Ventilation, filtration and indoor air quality

Lesson 1 left the Novaks with sweating windows and a recommendation: a heat recovery ventilator. In April, with the basement ceiling open for the duct work, Northfield installed one. Irene had read about them and had a list of questions. How much air did the house need? Why not an energy recovery ventilator instead? Would it make the house dry in winter or damp in summer? And what about filters: the dog had been shedding all winter, and her son had allergies. Theo, who had now done the loads, the ducts and the outlets, was ready for most of them.

This lesson covers why buildings need ventilation, how much the codes require for houses and commercial buildings, heat and energy recovery ventilators, filtration and MERV ratings, and simple indicators of indoor air quality such as carbon dioxide.

Why ventilate

People and buildings produce pollutants: moisture, as lesson 1 showed; carbon dioxide and odours from breathing; volatile organic compounds from furniture, finishes and cleaning products; combustion products from cooking; particles from cooking, pets and outdoors; and, in some areas, radon from the soil. Ventilation dilutes them by replacing indoor air with outdoor air. Older, leaky houses got that replacement by accident, unevenly and at the mercy of the weather: plenty on a cold windy day, almost none on a calm mild one. Tighter houses, like the Novaks' after the air sealing, need it provided deliberately.

The principle of good ventilation is to build tight and ventilate right: make the envelope as airtight as practical, then supply a controlled amount of outdoor air where it is needed and exhaust stale air from where pollutants are produced, such as kitchens and bathrooms. Source control comes first: a range hood that captures cooking pollutants at the stove does more good than general ventilation, and the best way to deal with a pollutant is not to bring it into the house.

How much ventilation houses need

In Ontario, the Building Code's ventilation requirements for houses, in Part 9, follow the approach of CSA F326, Residential Mechanical Ventilation Systems. A house needs a total ventilation capacity based on its rooms, about 10 L/s for the main bedroom and about 5 L/s for each other room in the simplified room-count method, and a principal ventilation fan, sized by the number of bedrooms, that runs continuously or on a schedule to provide the base rate. Many new houses meet the requirement with a heat recovery ventilator. Other provinces' codes, based on the National Building Code, have similar requirements. Kitchens and bathrooms also need local exhaust, by fans or ventilator connections, with minimum rates for each.

Ventilation systems for houses come in three basic types. Exhaust-only systems run a quiet bathroom fan continuously and let outdoor air leak in wherever it can; they are cheap but depressurize the house and give no control over where the air comes from. Supply-only systems bring outdoor air into the return of the furnace or air handler, filtered and tempered, and pressurize the house slightly, which can push moist air into walls in cold climates. Balanced systems, HRVs and ERVs, supply and exhaust equal amounts and recover heat, which is why they are the usual choice in cold climates.

HRVs and ERVs

A heat recovery ventilator, HRV, has two fans and a core in which the outgoing stale air and the incoming fresh air pass on opposite sides of thin plates without mixing. Heat flows through the plates from the warmer stream to the colder, so in winter the incoming air is warmed by the outgoing air. Its sensible recovery efficiency, the fraction of the possible temperature change it achieves, is typically about 60 to 85 %. An energy recovery ventilator, ERV, has a core that also transfers moisture, by a permeable membrane or a desiccant wheel, so in winter it returns some of the indoor moisture to the incoming air, and in summer it keeps some of the outdoor moisture out.

Which to choose depends on the climate and the house. In a cold climate, an HRV removes moisture as well as heat in winter, which suits a house with high indoor humidity, such as the Novaks'. An ERV retains moisture in winter, which suits a house that is too dry with an HRV, and reduces the latent load from ventilation in a humid summer, which matters more in Kentucky than in Ontario. In very cold weather, HRVs and ERVs need defrost: the exhaust air leaving the core can fall below freezing, and the core frosts; units defrost by recirculating indoor air through the core for a few minutes, by preheating the outdoor air, or by reducing the supply fan speed.

The ventilator's own ducts matter. The fresh-air intake must be away from the exhaust outlet, the dryer vent, the gas meter and any vehicle exhaust, typically by at least about 1.8 m (6 ft) or as the code and manual require; both outdoor ducts must be insulated, with a vapour barrier, because cold outdoor air in the duct will condense room moisture on the outside of it. The supply air is distributed to bedrooms and living areas, through the furnace ducts or its own small ducts, and the exhaust is taken from bathrooms and the kitchen area, away from the range. Most importantly, the supply and exhaust flows must be balanced, measured at the unit's flow stations or with a calibrated device and adjusted with its dampers.

The Novak ventilator

The script works out the ventilation the Novak house needed, the indoor humidity the family's moisture would produce on a cold day with and without the HRV, the heat the ventilation air would take on the design day with and without recovery, and, for comparison, the carbon dioxide level at the clinic with its economizer at minimum outdoor air.

import math
def p_atm(z_m):
    """Standard atmospheric pressure, kPa, at an elevation in metres."""
    return 101.325 * (1 - 2.25577e-5 * z_m) ** 5.2559
def pws(t):
    """Saturation pressure of water vapour over water, kPa, t in deg C (Magnus form)."""
    return 0.61094 * math.exp(17.625 * t / (t + 243.04))
def w_from_rh(t, rh, p):
    """Humidity ratio, kg of water per kg of dry air."""
    pv = rh * pws(t)
    return 0.622 * pv / (p - pv)
def pv_from_w(w, p):
    return w * p / (0.622 + w)
def dew_point(pv):
    a = math.log(pv / 0.61094)
    return 243.04 * a / (17.625 - a)
def enthalpy(t, w):
    """kJ per kg of dry air."""
    return 1.006 * t + w * (2501 + 1.86 * t)
def spec_volume(t, w, p):
    """Cubic metres per kg of dry air."""
    return 0.287042 * (t + 273.15) * (1 + 1.607858 * w) / p
def wet_bulb(t, w, p):
    """Thermodynamic wet-bulb temperature found by bisection."""
    lo, hi = -40.0, t
    for _ in range(60):
        m = (lo + hi) / 2
        ws = w_from_rh(m, 1.0, p)
        wc = ((2501 - 2.326 * m) * ws - 1.006 * (t - m)) / (2501 + 1.86 * t - 4.186 * m)
        lo, hi = (lo, m) if wc > w else (m, hi)
    return (lo + hi) / 2
def rel_humidity(t, w, p):
    return pv_from_w(w, p) / pws(t)

P = p_atm(330)
# 1. ventilation capacity for the Novak house (Ontario Building Code room-count method, simplified)
rooms = {"main bedroom": 10, "bedroom 2": 5, "bedroom 3": 5, "living room": 5, "dining room": 5, "kitchen": 5,
         "bathroom": 5, "recreation room": 5, "basement office": 5, "basement bathroom": 5}
tvc = sum(rooms.values())
pvc = 22                                   # principal ventilation capacity for three bedrooms, L/s
print(f"total ventilation capacity {tvc} L/s; principal (continuous) ventilation about {pvc} L/s")
# 2. winter moisture balance: indoor humidity ratio = outdoor + moisture added / dry-air flow
G = 14 / 86400                             # kg/s: about 14 kg of water a day, laundry drying indoors included
t_out, rh_out, t_in = -15.0, 0.75, 21.0
w_out = w_from_rh(t_out, rh_out, P)
for name, q in (("air leakage only", 18), ("leakage + HRV 22 L/s", 18 + 22), ("leakage + HRV 35 L/s", 18 + 35)):
    m = q / 1000 * 1.2
    w_in = w_out + G / m
    print(f"{name:22s} {q:3d} L/s: indoor {w_in * 1000:.1f} g/kg, {rel_humidity(t_in, w_in, P):.0%} RH, "
          f"dew point {dew_point(pv_from_w(w_in, P)):.1f} C")
# 3. heat to warm the ventilation air on the design day, with and without heat recovery
dT = 22 - (-19)
for eff in (0.0, 0.70):
    print(f"sensible recovery {eff:.0%}: ventilation load at design {1.21 * pvc * dT * (1 - eff):.0f} W")
# 4. CO2 at the clinic with the economizer at minimum outdoor air
people, gen = 12, 0.0052                   # occupants, L/s of CO2 each (light activity)
oa = 0.25 * 566
print(f"clinic: {oa:.0f} L/s outdoor air, steady CO2 about {420 + people * gen / oa * 1e6:.0f} ppm (outdoor 420)")

total ventilation capacity 55 L/s; principal (continuous) ventilation about 22 L/s
air leakage only        18 L/s: indoor 8.4 g/kg, 52% RH, dew point 10.9 C
leakage + HRV 22 L/s    40 L/s: indoor 4.3 g/kg, 27% RH, dew point 1.2 C
leakage + HRV 35 L/s    53 L/s: indoor 3.5 g/kg, 22% RH, dew point -1.7 C
sensible recovery 0%: ventilation load at design 1091 W
sensible recovery 70%: ventilation load at design 327 W
clinic: 142 L/s outdoor air, steady CO2 about 861 ppm (outdoor 420)

The room-count method gave a total capacity of 55 L/s and a principal rate of about 22 L/s for three bedrooms. With only the house's air leakage on a cold, calm morning, about 18 L/s, the family's moisture held the house at about 52 % relative humidity and a dew point of about 11 °C, matching Theo's January reading closely. With the HRV running at 22 L/s continuously, the humidity fell to about 27 % in the same weather, with the dew point near 1 °C, so the windows would stay dry. On the design day, warming 22 L/s of ventilation air would take about 1.1 kW without recovery and only about 0.3 kW with a 70 % HRV.

The numbers also showed a risk at the other end. On the coldest days, a continuously running HRV would make the house rather dry, below 30 %, which would bother Irene's son. Northfield set the HRV to run at its low speed continuously, with a boost from the bathroom timers and a dehumidistat that raised its speed only when the humidity climbed, and showed the Novaks how to lower its speed on the coldest days. Dana noted that if the house still felt too dry in a cold winter, the core could be swapped for an energy recovery core of the same size, which the manufacturer offered.

Commercial ventilation

Commercial buildings follow ASHRAE Standard 62.1, Ventilation and Acceptable Indoor Air Quality, or the code based on it. Its ventilation rate procedure gives a rate per person and a rate per unit floor area for each type of space, such as about 2.5 L/s per person plus 0.3 L/s per square metre for offices, adds them for each zone, and corrects for how well the air distribution delivers outdoor air to the breathing zone and for multi-zone systems. Health-care spaces, including dental clinics, have additional requirements in CSA Z317.2 and in ASHRAE Standard 170, such as minimum air changes, pressure relationships and filtration, for some rooms.

Carbon dioxide is a useful indicator, though not itself a pollutant at normal indoor levels: people exhale it at a predictable rate, so its concentration above outdoors shows roughly how much outdoor air each person is getting. Outdoor air is now about 420 ppm. Indoor levels of 800 to 1,100 ppm in an occupied office are common, and much higher levels suggest too little ventilation for the number of people. Demand-controlled ventilation uses CO2 sensors to vary outdoor air with occupancy, as RAC-230 described for the clinic's economizer. At the clinic, the script estimated about 860 ppm at minimum outdoor air with twelve people, a reasonable level.

Filtration

Filters protect the equipment, keeping coils and blowers clean, and can improve indoor air by removing particles. Their efficiency is rated by the minimum efficiency reporting value, MERV, from ASHRAE Standard 52.2, on a scale from 1 to 16, based on how well they capture particles in three size ranges. A typical thin fibreglass filter is about MERV 2 to 4 and protects equipment only. MERV 8 captures most large particles such as pollen and dust mite debris. MERV 11 to 13 captures a large share of fine particles, including much of the smoke, bacteria-sized and some virus-carrying particles, and was widely recommended during the COVID-19 pandemic. ISO 16890 is an international rating system used by some manufacturers.

Higher efficiency usually means more resistance, and lesson 7 showed what resistance does to airflow. A one-inch high-MERV filter in a slot designed for a cheap filter can choke a residential system. The usual answer is a deeper filter with more surface area, a 100 mm (4 in.) or 125 mm (5 in.) media filter in a proper cabinet, which gives higher efficiency at a lower pressure drop and lasts longer. Filters must also fit their racks without gaps, or air bypasses them. Electronic air cleaners and portable HEPA units are other options; ozone-generating air cleaners are not recommended for occupied spaces.

For the Novaks, Theo replaced the original one-inch filter slot with a 125 mm MERV 13 media cabinet at the air handler, which measured about 30 Pa (0.12 in. w.c.) clean at the design airflow, less than the old filter had. The HRV's own filters protected its core and were to be washed every few months. He added both to the Novaks' maintenance schedule.

Other indoor air quality measures

Combustion safety and radon are part of indoor air quality too. Houses with fuel-burning appliances need carbon monoxide alarms, and exhaust fans and ventilators must not depressurize the house enough to backdraft them, which is one reason balanced ventilation suits cold climates; makeup air is needed for large range hoods in some jurisdictions. Radon, a radioactive gas from the soil, is found in many regions of Canada; Health Canada recommends testing every house and mitigating above its guideline, usually with a sub-slab depressurization system. Northfield's technicians did not install radon systems, but they recommended a test whenever a basement was being renovated, as the Novaks' was.