GAS-210 · Lesson 12 of 12 · 31 min
Case study: replacing a furnace and water heater
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
In late October, Farah and Daniel Okoye called Bayline about the furnace in their 1958 one-and-a-half-story house on Highland Avenue in the Hilltop. It was a 1999 mid-efficiency furnace with an input of 100,000 Btu/h, and on its last service the technician had found heavy rust on the burners and flaking scale inside the heat exchanger openings. It still ran, but it was 27 years old. Their water heater, an atmospheric 40-gallon tank from 2012, shared the house's masonry chimney with it. The Okoyes wanted a quote for a new furnace. This case study follows the job from that call to the start-up sheets on Tuesday, November 10, and shows how the decisions in this course fit together.
The first visit
Hank Morrow made the estimating visit himself, with Jonah along to learn how it is done. Before talking about equipment, Hank measured the house: room dimensions, window and door sizes, wall and attic insulation where he could see it, and the basement walls. Back at the office he ran a room-by-room heat loss calculation with ACCA Manual J. The result was a design heat loss of 44,000 Btu/h at Columbus's winter design temperature, far below the old furnace's output. The house had been insulated and re-windowed since 1999, and the old furnace had probably been oversized even then.
Hank also measured the existing duct system's external static pressure with the old furnace's blower on its heating speed: 0.42 in. w.c.. The ducts were sheet metal, mostly sealed, with one undersized return in the living room. He checked the gas piping: a 3/4-inch line from the meter to the furnace and water heater, with the range on its own branch. He measured CO in the house and at the appliances, all clear, and tested the water heater for spillage under worst-case conditions. It drafted properly with the furnace running, which, as lesson 4 explained, was partly because the furnace's hot flue gas kept the chimney warm.
Choosing the furnace
With a heat loss of 44,000 Btu/h, Hank chose a two-stage condensing furnace with a high-fire input of 60,000 Btu/h and an output of 57,600 Btu/h, the furnace from lesson 1's first example, with an AFUE of 96. In Ohio a mid-efficiency furnace could still be installed, but the Okoyes chose condensing for its efficiency, and because a mid-efficiency replacement would have needed a new chimney liner anyway. Its low fire, about 65 in every 100 units of its full input, would carry the house through most of the season in long cycles.
Worked problem
Is the new furnace the right size?
The new furnace delivers 57,600 Btu/h at high fire and the house loses 44,000 Btu/h on a design day. The old furnace delivered about 80,000 Btu/h. Compare each with the heat loss.
Show solution
- New furnace:
- \[\frac{57\,600}{44\,000} \approx 1.31\]
- Old furnace:
- \[\frac{80\,000}{44\,000} \approx 1.82\]
Answer: The new furnace has a margin of about 1.3 times the design heat loss, which allows for recovery after setbacks without gross oversizing, and its low fire is close to the house's average winter load. The old furnace was about 1.8 times too large, which explained the Okoyes' complaint of short, noisy cycles and uneven rooms.
The new furnace's blower was rated to deliver the airflow it needed at up to 0.50 in. w.c. of external static pressure. The existing ducts had measured 0.42 in. w.c. with the old blower, so Hank expected to stay within the limit, but he recommended adding a second return in the living room to bring the static pressure down and quiet the system. The Okoyes agreed, and Bayline's sheet metal crew added it on the Monday morning.
The water heater decision
The furnace choice created a second decision. With the old furnace gone, the water heater would sit alone in the masonry chimney, the orphaned water heater problem GAS-120 described and the Upper Arlington job in lesson 4 showed in practice. There were two sound options. Bayline could install a liner sized for the water heater alone, as on the earlier job, and leave the 14-year-old water heater in place. Or it could replace the water heater with one that did not need the chimney at all, and take both appliances out of it.
Hank set out both options for the Okoyes with their costs and the water heater's age: storage water heaters commonly last somewhere in the range of 8 to 15 years, and theirs was near the end of that range, with a little rust at the base of the jacket. Lining the chimney for an old water heater and replacing the water heater a year or two later would mean paying twice. The Okoyes chose to replace it with a power-vent storage water heater, vented in plastic through the basement wall beside the furnace's pipes, which meant the chimney would no longer serve any gas appliance.
Worked problem
Checking the water heater size
The household of four has a peak hour demand estimated at about 77 gallons: two showers, a dishwasher and a sink. The new 50-gallon power-vent water heater has an input of 40,000 Btu/h, a recovery efficiency of 0.80 and a first-hour rating of 82 gallons. What is its recovery rate through a 90 °F rise, and does its FHR meet the demand?
Show solution
- Heat delivered:
- \[40\,000 \times 0.80 = 32\,000 \text{ Btu/h}\]
- Recovery:
- \[\frac{32\,000}{8.33 \times 90} = \frac{32\,000}{749.7} \approx 42.7 \text{ gal/h}\]
- Compare the FHR with demand:
- \[82 \text{ gal} > 77 \text{ gal}\]
Answer: The tank recovers about 42.7 gallons per hour, and its first-hour rating of 82 gallons covers the household's busiest hour with a small margin. A larger tank was not needed.
With two appliances changing, the gas load changed too. The new furnace and water heater together had an input of 100,000 Btu/h, the same as the old furnace alone and less than the old pair's 140,000 Btu/h. Hank checked the 3/4-inch line against Bayline's sizing tables for the new loads and the range; it was adequate with margin, so no piping changes were needed beyond the connections at each appliance. Bayline's office pulled a mechanical permit from the City of Columbus Building and Zoning Services, and Bayline's electrical partner pulled an electrical permit for the water heater's receptacle.
Monday: removal and installation
On Monday, November 9, Rosa and Jonah arrived at 7:30. Jonah took CO readings at the door and in the basement, all zero, and photographed the old installation. They shut off and locked out both appliances, proved them dead, drained the old water heater through a hose to the floor drain, and disconnected and capped the gas lines. The old furnace came out in pieces through the basement stairs. The air-conditioning coil on top of the old furnace was nearly new and was supported while the furnace under it was swapped, with no refrigerant work needed.
The two vent connector openings into the chimney were sealed at the basement thimble with a masonry patch, and Jonah fixed a label to it saying the chimney no longer served any gas appliance. Rosa recommended that the Okoyes have a mason cap the chimney top, which they booked for later in the month, and noted it on the job sheet. A chimney left open but unused is not a gas hazard, but it lets rain in and warm air out.
The new furnace went on a new pad, leveled and pitched as its instructions required for the condensate. Rosa and Jonah connected the gas supply with a new manual valve, a union and a sediment trap, supported independently. The exhaust and intake pipes, Schedule 40 PVC as the instructions listed, ran 15 ft with three elbows to a two-pipe sidewall termination on the side wall. Before drilling, Jonah measured every clearance the instructions and the code required: from the gas meter and its regulator vent, the nearest window, the property line, the ground and the expected snow level, and from the water heater's terminal. The condensate drained through a neutralizer to the floor drain.
The new water heater went where the old one had been, on a fresh pad. Jonah connected the gas with a new valve, union and sediment trap, and the water lines with new dielectric fittings. He fitted the T&P valve's discharge line full size to 6 inches above the floor drain. The house had a check valve on its water service, so he added a thermal expansion tank on the cold line, charged to the house's water pressure. The power-vent's PVC pipe ran 10 ft with two elbows to its own terminal, sloped as the instructions required. Bayline's electrical partner installed the receptacle for its blower in the afternoon.
Tuesday: start-up
On Tuesday morning the new return was finished and the gas connections were leak tested and purged. Jonah primed the furnace's condensate trap, filled the water heater, and checked that air had been bled from the hot water lines. Then he started each appliance in turn, following its instructions and Bayline's start-up sheet, with Rosa watching. He measured the inlet pressure at the furnace: 7.0 in. w.c. static and 6.6 in. w.c. with the furnace, the water heater and all four range burners running, well above the plate minimum. He set the manifold pressures to the plate values, 3.5 in. w.c. at high fire and 1.7 in. w.c. at low fire.
Worked problem
Clocking the new furnace
With only the furnace running at high fire, the meter's half-cubic-foot test dial takes 30.5 s per revolution. The gas is 1,000 Btu per cubic foot and the plate input is 60,000 Btu/h. What is the measured input, and how close is it to the plate?
Show solution
- Flow:
- \[\frac{0.5 \times 3600}{30.5} = 59.0 \ \text{ft}^3\text{/h}\]
- Input:
- \[59.0 \times 1000 = 59\,000 \text{ Btu/h}\]
- Difference:
- \[\frac{60\,000 - 59\,000}{60\,000} \approx 0.017\]
Answer: The measured input is about 59,000 Btu/h, under 2 in 100 below the plate, within the instructions' allowance. The orifices, manifold pressure and gas were as expected.
The flames were steady and blue and entered the heat exchanger cleanly. After ten minutes at high fire, Jonah measured a supply temperature of 124 °F and a return of 70 °F, a temperature rise of 54 °F, inside the plate's range of 35 to 65 °F. The external static pressure, with the new return in place and a clean filter, was +0.28 and −0.18 in. w.c., a total of 0.46 in. w.c., under the maximum. The combustion analysis at the furnace's test port gave readings inside the instructions' ranges, with an air-free CO of 22 ppm. He checked the low-fire stage the same way, then tested the safety controls as the instructions described.
Worked problem
Estimating airflow from the rise
The furnace delivers 57,600 Btu/h at high fire, and the measured temperature rise is 54 °F. Using Q = 1.08 × cfm × ΔT, what airflow is the blower moving?
Show solution
- Rearrange the formula for airflow:
- \[\text{cfm} = \frac{Q}{1.08 \times \Delta T} = \frac{57\,600}{1.08 \times 54} = \frac{57\,600}{58.3} \approx 988 \text{ cfm}\]
Answer: About 990 cfm, close to the airflow the blower table gives for the heating speed Jonah had selected at this static pressure. The two methods agreeing is a good sign that the readings are sound.
The water heater was next. Jonah confirmed its inlet pressure with the furnace running, watched its power venter and igniter sequence, checked the flame, measured the manifold pressure, and took a combustion reading at the vent's test port: air-free CO 35 ppm, within the maker's range. He lifted the T&P valve's lever to prove it, checked the expansion tank, and set the gas control so the water at the kitchen tap came out at 120 °F through the house's existing mixing valve. With both appliances running and the house's exhaust fans and dryer on, he checked CO in the basement and on the main floor: zero.
Handing over
The last hour went to the Okoyes. Jonah showed them the furnace filter and how to change it, the manual valves for both appliances, the condensate trap and neutralizer, the water heater's T&P valve and why it must never be capped, and the two new vent terminals, which must be kept clear of snow, leaves and new plantings. He tested the CO alarms and added one in the basement near the appliances, where there had been none. He explained the thermostat's two-stage operation and why the new furnace would run longer, quieter cycles. Rosa left the instructions for both appliances in a sleeve on the furnace and the start-up sheets with the Okoyes.
Bayline's office registered both warranties and booked the city's mechanical inspection for Wednesday, November 18; the electrical partner's inspection was booked for the same week. Bayline's plan for the house was its first annual service in the fall of 2027, with the neutralizer media checked then.
Worked problem
What the replacement saves
The house needs about 520 therms of heat a year. The old furnace had an AFUE of 78; the new one has 96. Ignoring the water heater, how many fewer therms will the house use?
Show solution
- Gas used by each furnace:
- \[\frac{520}{0.78} = 666.7 \text{ therms} \qquad \frac{520}{0.96} = 541.7 \text{ therms}\]
- Difference:
- \[666.7 - 541.7 = 125 \text{ therms}\]
Answer: About 125 therms a year less, close to a fifth of the old furnace's use, before counting the benefit of the right-sized, two-stage operation.
What the job shows
| Decision | Lesson | Why it was made |
|---|---|---|
| Size the furnace from a heat loss calculation | 1, 12 | The old furnace was 1.8 times too large |
| Measure duct static pressure before choosing | 4 | A blower can only deliver its airflow if the ducts allow it |
| Choose a two-stage condensing furnace | 2, 3 | Efficiency, long low-fire cycles, no chimney needed |
| Replace the water heater rather than line the chimney | 4, 5 | An orphaned water heater near the end of its life |
| Check piping against the new loads | 1, 12 | Inputs changed; the line had to be proved adequate |
| Measure every termination clearance before drilling | 3, 5 | Flue gas must not re-enter the house or reach the meter |
| Record every start-up reading | 4, 11 | The next service technician needs a baseline |
Jonah's notes on the job ended with a line Rosa liked enough to repeat at Hank's next shop training: "Two appliances out of a chimney, two appliances in, and the hard part was deciding, not installing." Every measurement on the start-up sheets came from a lesson in this course, and so did every decision. GAS-220 takes the controls and ignition systems that ran each appliance's start-up sequence and opens them up.
Common mistakes
MistakeMatching the old furnace's input instead of calculating the heat loss.
InsteadCalculate the heat loss and choose the furnace from it.
MistakeRemoving a furnace from a shared chimney and leaving the water heater as it is.
InsteadLine the chimney for the water heater or take the water heater out of the chimney.
MistakeDrilling the vent hole before measuring the termination clearances.
InsteadMeasure every clearance from the instructions and code first.
MistakeForgetting the expansion tank on a house with a check valve.
InsteadFit a thermal expansion tank on a closed water system.
MistakeLeaving without explaining the new equipment.
InsteadWalk the customer through filters, valves, terminals, condensate, the T&P valve and CO alarms.
Summary and key terms
- The Okoye job replaced a 27-year-old, oversized mid-efficiency furnace and a 14-year-old atmospheric water heater sharing a masonry chimney.
- A heat loss calculation set the new furnace's size: a two-stage condensing furnace with about 1.3 times the design heat loss.
- Duct static was measured first, and a return was added.
- Rather than orphan the water heater in the chimney, the owners replaced it with a power-vent model sized by first-hour rating, and the chimney was sealed and labeled.
- The piping was checked against the new loads.
- Start-up recorded inlet and manifold pressures, the clocked input, temperature rise, static pressure, airflow, combustion readings and CO, all within the instructions' limits.
- The customer was shown everything and the city inspection was booked.
- Orphaned water heater
- A water heater left alone in a chimney or vent sized for more than one appliance.
- Design heat loss
- The heat a house loses on the coldest day it is designed for.
- Peak hour demand
- The most hot water a household uses in its busiest hour.
- Thimble
- The opening in a chimney wall where a vent connector enters.
- Dielectric fitting
- A fitting that separates dissimilar metals in water piping to slow corrosion.
- Handover
- The explanation of new equipment, its controls and its care given to the customer at the end of a job.
- Baseline
- The readings recorded at start-up against which later service readings are compared.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
Why did Hank not size the new furnace from the old one?
Show answer
The old furnace was far larger than the house's heat loss.
What problem would removing the furnace have caused for the old water heater?
Show answer
It would have been orphaned in a chimney too large for it alone, risking poor draft and spillage.
Why was a thermal expansion tank added?
Show answer
The water service had a check valve, making it a closed system.
What airflow corresponds to 57,600 Btu/h at a 50 °F rise?
Show answer
57,600 ÷ (1.08 × 50) ≈ 1,067 cfm.
Name three readings recorded on the furnace start-up sheet.
Show answer
Inlet and manifold pressure, clocked input, temperature rise, static pressure, combustion readings or CO.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.