Working with people on the street and in the field

Street and documentary photography are about people, and how photographers behave toward the people they photograph affects both the images and the people themselves. Some photographers prefer to remain invisible; others engage, talk and ask; most move between the two depending on the situation. This lesson covers the spectrum of engagement, being present and unobtrusive, approaching strangers, asking for portraits, responding when someone objects, photographing children and vulnerable people in public, cultural sensitivity in unfamiliar places, building trust in documentary work, and talking about your work with the people you meet.

The spectrum of engagement

Photographers relate to people in public in different ways, from completely candid to fully collaborative:

No single mode is always right. Candid images capture authentic moments but give people no choice; asked portraits give choice but change behavior. Many photographers shoot candidly in crowds and at public events, engage directly with individuals they photograph closely, and seek consent for anything that might be sensitive.

Being present and unobtrusive

Paradoxically, the best way to avoid disturbing a scene is often to be openly present rather than sneaking. People notice furtive behavior, such as hiding a camera or shooting from a distance and then looking away, and it makes them suspicious. Photographers who stay in one place, move calmly, hold the camera openly and make eye contact and smile when noticed tend to be ignored or accepted. Spending time in a place before photographing, becoming part of the scenery, lets people get used to you. Dressing to blend in, carrying minimal gear, and moving with the flow of people rather than against it all help. If someone looks at you, a friendly nod or smile, or lowering the camera briefly, usually defuses tension.

Approaching strangers for portraits

Asking strangers for portraits is a skill that improves with practice and makes many photographers less anxious about street work in general. Approaches that tend to work include:

• Being specific and sincere: "I love the way the light falls on you in that doorway; could I take your photograph?"
• Being brief and clear about who you are and what the photograph is for, such as a personal project, a class or a publication.
• Accepting refusals graciously; most people who say no do so politely, and a refusal is not a failure.
• Offering to send the photograph, and following through.
• Asking questions and listening; a short conversation often leads to more relaxed, expressive portraits, and to names and stories for captions.
• Working quickly once permission is given, making a few frames and perhaps adjusting position slightly, without turning the encounter into a long session.

Projects such as Humans of New York, begun by Brandon Stanton in 2010, showed how short conversations with strangers, combined with portraits and quotations, can reach huge audiences and build empathy, while also raising questions about how people's stories are framed and shared.

When someone objects

Sometimes people react badly to being photographed: they may wave you away, ask what you are doing, demand that you delete the image or become angry. How you respond matters ethically and for your safety. Useful principles include:

• Stay calm and polite, and lower the camera.
• Explain honestly what you are doing and why; many objections soften once people understand.
• Consider their concern: they may have good reasons, such as fear of being identified by an abuser or an employer, cultural or religious reasons, or simply discomfort.
• Offer to delete the image if they ask, especially if it is not important; even where the law does not require deletion, doing so is often the respectful choice.
• If the situation escalates, walk away; no photograph is worth a fight.

Keep in mind that the law in most places in Canada and the United States does not require you to delete photographs taken lawfully in public (Lesson 7), and no private person has the right to take your camera. But legal rights and ethical choices are different questions.

Children in public

Photographing children in public is legal in most places in Canada and the United States, but it is sensitive. Parents may be protective, and an adult stranger photographing children can provoke alarm, especially in parks, schools and playgrounds. Many street photographers avoid making children the main subject of candid photographs, include children only as part of wider scenes, or ask parents first. If a parent objects, delete the image and apologize. Never photograph children in ways that could be exploitative, and be cautious about publishing identifiable images of children, especially with locations. In documentary projects involving children, always obtain consent from parents or guardians and the child's own agreement, and follow the policies of schools and organizations.

Vulnerable people in public

Streets are also where people who are homeless, intoxicated, in mental health crisis, injured or grieving may be visible. Photographing them candidly raises ethical concerns: they may be unable to object, and images may humiliate them or deepen stigma. Many photographers adopt a rule of not photographing people in such situations without engagement and consent, or only in ways that do not identify them. Documentary projects on homelessness, addiction or mental health are usually best done through sustained relationships, collaboration and organizations that work with the people concerned, rather than through candid street images. Ask whether the photograph would still be acceptable if the person saw it, and whether it adds understanding rather than spectacle.

Cultural sensitivity

Attitudes to photography vary between cultures, communities and individuals. In some places and religious traditions, photographing people, especially women, children, religious leaders or worshippers, is considered offensive without permission. Some communities have experienced exploitative photography by outsiders and are understandably wary. Before photographing in an unfamiliar place, learn local customs and laws, observe how locals behave toward cameras, dress respectfully, and ask permission more readily than you might at home. Learning a few words of the local language, being patient and showing genuine interest go a long way. Religious sites, ceremonies, markets and private gatherings often have explicit or implicit rules; follow them.

Building trust in documentary work

Documentary projects that involve sustained access to people's lives depend on trust. Building trust takes time: visiting repeatedly, often without photographing at first; explaining the project clearly; listening; respecting limits; showing work in progress; keeping promises; and being honest about where images may appear. Many documentary photographers describe the first weeks or months of a project as relationship-building rather than photography. Trust can be lost quickly if images are published without warning, used in ways people did not expect, or if the photographer behaves disrespectfully. Gatekeepers, such as community leaders, organizations or family members, often control access and must be treated with respect (Lesson 9).

Talking about your work

People are often curious about why someone is photographing their street, market or community. Having a short, honest explanation ready makes encounters easier: "I photograph everyday life in this neighborhood for a long-term project" or "I'm a student working on a series about public markets." Carrying cards with your name, website and contact details lets people see your work and contact you later, which can turn suspicious encounters into collaborations. Being open about your work builds goodwill in places where you return often, and sometimes leads to invitations that open doors to new photographs.

Your own presence and identity

How people react to a photographer depends partly on who the photographer is: their apparent age, gender, race, size, accent and dress. Some photographers find that they are seen as threatening in some places and invisible in others. Women photographers may face harassment; photographers of color may face suspicion or profiling, including from security guards and police; photographers in their own communities may have access outsiders lack. Being aware of how your presence is read helps you choose approaches and stay safe, and reflecting on whose streets you photograph and from what position is part of an ethical practice.

Photographing at events and protests

Public events, such as parades, festivals, sporting events, rallies and protests, are rich subjects for street and documentary photographers. At celebratory events, people are often happy to be photographed, and engaging openly is easy. At protests, the situation is more complex: participants may want their message documented but may fear identification by police, employers or opponents, especially when protests involve undocumented people, political dissidents or marginalized groups. Good practice includes identifying yourself if asked, respecting people who cover their faces or ask not to be photographed, avoiding close-ups of identifiable individuals who appear vulnerable, and thinking about how images could be used before publishing them. Photographers should also be aware of their own safety, keeping exit routes in mind and staying alert to changes in mood.

Working in your own community

Photographing your own neighborhood, family, workplace or cultural community offers unique advantages: you already have relationships and knowledge, you understand nuances that outsiders miss, and people may trust you more readily. It also brings challenges: people may expect you to show them only in a flattering light; you may be too close to see some things clearly; and publishing images can affect your own relationships. Discussing the project openly with the people involved, sharing work as it develops, and being clear about where it will appear help manage these tensions. Many acclaimed documentary projects come from photographers working within their own communities, and their insider perspective is often what gives the work its depth.

Gifts, payment and exchange

Documentary photographers sometimes face questions about payment: should subjects be paid for being photographed? Many journalistic organizations prohibit paying subjects, because payment can influence behavior and compromise credibility. In longer-term documentary projects, however, photographers often reciprocate in other ways, such as giving prints, sharing meals, helping with tasks, or paying for people's time when they contribute substantially, for example in collaborative projects or interviews. Whatever approach you take, be transparent about it and avoid creating expectations that distort the situation or exploit people's needs.

Showing people their photographs

Showing people the image you have just made, on the camera screen or phone, is often the simplest way to build goodwill. Many people are curious and pleased, some ask for a copy, and a few change their minds about being photographed, which is useful to know before publication. Offering to email or message the photograph, and actually doing so, turns a brief encounter into a positive memory and sometimes a lasting connection.