Engine displacement, compression and power

Gord Haney stops by the counter on a slow afternoon to pay for his sway bar bushings and stays to talk. He tows a trailer of landscaping equipment, and he has noticed that his pickup pulls noticeably harder on the flat roads east of the city than it does in the mountains when he takes the trailer to a job near Silverthorne. “Is something wrong with it?” he asks. Simone sends him to the shop floor, where Marty hands the question to Kiran. “You tell him. Work it out first.”

To answer, Kiran needs the numbers that describe what an engine can do: its displacement, its compression ratio, the torque and power it makes, how well it fills its cylinders, and how all of these change with the air it breathes. This lesson explains each one and how technicians use them, from reading a specification sheet to judging whether a complaint is a fault or simply physics.

Displacement

Displacement, also called swept volume, is the volume the pistons sweep as they move from bottom dead center to top dead center, added up for all the cylinders. It is the most common single figure used to describe an engine's size: the 2.0 liter training engine, the 3.6 liter minivan V6 and Gord's 5.3 liter V8. In the United States, engine displacement was traditionally given in cubic inches, and Gord's engine family is still often called a 325 by people who grew up with that measure.

Here V_d is the displacement, B is the bore, S is the stroke and n is the number of cylinders. The first part of the formula, pi over four times the bore squared, is the area of the piston crown. Multiplying it by the stroke gives the volume swept by one piston, and multiplying that by the number of cylinders gives the engine's displacement.

# Displacement from bore and stroke
import math
engines = [("training engine, inline four", 3.386, 3.386, 4),
           ("Gord's pickup, V8", 3.780, 3.622, 8),
           ("Lindqvists' minivan, V6", 3.780, 3.268, 6)]
for name, bore, stroke, n in engines:
    one = math.pi / 4 * bore ** 2 * stroke          # swept volume of one cylinder
    total = one * n
    print(f"{name:<30} one cylinder {one:6.1f} in3, engine {total:7.0f} in3 = {total * 16.387 / 1000:.1f} L")

training engine, inline four   one cylinder   30.5 in3, engine     122 in3 = 2.0 L
Gord's pickup, V8              one cylinder   40.6 in3, engine     325 in3 = 5.3 L
Lindqvists' minivan, V6        one cylinder   36.7 in3, engine     220 in3 = 3.6 L

Bore and stroke are entered in inches so the result comes out in cubic inches; one cubic inch is 16.387 cubic centimeters, and a thousand cubic centimeters make a liter. Displacement tells the technician how much air the engine can draw in per cycle, and therefore roughly how much power it can make, but two engines of the same displacement can be very different. A small turbocharged engine can outperform a larger engine that breathes at atmospheric pressure, and an engine tuned for economy can make far less power than one of the same size tuned for performance.

Compression ratio

The compression ratio compares the volume above the piston at BDC with the volume above it at TDC. The small volume left at TDC is the clearance volume, made up of the combustion chamber in the head, the space taken by the head gasket's thickness, any gap between the piston crown and the block deck, and any dish or valve pockets in the piston (a domed piston reduces it).

In this formula, V_s is the swept volume of one cylinder and V_c is the clearance volume. A typical modern gasoline engine has a ratio between about 10 and 12.5 to one; Gord's engine is about 11 to one. Higher ratios extract more work from each charge of fuel and air, which improves both power and economy, but they also raise the temperature and pressure of the mixture during compression. Too high, and the end of the mixture can explode on its own before the flame reaches it. This uncontrolled burning is called detonation, knock or pinging, and it can crack pistons and damage head gaskets. The engine control module listens for it with knock sensors on the block and retards the spark when it hears it.

Fuel's resistance to knock is its octane rating. An engine designed for regular fuel runs correctly on regular; using a higher octane fuel than specified adds nothing. An engine that specifies premium fuel can usually run on regular, but the control module will retard the timing to protect it and power and economy will fall. Direct injection, which cools the mixture as the fuel evaporates inside the cylinder, has allowed manufacturers to raise compression ratios without knock.

Compression ratio matters to technicians in two ways. When an engine is rebuilt, machining the deck or the head, or using a thinner head gasket, reduces the clearance volume and raises the ratio, so the service information's limits on how much material may be removed must be followed. And the ratio sets what a compression gauge will read during a test, which Lesson 10 covers. A higher-ratio engine produces a higher cranking pressure, and so does a lower altitude.

# Compression ratio of the training engine from measured volumes
import math
swept = math.pi / 4 * 3.386 ** 2 * 3.386 * 16.387     # one cylinder, cc
chamber = 42.0                                       # combustion chamber in the head, cc (measured by filling it)
gasket = math.pi / 4 * 3.425 ** 2 * 0.028 * 16.387        # compressed head gasket: bore 3.425 in, thickness 0.028 in
deck = math.pi / 4 * 3.386 ** 2 * 0.008 * 16.387        # piston 0.008 in below the deck at TDC
dish = 5.0                                           # dish in the piston crown, cc
clearance = chamber + gasket + deck + dish
print(f"swept {swept:.1f} cc; clearance {clearance:.1f} cc (chamber {chamber}, gasket {gasket:.1f}, deck {deck:.1f}, dish {dish})")
print(f"compression ratio {(swept + clearance) / clearance:.2f} : 1")
thinner = gasket * 0.020 / 0.028
cl2 = clearance - gasket + thinner
print(f"with a 0.020 in gasket: {(swept + cl2) / cl2:.2f} : 1")

swept 499.6 cc; clearance 52.4 cc (chamber 42.0, gasket 4.2, deck 1.2, dish 5.0)
compression ratio 10.53 : 1
with a 0.020 in gasket: 10.76 : 1

Builders measure the chamber volume by sealing a clear plate over it and filling it from a graduated burette with a light oil; the volume of oil it takes is the chamber volume. Every part of the clearance volume matters. On the training engine, changing to a thinner head gasket would raise the compression ratio noticeably, which is why gaskets are replaced with the thickness the service information specifies, and why a technician never adds a second gasket or a thicker one to cure a problem.

Torque and power

Torque is a turning force: the force on the end of a lever multiplied by the lever's length, as Kiran learned with torque wrenches in AUTO-110. The torque an engine delivers at its crankshaft depends on how hard the gas pushes on the pistons, so it rises and falls with how well the engine fills its cylinders at each speed. Power is the rate of doing work: torque multiplied by rotational speed. An engine can make a lot of torque at low speed and still not much power, because it is turning slowly; power is what decides how fast a vehicle can climb a hill or accelerate a load.

In the first formula P is power in kilowatts, T is torque in newton meters and n is speed in revolutions per minute. In the second, power is in horsepower and torque in pound-feet; the two curves cross at 5,252 rpm, which is why a horsepower and a pound-foot of torque are equal there on any dynamometer chart.

Gord's engine is rated at about 355 hp at 5,600 rpm and 383 lb·ft of torque at 4,100 rpm. These figures are measured under standard sea-level conditions on a dynamometer and corrected to a standard air pressure and temperature, so that engines tested in different places can be compared fairly.

Another way to compare engines of different sizes is brake mean effective pressure, BMEP: the average pressure that would have to act on the pistons during each power stroke to produce the measured torque. It shows how hard an engine is working for its size. Engines that breathe at atmospheric pressure reach about 160 to 190 psi at peak torque; turbocharged engines reach well over 290 psi.

# Power, torque and BMEP for Gord's engine
import math
torque = 383               # lb ft at peak torque
rpm_t = 4100
power_at_t = torque * rpm_t / 5252
print(f"at {rpm_t} rpm: {torque} lb ft gives {power_at_t:.0f} hp")
rated_power, rpm_p = 355, 5600
torque_at_p = rated_power * 5252 / rpm_p
print(f"at {rpm_p} rpm: {rated_power} hp needs {torque_at_p:.0f} lb ft")
displacement_m3 = 5.327e-3
bmep_kpa = 4 * math.pi * torque * 1.3558 / displacement_m3 / 1000
print(f"BMEP at peak torque {bmep_kpa * 0.145:.0f} psi")

at 4100 rpm: 383 lb ft gives 299 hp
at 5600 rpm: 355 hp needs 333 lb ft
BMEP at peak torque 178 psi

Volumetric efficiency

An engine never quite fills its cylinders with air at atmospheric pressure. Restrictions in the air filter, throttle, intake manifold, ports and valves, and the short time the valves are open, all reduce the amount of air that gets in. Volumetric efficiency, VE, compares the mass of air actually drawn in with the mass that would fill the displacement at the outside air's density. A good engine that breathes at atmospheric pressure reaches about 85 to 95 percent at its torque peak, and much less at idle, where the throttle is nearly closed. Supercharged and turbocharged engines can exceed 100 percent.

Technicians meet volumetric efficiency in diagnosis. The mass airflow sensor tells the control module how many grams of air enter each second, and a scan tool displays it. If the airflow at wide-open throttle is much lower than an engine of that size should take in, something is restricting it: a plugged air filter, a collapsed intake duct, a sticking throttle, a restricted exhaust or a mass airflow sensor that is reading low. A quick volumetric efficiency calculation, using the airflow, engine speed, displacement and air density, helps a technician decide whether the reading makes sense before chasing a fault.

# Volumetric efficiency from scan tool airflow (test drive, wide-open throttle)
pressure_kpa, air_temp_c = 83.4, 20            # outside air at the shop
density = pressure_kpa * 1000 / (287 * (air_temp_c + 273.15))     # kg per m3
displacement_m3 = 5.327e-3
rpm = 4000
maf_gs = 160                                     # mass airflow sensor reading, g/s
theory_gs = displacement_m3 * rpm / 2 / 60 * density * 1000     # each cylinder fills once every 2 turns
print(f"airflow that would exactly fill the displacement: {theory_gs:.0f} g/s; measured {maf_gs} g/s")
print(f"volumetric efficiency {maf_gs / theory_gs * 100:.0f} %")

airflow that would exactly fill the displacement: 176 g/s; measured 160 g/s
volumetric efficiency 91 %

A result between about 80 and 95 percent at wide-open throttle tells Kiran that the engine is breathing normally. A result of 60 percent would send her to check the air filter, the intake and the mass airflow sensor before anything else.

Altitude and power

Air pressure falls with height above sea level, and with it the density of the air. At Denver's elevation of about 5,280 ft, the average air pressure is about 24.6 inches of mercury, roughly 82 percent of the sea-level value of 29.92 inches. Because a naturally aspirated engine fills its cylinders with air at the pressure around it, it takes in less air at altitude, can burn less fuel, and makes less power, in close proportion to the pressure. Hot air is less dense too, so an engine makes less power on a hot day than a cold one.

# How much power does Gord's engine make where he drives?
rated_sea_level = 355               # rated at sea level, hp
places = [("sea level", 0), ("Denver", 5280), ("Silverthorne", 8740), ("a mountain pass", 11150)]
for name, height in places:
    h_m = height * 0.3048
    pressure = 101.325 * (1 - 2.25577e-5 * h_m) ** 5.25588      # standard atmosphere (kilopascals)
    ratio = pressure / 101.325
    print(f"{name:<18} {height:>6,} ft: {pressure * 0.2953:5.2f} inHg, {ratio * 100:3.0f} % of sea level, about {rated_sea_level * ratio:4.0f} hp")

sea level               0 ft: 29.92 inHg, 100 % of sea level, about  355 hp
Denver              5,280 ft: 24.64 inHg,  82 % of sea level, about  292 hp
Silverthorne        8,740 ft: 21.60 inHg,  72 % of sea level, about  256 hp
a mountain pass    11,150 ft: 19.68 inHg,  66 % of sea level, about  233 hp

The standard atmosphere formula in the code works in meters and kilopascals internally, because that is how it is defined. The answer for Gord is that nothing is wrong with his truck. At the heights he drives, his engine has lost a substantial share of its sea-level power, and with a loaded trailer behind it he feels every bit of that loss. Turbocharged engines lose much less, because the turbocharger can make up the missing pressure, which is one reason they are popular in mountain regions.

Altitude also matters to technicians in other ways. Compression readings, manifold vacuum and the boiling point of coolant all depend on the air pressure around the engine, and a specification written for sea level must be adjusted before a reading at Ridgeline is compared with it. Lessons 9 and 10 show how.

Piston speed

Mean piston speed is the average speed of the piston over a stroke: twice the stroke multiplied by revolutions per second. It is a useful measure of how hard an engine's bottom end is working, because the loads on the connecting rods and the wear on the rings rise with it. Most passenger car engines stay below about 66 feet per second at their highest speed; racing engines reach about 82. Long-stroke engines therefore tend to have lower maximum speeds than short-stroke ones.

# Mean piston speed at the top of each engine's speed range
engines = [("training engine", 3.386 / 12, 6500), ("Gord's V8", 3.622 / 12, 6000), ("minivan V6", 3.268 / 12, 6400)]
for name, stroke, max_rpm in engines:
    speed = 2 * stroke * max_rpm / 60
    print(f"{name:<16} {max_rpm} rpm: {speed:5.1f} ft/s")

training engine  6500 rpm:  61.1 ft/s
Gord's V8        6000 rpm:  60.4 ft/s
minivan V6       6400 rpm:  58.1 ft/s