IRW-330 · Lesson 11 of 12 · 23 min

Quality and warranty items

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

On Friday, August 14, 2026, at 10:00 a.m., Corwin walked the finished Brannock building with Dale and Erin Brannock and Northfield's field representative, who had driven out to inspect the building for the manufacturer's records. They walked the outside first, then the inside, with a clipboard, a flashlight and a pair of binoculars for the roof. The punch list at the end of the walk had eleven items. Corwin had found and fixed nineteen more the day before, on his own walk with Juno.

This lesson covers the quality side of a metal building job: the erector's checks during the work, the tolerances a finished building must meet, the final walk and punch list, the warranties that come with a metal building and what voids them, and the records that go to the owner.

Quality is built in, not inspected in

Most of what makes a metal building last cannot be seen once it is finished. Anchor rods are buried under base plates, bolts are hidden inside frames, flange braces and sag rods are behind panels, and fasteners are under trim. If they were not checked when they were installed, they never will be. That is why Corwin's crew checked each part of the building as it was completed, before the next part covered it, and recorded each check in the binder.

Crossbeam's quality checks on the Brannock job, recorded in the binder.
StageWhat was checkedWhen on Brannock
FoundationBuilding lines, diagonals, anchor rods: location, spacing, projection, elevationJune 22
ShipmentEvery piece and bundle against the shipping list; damage photographedJuly 6 and with later loads
FramesPart marks, orientation, bolts installed, plumbness, pretensioningJuly 7 to 14
BracingEvery brace present, correct, connected and snugJuly 14, again August 13
Secondary framingLaps, bolts, flange braces, sag rods, eave strutsJuly 13 to 17, before panels
InsulationFacing continuous, tabs sealed, tears patchedWith each run of panels
PanelsCoverage, plumb and square, fastener pattern and seating, laps sealedDaily, July 20 to 31
Trim and accessoriesLaps shed water, closures in, sealant, alignmentAugust 4 to 12
CleanupSwarf removed, scratches touched up, debris clearedDaily and August 13

Tolerances

A finished metal building must meet tolerances for plumbness, alignment and flatness, set by the manufacturer's notes, the project specification and the codes of standard practice the manufacturer refers to. For the frames, the common rule for columns is that a column is plumb within about 1 in 500 of its height, which follows the same principle as the conventional steel tolerances in IRW-210.

Worked problem

Column plumbness

A Brannock rigid frame column is 6.0 m tall from base to eave. Using a tolerance of 1 in 500, how far out of plumb may the top be?

Show solution
  1. Allowable = 6 000 mm ÷ 500 = 12 mm.

Answer: 12 mm at the top. Corwin's crew aimed for half of that, because a column at the limit makes the wall panels harder to line up and shows in the trim. The worst column on the building measured 5 mm out.

Other tolerances that matter on a metal building are less formal but just as visible.

  • Eave struts straight from end to end, so the eave trim and gutter run straight.
  • Purlins in plane, so the roof does not show waves, and at the right spacing for the fastener rows.
  • Panel ribs plumb on the walls and square to the eave on the roof, with no creep at the corners.
  • Fastener rows straight and on the girts and purlins, with every washer properly seated.
  • Trim straight, tight and lapped correctly, with no gaps at corners.

Owners judge a metal building mostly by what they see. A building can be structurally perfect and still be refused for crooked screw rows or a wavy eave. Metal panels also show oil canning, a waviness in the flat parts of the panel, which is a characteristic of thin flat steel and not usually a defect, but which installation can make worse by overdriving fasteners or forcing panels into misaligned framing. Manufacturers' literature usually says plainly that oil canning is not a cause for rejection; an erector still avoids making it worse.

Bolt and fastener checks

The frame connections on the Brannock building were pretensioned by turn-of-nut, as Northfield's notes required. After plumbing, the crew snugged every bolt, match-marked each nut and bolt end with paint, turned each nut the required rotation and checked that the marks had moved the right amount. The match marks are what a field representative or inspector looks for, because they show that every bolt was turned. Bolts in the secondary framing are snug-tight only, and the check there is that every hole has its bolt and every nut is tight.

Worked problem

A fastener audit

On August 13, Corwin and Juno audited the roof fasteners by checking ten panels chosen at random. Each panel should have 37 screws in the pattern for that location. They counted 366 screws correctly placed and seated across the ten panels. How many were missing or faulty, and what share is that?

Show solution
  1. Expected = 10 × 37 = 370 screws.
  2. Missing or faulty = 370 − 366 = 4.
  3. Share = 4 ÷ 370 = 0.011, about 1 in 100.

Answer: Four screws, about 1 in 100. Three had missed the purlin and one washer was overdriven. Because the audit found faults, Corwin had the crew walk every screw row on the roof that afternoon with a straight edge and a light, and they found and fixed eleven more. A small sample is a check on the work, not a substitute for it.

The final walk and punch list

At the end of a metal building job, the builder walks the building with the owner, and often with the manufacturer's representative and the building inspector, and lists every item that needs correcting. The erector fixes the list and the owner signs off. A good erector walks the building first, alone, and fixes everything they can find, so the owner's list is short.

The Brannock punch list from the final walk on August 14, 2026.
No.ItemAction
1Scratch on rake trim, north-west cornerTouch up with manufacturer's paint
2Two screws missing at front gutter strapInstall
3Sealant smear on wainscot near big doorClean with approved cleaner
4Light panel 4 screen has one loose fastenerTighten
5Walk door, back sidewall, closer not adjustedDoor crew to adjust
6Downspout at north-east corner lacks splash blockOwner to supply; set
7Base trim dent at sprayer doorReplace trim piece
8Swarf in ribs at roof bay 6–7Sweep and check for staining
9Gap at corner trim, south-eastAdd closure and sealant
10Big door weather seal not touching floor at one endDoor crew to adjust
11Ridge vent end closure missing, bay 4–5Install

Corwin's crew closed nine of the eleven items that afternoon; Elmridge's door crew closed the two door items the next week. Corwin photographed each item before and after and put the photographs in the binder.

Warranties

A metal building comes with several warranties, each from a different party and each covering something different. An erector needs to know them because many of them depend on how the building was erected.

  • The manufacturer's material warranty covers defects in the steel components for a stated period.
  • Panel coating warranties cover the paint, against film failure such as peeling or cracking and against chalking and fading beyond stated limits, often for twenty to forty years depending on the paint system, and the metallic coating against perforation by corrosion. These periods are typical; each product's warranty sets its own.
  • A weathertightness warranty, offered mainly on standing seam roofs, covers leaks in the roof system for a stated period. It usually requires the erector to be trained or certified by the manufacturer for that system and the roof to be inspected by the manufacturer during and after installation.
  • The builder's or erector's workmanship warranty covers the installation, often for one or two years; Crossbeam's was two years on metal buildings.

Warranties have exclusions, and many of them are erection mistakes. A coating warranty usually excludes damage from abrasive cutting, swarf, scratches, contact with incompatible materials, and panels stored wet. A weathertightness warranty is void if the roof was installed by an uncertified crew, if the manufacturer's details were not followed, or if someone later cuts holes for equipment without the manufacturer's approval. The structural design itself may no longer be the manufacturer's responsibility if members were cut, welded or left out in the field.

Erectors can also hold their own quality credentials. In Canada, CSA A660 covers manufacturers, and some specifications ask erectors to show training records from the manufacturer. In the US, the International Accreditation Service runs an accreditation program for metal building assemblers, AC478, alongside the manufacturers' AC472, and some specifications and building officials ask for it.

The building inspection

The Brannock building was a farm building, and in Ontario many farm buildings are still subject to a building permit and inspection by the municipality, with requirements adapted to low human occupancy. Haldimand County's building inspector inspected the footings before the pour and the finished building on August 13, checking the anchor rods, the bracing, the framed openings and the manufacturer's sealed drawings, and closed the permit.

The hand-over binder

Corwin's binder had two copies. The one he lent Shay was Crossbeam's file copy. The other went to the Brannocks on August 14 with the keys. It held what an owner needs to keep a metal building in service for decades.

  • The manufacturer's sealed erection drawings and design summary, including the design loads.
  • The bracing plan, marked, with a note never to remove bracing or cut a braced bay without the manufacturer's approval.
  • Warranty certificates, with what voids them.
  • The panel colour and profile names and the touch-up paint, so repairs match.
  • Maintenance notes: keep gutters clear, keep snow off the light panels, check fasteners and sealant every few years, wash the panels, and keep fertilizer and corrosive materials off the wall panels.
  • The notes from the final walk: the heated workshop corner, the hoist question and the first-winter ventilation.

Erin Brannock read the maintenance notes on the spot and asked one question: how often should they look at the roof? Corwin said once a year, from a ladder at the eave or with binoculars from the ground, and after every big storm, and never by walking past the light panels.

Touch-up and cleaning

Some scratches and cut edges are unavoidable, and the manufacturer supplies touch-up paint in the panel colour for them. Touch-up is applied sparingly with a small brush, only to the scratch itself, because the touch-up paint weathers differently from the factory coating and a large patch shows as a different shade within a year. Large damaged areas mean a replacement panel, not paint. Spray cans are not used on the panels, because overspray drifts and spots the surrounding coating.

Cleaning at the end of the job removes the marks every job leaves: chalk lines, sealant smears, footprints and handprints, and dust. The crew cleans the panels with water and a mild cleaner the manufacturer approves, never with solvents or abrasive pads that can dull or remove the paint. On the Brannock job, Tobin spent most of the morning of August 13 washing chalk lines off the wainscot and the big door trim while Corwin and Juno did the fastener audit on the roof.

Debris goes last: offcuts, screw boxes, packing, banding, broken closures and the cribbing. Steel offcuts and swarf are collected with a magnet sweeper around the building, because a farm site has tires and animals that find every sharp scrap. Corwin asked the Brannocks to drive their truck around the building once after the sweep, and nothing was punctured.

Records that matter later

Years after a building is finished, the records made during erection answer questions that nobody can answer from the building itself: which bolts were pretensioned and how, where the repaired rod group is, which panels were replaced and why, and who installed the roof. A manufacturer considering a warranty claim, an engineer designing an addition or an insurer looking at storm damage will ask for them. That is why Corwin's file copy of the binder is kept at Crossbeam for the life of the warranty and beyond.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeChecking work only at the end.

    InsteadCheck each part before the next part hides it, and record the check.

  • MistakePretensioning bolts without match marks.

    InsteadMatch-mark every pretensioned bolt so the turn can be seen.

  • MistakeTreating oil canning as a defect to fix by over-tightening.

    InsteadExplain it as a characteristic of flat steel and avoid making it worse.

  • MistakeUsing an uncertified crew on a warranted standing seam roof.

    InsteadUse crews trained or certified for that roof system.

  • MistakeHanding over without maintenance and warranty information.

    InsteadGive the owner the drawings, warranties, colours and maintenance notes.

Summary and key terms

  • Quality is built in by checking each part before it is covered.
  • Columns are plumbed within about 1 in 500, and alignment of struts, purlins, panels, fasteners and trim decides how the building looks.
  • Pretensioned bolts are match-marked; fasteners are checked by sample and by walking the rows.
  • The final walk and punch list close out the job.
  • Material, coating, weathertightness and workmanship warranties each have exclusions, many caused by erection mistakes.
  • The owner receives a hand-over binder with drawings, warranties, colours and maintenance notes.
Punch list
The list of items to correct at the final walk of a job.
Match marking
Paint marks on a nut and bolt end that show the nut was turned the required amount.
Oil canning
Visible waviness in the flat areas of metal panels, characteristic of thin flat steel.
Weathertightness warranty
A warranty against roof leaks, usually for standing seam roofs, with conditions on the installer.
Coating warranty
A warranty on a panel's paint and metallic coating against failure, fading and perforation.
Hand-over binder
The owner's file of drawings, warranties and maintenance information for the building.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. How far out of plumb may a 7.5 m column be at 1 in 500?

    Show answer

    7 500 ÷ 500 = 15 mm.

  2. Twelve panels need 30 screws each and 352 are found correct. How many are missing or faulty?

    Show answer

    360 − 352 = 8.

  3. Name two things that commonly void a coating warranty.

    Show answer

    Any two of: abrasive cutting, swarf, scratches, wet storage, incompatible materials.

  4. Why is the erector's own walk done before the owner's?

    Show answer

    To find and fix as much as possible so the owner's list is short.

  5. What should the bracing note in the hand-over binder say?

    Show answer

    Never remove bracing or cut a braced bay without the manufacturer's approval.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz