INS-420 · Lesson 6 of 12 · 23 min
Scaffold and access planning
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
On Tuesday morning, November 10, Bernie Valois spent two hours in Coldstream's office with Raj, going through the Ridgemount drawings page by page. Raj called it a constructability review: an experienced foreperson reads the job the way the crew will meet it, and points out what the drawings do not say. Most of Bernie's notes were about access. "The gym supply ducts are at eight and a half metres," she said, pointing at the section. "That's a lift, not a ladder, and the gym floor goes in before we get there, so it'll need floor protection. And the mechanical room headers are stacked three high over the boilers. Somebody has to plan how we reach the top one."
Access is one of the most underestimated costs in insulation work. A crew that spends a quarter of its day moving ladders, waiting for a lift or rebuilding a scaffold is installing insulation only three quarters of the time. This lesson covers the common access methods, the main Ontario rules for scaffolds and elevating work platforms, how to choose access for each area of a job, and how to price it.
Access methods
Insulators reach their work in five main ways, each suited to a range of heights and conditions:
| Method | Typical use | Limits |
|---|---|---|
| Step ladders and platform ladders | Ceilings up to about 3.5 m (12 ft), short tasks, light materials | Frequent moves; one person per ladder; little room for material |
| Rolling scaffold towers | Ceilings of 3 to 6 m (10 to 20 ft) on level floors, longer runs in one area | Height limited by base size; floors must be level and clear; moved by hand |
| Frame or system scaffold | Long work at one location: tall equipment, shafts, boiler fronts | Erected and inspected by competent workers; takes time to build and move |
| Scissor lifts | Large open areas such as gyms and warehouses, with a level slab | Vertical reach only; floor loading and protection |
| Boom lifts | Reaching over obstacles, outdoor racks, uneven ground | Larger, heavier and costlier; fall protection required in the basket |
Height is only one factor. A rolling tower needs a level, clear floor, so it is no use in a mechanical room full of pumps. A scissor lift needs a slab that can carry it and a route to get there, and it cannot reach over a row of equipment. A boom lift can reach over obstacles but needs room to swing. A frame scaffold suits work that stays in one place for days, such as a boiler front or a tall tank, but costs too much time to move for work spread along a corridor.
The rules for scaffolds
In Ontario, the construction regulation, O. Reg. 213/91, sets the rules for scaffolds, and CSA Z797, the code of practice for access scaffold, gives guidance on their erection and use. In summary, in our own words:
- A scaffold must be designed by a professional engineer, and built to that design, if it is more than 15 m above its base support, or more than 10 m for a tube and clamp scaffold. Before such a scaffold is used, an engineer or a competent worker designated by the supervisor must inspect it and confirm in writing that it matches the design.
- A scaffold and its components must be able to carry at least twice the maximum load without exceeding the material's limits, and four times the load without overturning. Its footings must be firm and carry at least twice the maximum load.
- Scaffolds must be secured to the structure at vertical intervals of no more than three times their least base dimension. A rolling scaffold must have its wheels locked while in use and must follow the maker's limits on height and base size.
- Only competent workers may supervise the erection, alteration and dismantling of a scaffold, and nobody may load a scaffold or a platform beyond its rated capacity. Working platforms must carry a uniform load of at least 2.4 kN/m².
The fall protection rules from INS-110 still apply on every platform and ladder: guardrails where they are required, a fall arrest system where they are not practical, and a rescue plan for anyone working in a harness. Mei Zhou keeps Coldstream's scaffold and fall protection training records, and the site supervisor or general contractor usually requires a copy before anyone works at height.
Worked problem
How tall can the tower go?
Coldstream's rolling towers have a base of 1.5 m by 2.4 m. The maker's instructions limit the platform height to three times the least base dimension without outriggers. How high can the platform be?
Show solution
- Least base dimension: 1.5 m.
- Limit: 3 × 1.5 = 4.5 m to the platform without outriggers.
- With the maker's outriggers fitted, the base is wider and the limit higher, as the instructions state.
Answer: A platform at 4.5 m reaches work at about 6 m, which covers the classroom ceilings but not the gym. The maker's limit is a sample figure; always follow the instructions for the tower in use.
Elevating work platforms
Scissor lifts and boom lifts are elevating work platforms (EWPs), also called mobile elevating work platforms (MEWPs). In Ontario, O. Reg. 213/91 requires that they be designed, built and maintained to the CSA B354 series of standards, that operators be trained on the type of machine they use, and that the platform's rated load and the maker's instructions be followed. Workers in a boom lift basket wear a full body harness attached to the anchor in the basket. A scissor lift's guardrails are its fall protection, unless the maker or the site rules require more.
For estimating, lifts bring three extra considerations. The floor must carry the lift's weight, so a lift on an upper floor or a suspended slab needs the general contractor's or engineer's approval. The finished floor may need protection: Ridgemount's gym floor would be installed before the duct insulation, so Bernie's note asked for plywood runways or non-marking tires and a floor protection plan. And lifts must be charged, delivered and picked up, which takes time and money.
Choosing access area by area
Bernie's constructability notes for Ridgemount gave access for each part of the building:
- Classroom wings: ceilings about 3.6 m (12 ft) with the pipe and duct about 3.0 to 3.4 m (10 to 11 ft) up. Platform ladders for short branches and rolling towers for the mains, with the height factor from lesson 5.
- Corridors: mains in a narrow corridor ceiling, about 2.4 m (8 ft) wide. A narrow tower, moved often.
- Gymnasium: supply ducts at about 8.5 m (28 ft). A scissor lift with floor protection, for about two weeks.
- Mechanical room: headers stacked over boilers and pumps. Platform ladders for the low headers, a small system scaffold over the boilers for the top header, built by the scaffold supplier and inspected before use.
- Roof: short outdoor runs to the rooftop units, inside the roof guardrails provided by the general contractor.
Choosing access area by area matters because the cost is not only the rental. Each move of a tower, ladder or lift takes crew time, and an access method that does not fit the work makes every task slower. Some estimators price access entirely in the labour factors; Coldstream prices the equipment as a separate line and the moves in the hours, so that both can be checked.
Pricing access
Access costs fall into three parts: equipment, set-up and moves, and lost productivity. Equipment owned by the company, such as Coldstream's rolling towers and ladders, is charged at an internal rate per week. Rented equipment is priced from the rental company's rates plus delivery and pickup. Scaffold built by a scaffold contractor is priced from that contractor's quotation, which includes erection, inspection, rental time and dismantling.
Worked problem
The gymnasium lift
Bernie expects the gymnasium duct to need a scissor lift for two weeks. A sample rental rate is 1,150 dollars a week, with 300 dollars for delivery and pickup. The gym duct has about 74 m² of surface, at the duct wrap unit of 0.18 h/m² plus a lift factor of 20 in 100, and the crew expects about six lift moves of half an hour each for two people. What does access add to the gym work?
Show solution
- Equipment: 2 × 1,150 + 300 = 2,600 dollars.
- Base hours: 74 × 0.18 = 13.3 h; with the lift factor: 74 × 0.18 × 1.2 = 16.0 h, so the factor adds 2.7 h.
- Moves: 6 × 0.5 × 2 = 6.0 h.
- Access labour: 2.7 + 6.0 = 8.7 h, or 8.7 × 96 = 835 dollars at the sample rate.
Answer: Access adds about 3,435 dollars to work whose base labour is only about 1,280 dollars. That is normal for a small amount of high work, and it is why high areas are priced separately.
On a general contractor's site, some access may be provided by others. Some contracts make the general contractor responsible for all scaffold, or let trades share a lift. The tender documents usually say who supplies what, and an estimator who assumes the general contractor will provide something should state it in the qualifications. Raj's Ridgemount quotation said: "Includes rolling towers, ladders and one scissor lift for the gymnasium. Excludes scaffold over 3 m (10 ft) in the mechanical room, assumed by others; add price available."
Access on site
Planning does not end with the estimate. On site, the foreperson checks every access item before use, follows the maker's instructions and the site rules, and keeps the area under work clear. A tower that has a missing brace, a lift whose daily check was skipped or a ladder set on a pump base is how insulators get hurt. Mei's inspection of Coldstream's rolling towers at Mountview on Monday, October 19, before the penthouse work started, found one tower with a cracked caster; it went back to the shop and was replaced the same day.
Ladders: the most common access, and the most misused
Ladders are the access insulators use most, and they cause a large share of falls in construction. The rules are simple and well known, yet broken every day: the right ladder for the height and the task; inspected before use; set on firm, level footing; extension ladders at the correct angle, about one out for every four up, and secured or held; three points of contact while climbing; tools and material raised by line or carried in a pouch, not in the hands; and nobody standing higher on a step ladder than the maker's label allows. O. Reg. 213/91 and the maker's instructions set the details. A ladder is for short tasks; work that keeps a person on a ladder for long periods, or needs both hands and heavy material, belongs on a platform.
Platform ladders, with a small standing platform and a guardrail at the top, are a good compromise for insulation work at classroom ceiling heights. They let an insulator work with both hands at a steady height, and they move quickly. Coldstream bought more of them in 2025 after its job reviews showed that crews on ordinary step ladders were slower and more tired by the afternoon.
Access on plant work
In a plant such as Kellerton, access has extra constraints. Scaffold over live equipment must be planned with the owner, often with a permit. Lifts may be banned from certain floors or need a spotter in forklift traffic. Racks over roadways may need traffic control. And during an outage, the scaffold contractor, the insulators, the pipefitters and the plant's maintenance staff all want the same scaffold at the same time. The access plan for an outage is agreed weeks in advance, scaffold is built before the shutdown starts wherever possible, and each trade's time on it is scheduled. The yard rack job in INS-220 used two lifts over a truck lane; the plan included the hours when trucks could not use it.
Who supplies and inspects
On a large site, several kinds of access may be in use by different trades at once, and responsibility must be clear. The trade that rents or owns a lift is responsible for its maintenance and its operators' training; a scaffold built by a scaffold contractor is that contractor's to inspect and tag, but each worker on it must check the tag and the platform before use. Coldstream's rule is that nobody uses another trade's access without that trade's permission and a check of its condition, because a borrowed ladder with a cracked rail injures the borrower just as surely.
Common mistakes
MistakeChoosing access by height alone.
InsteadConsider floor conditions, obstacles, duration and how often the access must move.
MistakeIgnoring the maker's height limits on a rolling tower.
InsteadFollow the instructions and fit outriggers or ties where required.
MistakePutting a lift on a finished or suspended floor without checking.
InsteadGet approval for floor loading and plan floor protection.
MistakePricing the rental but not the moves.
InsteadAdd the crew time for set-up and moves, and the productivity factor for work at height.
MistakeAssuming the general contractor will supply scaffold.
InsteadCheck the documents and state the assumption in the qualifications.
Summary and key terms
- Insulators work from ladders, rolling towers, frame or system scaffold, scissor lifts and boom lifts, each suited to different heights and conditions.
- O. Reg. 213/91 and CSA Z797 govern scaffolds in Ontario: engineering above 15 m, strength and stability margins, ties at three times the base, competent workers, and rated loads.
- Lifts need trained operators, harnesses in boom baskets, floor loading approval and floor protection.
- Access is chosen area by area, and priced as equipment, set-up and moves, and lost productivity.
- Qualifications state what access is included and what is assumed to be supplied by others.
- Constructability review
- A review of drawings by an experienced field person to find practical problems before work starts.
- Rolling scaffold
- A scaffold tower on locking wheels, moved by hand on level floors.
- Elevating work platform
- A machine with a platform that raises workers, such as a scissor or boom lift (EWP or MEWP).
- Outrigger
- An arm that widens the base of a scaffold to improve its stability.
- Floor protection
- Boards, mats or runways that protect a finished floor from equipment.
- Competent worker
- A worker trained and experienced in a task and its hazards, as defined in the safety rules.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
Why is a rolling tower a poor choice in a crowded mechanical room?
Show answer
It needs a level, clear floor and room to move.
Above what height must an Ontario scaffold be designed by a professional engineer?
Show answer
More than 15 m above its base support, or 10 m for tube and clamp scaffold.
What two things must be checked before a scissor lift goes onto a finished gym floor?
Show answer
The floor's ability to carry it and the floor protection.
A lift rents for 1,150 dollars a week plus 300 for delivery. What do three weeks cost?
Show answer
3,750 dollars.
What did Raj's quotation say about mechanical room scaffold?
Show answer
That scaffold over 3 m (10 ft) there was excluded and assumed by others, with an add price available.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.