least excess air.
| Flue gas oxygen (dry, parts in 100) | Excess air (approximate) | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | about 5 in 100 | Very tight; carbon monoxide risk on most burners |
| 2.0 | about 11 in 100 | Good for a well-tuned gas burner |
| 3.0 | about 17 in 100 | Typical for gas at moderate load |
| 5.0 | about 31 in 100 | Wasteful unless the burner needs it at low fire |
| 8.0 | about 62 in 100 | Very wasteful; check for air leaks or poor tuning |
Carbon dioxide can be used the same way. Burning methane with exactly the theoretical air gives about 11.7 parts in 100 of CO₂ in the dry flue gas, the highest possible. Excess air dilutes it, so a lower CO₂ reading means more excess air. Oxygen is preferred because it changes more sharply with excess air and its meaning is the same for every fuel.
Watch out for air leaking into the boiler casing or breeching ahead of the test port. It raises the oxygen reading without passing through the burner, so the analyzer suggests more excess air than the burner actually has. Carbon monoxide readings should always be taken along with oxygen; a combination of high oxygen and high carbon monoxide points to poor mixing rather than too little air.
Air flow for a burner
Worked problem
How much air the burner moves
Boiler 1 is burning 860 m³/h of natural gas at 3.0 oxygen, with about 0.17 excess air. Treating the gas as methane, how much combustion air does the fan supply?
Show solution
- Theoretical air:
- \[860 \times 9.52 \approx 8{,}187 \text{ m}^3\text{/h}\]
- Actual air with 0.17 excess:
- \[8{,}187 \times 1.17 \approx 9{,}579 \text{ m}^3\text{/h}\]
Answer: About 9,600 m³ of air every hour, more than eleven times the gas volume. The flue gas leaving the boiler is a little more again, and it is very much hotter, so it needs an even larger volume.
Heating values
The heating value of a fuel is the heat released when a unit amount of it burns completely. Because burning hydrogen makes water, there are two ways to count it:
- The higher heating value (HHV), or gross calorific value, counts all the heat, including the latent heat released when the water vapour in the flue gas condenses back to liquid.
- The lower heating value (LHV), or net calorific value, leaves out that latent heat, on the basis that the water usually leaves the stack as vapour.
For natural gas, the LHV is roughly nine tenths of the HHV. Ontario gas typically has an HHV of about 37 to 39 MJ/m³, and the gas utility's bill states the value used for each billing period. Cantwell's current bill uses 37.3 MJ/m³, so the LHV is about 0.9 × 37.3 ≈ 33.6 MJ/m³.
North American practice is to state boiler efficiencies on the HHV basis, which gives lower numbers than the LHV basis used in much of Europe. When comparing efficiencies, always check which heating value was used. A condensing boiler, which cools its flue gas enough to condense some of the water vapour, recovers part of the latent heat that the LHV leaves out.
Boiler efficiency: the input-output method
The simplest way to find a boiler's efficiency is to measure what goes in and what comes out over the same period. The input is the fuel flow times its heating value. The output is the steam flow times the heat added to each unit of steam, which the steam tables give (lesson 7).
Worked problem
Efficiency of boiler 1
Over a steady hour, boiler 1 burns 860 m³ of gas (HHV 37.3 MJ/m³) and makes 11,300 kg of dry saturated steam at 1,136 kPa abs from feedwater at 105 °C. Lesson 7 found the heat added as 2,342 kJ/kg. What is the boiler efficiency?
Show solution
- Heat input:
- \[860 \times 37.3 = 32{,}078 \text{ MJ}\]
- Heat output:
- \[11{,}300 \times 2{,}342 \approx 26{,}465{,}000 \text{ kJ} = 26{,}465 \text{ MJ}\]
- Efficiency:
- \[\eta = \frac{26{,}465}{32{,}078} \approx 0.825\]
Answer: About 82.5 in 100 on the HHV basis, a normal figure for a gas-fired steam boiler without an economizer. The other 17.5 in 100 goes mostly up the stack as hot gas and water vapour, with smaller amounts lost from the casing and in blowdown.
The input-output method is simple, but it depends entirely on accurate meters. A gas meter or steam flow meter that is a few parts in 100 out gives an efficiency that is a few parts in 100 out. The alternative, the heat loss method, measures the losses instead, mainly from the stack temperature and oxygen reading, and subtracts them from the whole. Because the losses are small numbers, errors in measuring them matter less. Combustion analyzers estimate efficiency this way, and lesson 12 looks at the losses again.
Where the losses go
The largest loss in a gas-fired boiler is the dry flue gas loss: the heat carried away by the hot carbon dioxide, nitrogen and excess oxygen leaving the stack. It grows with the stack temperature and with the excess air. The second is the moisture loss: the latent and sensible heat in the water vapour formed by burning hydrogen, which is why gas has a larger gap between HHV and LHV than oil. Smaller losses come from radiation and convection from the boiler casing, from unburned fuel if combustion is poor, and from blowdown.
Two operating rules of thumb follow, both typical values worth checking against a combustion analyzer's own calculation. For a gas-fired boiler, each 20 °C (40 °F) rise in stack temperature at the same excess air costs roughly one point of efficiency. And reducing excess air from about 30 to about 15 in 100 typically gains about one point. Rising stack temperature at steady load, as PWR-120 showed on boiler 2, is the clearest early warning that heating surfaces are fouling.
Pilar's numbers
Tamar worked it through in the combustion log: about 17 in 100 excess air, about 9,600 m³/h of combustion air; carbon monoxide low; efficiency on the input-output check about 82.5 in 100. Pilar compared the analyzer's own efficiency estimate, which used the heat loss method and gave a figure within a point of Tamar's. "Close enough that I believe both meters," she said. "If they ever drift apart by three or four points, one of them is lying, and we find out which before we trust either."
Firing the backup fuel
Cantwell can switch its boilers to light fuel oil when the gas utility asks, as PWR-120 described. The same methods apply, with different numbers. Light fuel oil is mostly carbon and hydrogen in longer chains than methane, so it needs a little less air per kilogram of fuel, typically about 14 kg of air per kilogram of oil, and it has a typical HHV of about 45 MJ/kg, or about 38 MJ per litre. Because it has proportionally less hydrogen than gas, its gap between HHV and LHV is smaller, about one fifteenth instead of one tenth.
Oil burners usually run with somewhat more excess air than gas burners, because the oil must first be broken into fine droplets and evaporated before it can burn, and poor atomization quickly produces smoke and soot. A typical oil flue gas oxygen of about 3 to 4 parts in 100 is common. The same excess air formula applies, but the maximum possible carbon dioxide is higher for oil, about 15 parts in 100, so carbon dioxide readings mean something different on each fuel. Operators also check smoke readings on oil, since soot on the tubes (lesson 8) builds up much faster on oil than on gas. After any fuel switch, a fresh combustion test confirms that the burner is set correctly for the new fuel.
Common mistakes
MistakeThinking more excess air is always safer.
InsteadSome is needed for complete combustion; too much wastes heat up the stack.
MistakeReading high oxygen with high carbon monoxide as a lack of air.
InsteadThat combination points to poor mixing or flame trouble.
MistakeComparing an HHV efficiency with an LHV one.
InsteadCheck the basis; LHV efficiencies read higher.
MistakeIgnoring air leaks ahead of the test port.
InsteadLeaks raise oxygen readings without passing through the burner.
MistakeTrusting the input-output efficiency without checking the meters.
InsteadMeter errors pass straight into the result.
Summary and key terms
- Methane burns as CH₄ + 2 O₂ → CO₂ + 2 H₂O.
- Theoretical air for methane is about 9.52 volumes per volume, or about 17.2 by mass.
- Excess air fraction ≈ O₂ ÷ (20.9 − O₂), from a dry flue gas oxygen reading.
- The HHV counts the latent heat of the water formed; the LHV does not, and is about 0.9 of the HHV for gas.
- Input-output efficiency = steam flow × heat added per unit ÷ (fuel flow × heating value).
- Dry flue gas loss and moisture loss are the largest boiler losses; stack temperature and excess air drive them.
- Stoichiometric air
- The exact amount of air needed for complete combustion with no oxygen left over.
- Excess air
- Air supplied beyond the stoichiometric amount, stated as a fraction of it.
- Higher heating value
- The heat released by burning a fuel, including the latent heat of the water formed.
- Lower heating value
- The heat released by burning a fuel, excluding the latent heat of the water formed.
- Input-output method
- Finding boiler efficiency by dividing measured heat output by measured fuel input.
- Heat loss method
- Finding boiler efficiency by measuring the losses and subtracting them from the whole.
- Dry flue gas loss
- The heat carried out of the stack by hot, dry combustion gases.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
What is the excess air at 4.0 oxygen in the flue gas?
Show answer
About 0.24, or 24 in 100 (4.0 ÷ 16.9).
How much theoretical air does 100 m³ of methane need?
Show answer
About 952 m³.
A gas has an HHV of 38.0 MJ/m³. Estimate its LHV.
Show answer
About 34.2 MJ/m³.
A boiler uses 500 m³/h of gas at 37.3 MJ/m³ and produces 15,000 MJ/h of heat in steam. What is its efficiency?
Show answer
About 0.80 (15,000 ÷ 18,650).
What two readings should always be taken together on a combustion test?
Show answer
Oxygen and carbon monoxide.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.