SLS-150 · Lesson 5 of 12 · 18 min
Misleading claims under the Competition Act
▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.
Ridgeline's marketing team wanted a headline for the RoomFlow booking software. Their draft read: "RoomFlow cuts double bookings by 95 per cent." The number came from a single customer, Halverson Law, whose meeting room double bookings had dropped from twenty a month to one after it switched. Rob Kowalski, Ridgeline's vice-president of sales, liked the line. Grace Liu, the sales operations analyst who keeps the customer data, did not. She pulled the numbers for all six customers that had used RoomFlow for at least three months and sent them to Rob with one sentence: "If we say 95, we need to be able to show 95 to anyone who asks."
Sellers make claims constantly: in conversations, proposals, emails, social media posts, product demonstrations and the marketing materials they hand to buyers. Every one of those claims is subject to advertising law, which bans false or misleading representations to the public. This lesson explains how your country's law judges claims, what evidence a seller needs before making certain kinds of claims, and how to talk about competitors, the environment and customer reviews without crossing the line.
The Competition Act and deceptive marketing
In Canada, misleading advertising is governed mainly by the federal Competition Act, enforced by the Competition Bureau. The Act has two tracks. The criminal provision, section 52, makes it an offence to knowingly or recklessly make a representation to the public that is false or misleading in a material respect; penalties can include fines at the court's discretion and imprisonment of up to 14 years. The civil track, section 74.01, covers the same kind of conduct without requiring proof of intent. Under the civil track, the Competition Tribunal or a court can order the conduct to stop, order restitution to customers and impose administrative monetary penalties. For a corporation, the maximum penalty is the greater of 10 million dollars, or 15 million dollars for a repeat order, and three times the value of the benefit gained; if that benefit cannot reasonably be determined, the maximum is 3 per cent of the company's annual worldwide gross revenues. Since June 2025, private parties can also apply to the Tribunal for permission to bring deceptive marketing cases themselves.
How a claim is judged
Two ideas decide most cases. First, the general impression test: the question is not only whether a claim is literally true, but what overall impression it creates. A headline that says "cuts double bookings by 95 per cent" creates the impression that customers generally get that result, even if fine print says "results from one customer". Second, the standard is the credulous and inexperienced consumer. In Richard v. Time Inc., decided in 2012, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the general impression is judged from the perspective of an ordinary hurried consumer who takes no more than ordinary care, not an expert who reads every word. That case was decided under Quebec's consumer protection law, but the Competition Bureau and courts apply the same approach under the Competition Act.
Performance claims need evidence first
The Competition Act treats claims about a product's performance, efficacy or length of life specially. Under paragraph 74.01(1)(b), such a claim is reviewable unless it is based on an adequate and proper test, and the test must be done before the claim is made. A seller cannot make the claim first and find evidence later. "Adequate and proper" depends on the claim: a claim that a printer prints 45 pages a minute needs testing under realistic conditions, and a claim that software saves users two hours a week needs data from real users that supports that figure.
Worked problem
Turning customer data into an honest claim
Grace's data for the six RoomFlow customers showed the following total double bookings per month, before and after switching: Halverson Law 20 before, 1 after; Northfield Family Clinic 6 before, 2 after; Keystone Grain Equipment 9 before, 2 after; and three smaller offices with 13 before and 4 after combined. What claim can the data support?
Show solution
- Total before: 20 plus 6 plus 9 plus 13, which is 48 double bookings a month.
- Total after: 1 plus 2 plus 2 plus 4, which is 9 a month.
- Reduction: 48 minus 9 is 39. Divided by 48, that is about 0.81, or about four-fifths.
- Halverson's result: 19 out of 20, or 95 in 100, is the best result, not the typical one.
- Six customers over three months is a small sample, so the claim should say so.
Answer: A supportable claim is: "Across our first six RoomFlow customers, double bookings fell by about four-fifths in the first three months." The 95 figure can only be used as a clearly labelled single customer story, not as a general promise.
Rob agreed to the revised wording. He also asked Grace to set up a simple substantiation file: a folder in the shared drive holding the data, the date it was collected and who approved each claim used in marketing and proposals. Leah Marchand, the contracts manager, now checks new claims against that file before they go into proposal templates.
What sellers say counts too
Advertising law is not only about printed ads and websites. Statements a seller makes to buyers, product demonstrations, proposals and posts on social media can all be representations to the public. When Maya tells a school division that RoomFlow "eliminates double bookings", she is making a performance claim. If it is not true, the risk is the same as if it were printed on a billboard, and so is the damage to trust. The safe habit is to repeat the approved, substantiated claim, not a stronger version of it: "Our first six customers saw double bookings fall by about four-fifths. I can show you how we measured it."
Talking about competitors
Comparative claims are allowed in both countries if they are true and not misleading. A seller can say that Ridgeline's managed print plan includes toner and a competitor's does not, if that is accurate and current. Problems arise when comparisons are selective, out of date or simply invented. A claim such as "their machines break down twice as often as ours" needs reliable evidence comparing like with like. Disparaging a competitor with false statements can expose the seller and company to claims from the competitor as well as regulators.
| Safer | Riskier |
|---|---|
| "Our plan includes toner and service visits; theirs charges toner separately, according to their current price list." | "They'll nickel-and-dime you on everything." |
| "We have a technician based in the city; I can show you our response-time data." | "Their service is terrible." |
| "Here's a side-by-side of the published specifications." | "Their machines break down twice as often." (with no data) |
| "I don't know their current pricing, but I can tell you ours." | Guessing at a competitor's price to make yours look better |
Environmental claims
Environmental claims got special attention in 2024, when Parliament amended the Competition Act. A claim about the environmental or climate benefits of a product must now be based on an adequate and proper test, and a claim about the environmental benefits of a business or business activity, such as a claim to be carbon neutral, must be based on adequate and proper substantiation in accordance with internationally recognized methodology. The Competition Bureau has already acted on green claims: in 2022, Keurig Canada agreed to pay a 3 million dollar penalty after the Bureau concluded that its claims about coffee pods being recyclable were misleading, because most municipal programs did not accept them.
At Juniper & Pine, a mattress supplier's display card described one model as "eco-friendly and non-toxic". Bev asked the supplier for the evidence behind it. The supplier sent a certificate for low chemical emissions from the foam, which supports a narrower claim about emissions. The card was replaced with one that named the certification and what it tested.
Reviews, testimonials and endorsements
Testimonials and reviews are representations too. The Competition Act treats a testimonial as misleading if it was not actually given, or if it is used without permission or in a way that changes its meaning. The Bureau has warned that fake reviews, reviews from employees presented as independent customers, and incentives to post positive reviews without disclosure can all be deceptive. If Juniper & Pine offers customers a draw entry for leaving a review, it must accept negative reviews equally and should disclose the incentive.
Building a substantiation file
Grace's substantiation file turned an informal habit into a system. Each claim the company uses in marketing, proposals or sales scripts has an entry. The entry records the exact wording approved, the evidence behind it, when the evidence was collected, who approved the claim and when it must be reviewed. Claims based on customer results are reviewed every six months, because results change as more customers join.
| Field | Example for the RoomFlow claim |
|---|---|
| Approved wording | "Across our first six RoomFlow customers, double bookings fell by about four-fifths in the first three months." |
| Evidence | Booking logs for six customers, three months before and after, pulled by sales operations |
| Date collected | October 2026 |
| Approved by | Rob Kowalski and Leah Marchand |
| Limits | Small sample; not a guarantee; customers used different room setups |
| Review date | April 2027, or sooner if the result changes |
The file also protects sellers. When a buyer asks "Where does that number come from?", Maya can answer with confidence, and if a competitor or regulator ever questions a claim, the company can show that it had the evidence before making it.
Demonstrations, social media and employee posts
Claims are not only made in words. A product demonstration that uses a specially tuned machine, a carefully chosen file or ideal network conditions can create a misleading impression of how the product performs in normal use. The honest approach is to demonstrate under realistic conditions, or to say what is different: "This demo unit has the extra memory upgrade; the standard model is a little slower on large scans."
Social media posts by sellers are representations too. When Maya posted on a professional network about Northfield's new managed print setup, she checked two things first: that the clinic had agreed to be mentioned, and that every number in the post came from the substantiation file. Employees who post about their own company's products should also make the connection clear. A post praising RoomFlow from someone whose profile does not show that they work for Ridgeline can mislead readers into thinking it is an independent opinion, which is exactly the kind of undisclosed connection that advertising rules in both countries target.
Finally, sellers should be careful with claims they did not make but repeat. If a supplier's brochure says a mattress is "recommended by chiropractors", a Juniper & Pine associate who repeats it is making the claim too. Bev's rule is to repeat only claims the store has checked, and to ask the supplier for evidence of the rest.
Checking a claim before you use it
Before repeating any claim to a buyer, a seller can run four quick checks. Is it in the approved wording, or a stronger version of it? Is there evidence on file, and is it current? Does the overall impression match the evidence, including any limits? And would the claim still be fair if the buyer's situation is different from the customers it is based on? If the answer to any of these is uncertain, the safer course is to describe what happened for specific customers and offer to show the data, rather than to promise a result.
The same discipline applies to numbers that sound modest. "Saves about an hour a week" is a performance claim just as much as "cuts costs in half", and it needs the same evidence. Small claims are repeated more often, so an unsupported small claim can mislead more buyers than a bold one.
Common mistakes
MistakeIf the fine print explains it, the headline can say anything.
InsteadClaims are judged by their overall impression; qualifications must be clear and close to the claim.
MistakeI can make the claim now and gather proof if anyone asks.
InsteadEvidence must exist before a performance claim is made.
MistakeSpoken claims in a meeting are not advertising.
InsteadWhat sellers say, show and post can all be representations to the public.
MistakeComparing ourselves with a competitor is always risky.
InsteadTruthful, current, like-for-like comparisons are allowed; invented or selective ones are not.
Mistake"Eco-friendly" is just a marketing word.
InsteadEnvironmental claims must be specific and supported.
Summary and key terms
- The Competition Act bans false or misleading representations on a criminal track (section 52) and a civil track (section 74.01), with large administrative penalties.
- Claims are judged by their general impression on a credulous and inexperienced consumer.
- Performance claims must be based on an adequate and proper test done before the claim is made.
- Sellers should repeat approved, substantiated claims, not stronger versions of them.
- Comparative, environmental and review-based claims follow the same rules, with particular attention to evidence and disclosure.
- General impression
- The overall meaning a representation conveys, including what it implies.
- Adequate and proper test
- The evidence the Competition Act requires before a performance claim is made.
- Testimonial
- A statement by a customer or other person about a product, used in marketing.
- Substantiation file
- A record of the evidence and approvals behind each claim a company uses.
Practice problems
Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.
Why was "cuts double bookings by 95 per cent" misleading even though one customer achieved it?
Show answer
The overall impression is that customers generally get that result, but the typical result across customers was about four-fifths.
What should a seller say instead of "RoomFlow eliminates double bookings"?
Show answer
The approved claim: double bookings fell by about four-fifths across the first six customers, with an offer to show how it was measured.
Give one example of a safer comparative claim.
Show answer
A side-by-side of published specifications, or a factual, current comparison of what is included in each plan.
Lesson quiz · 5 questions
Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.
Create a free account to save your progress, take quizzes and earn a certificate.