SLS-299 · Lesson 7 of 12 · 19 min

Solution and value case

▶ Video coming soon A video version of this lesson is on the way.

By Tuesday, January 26, 2027, in the scenario, Maya had what she needed to design a solution: the problems in Wheatland's own words, the constraints from the site visit, Gareth's criteria, Joanne's privacy requirements and Trevor's technical rules. She took her draft to Rob Kowalski's value desk, the weekly session from SLS-222 where sellers test business cases before customers see them.

The deliverable has two parts. The solution design says what Ridgeline would supply and why each part answers something Wheatland said. The value case puts numbers on the parts that can be priced, using Wheatland's data, and states every assumption.

Designing from the problems, not the catalog

Rob's first test of any solution is a trace: every item in the design must point back to a problem, a constraint or a requirement the customer stated. Items that cannot be traced are either removed or offered as options, never slipped into the main proposal.

Maya's solution design, with each component traced to what Wheatland said.
ComponentWhat it includesTraces to
Scheduling hub furniture18 sit-stand workstations with acoustic screens and dual monitor armsDeshawn: adjustable desks, quiet, two schedule views
Private offices6 desk, storage and seating setsNew office floor plan
Meeting roomsTables and seating for 3 roomsFloor plan; board table kept
Training room12 flip-top tables, 24 stacking chairs, instructor stationRachel: room to train caregivers
LunchroomTables and seatingFloor plan
Training-room videoTracking camera, ceiling microphones, large displaySimone: branch hires waiting for group orientation
Meeting-room videoVideo bars and displays in 2 roomsRachel: linking branches to head office
RoomFlow6 rooms across 3 sites, single sign-on, titles hidden by defaultThree offices; Trevor's sign-on rule; Joanne's no-names rule
Managed print9 devices replaced by 5, badge release, encrypted drives, wipe certificates, secure digital faxFax-tray incident; Joanne's four requirements

One item did not survive the trace. Maya had added laptop leasing for the 44 office staff, because Ridgeline offers it through a leasing partner and the move seemed a natural moment. No one at Wheatland had mentioned laptops. Rob asked her to move it to a list of future possibilities in the account plan, where it would reappear in lesson 12.

Prices for the solution

Ridgeline's standard prices for the components, before taxes, came to the totals below. The furniture prices are Ridgeline's list prices for this range; the technology prices include equipment and configuration; the recurring prices follow Ridgeline's published rates, including the 45 dollars per room per month for RoomFlow used with Keystone in SLS-222.

Ridgeline's standard prices for the solution, before taxes.
ComponentBasisPrice (dollars)
Scheduling hub18 × 1,45026,100
Private offices6 × 2,20013,200
Meeting rooms3 × 3,40010,200
Training room furniturePackage9,600
LunchroomPackage3,800
Furniture products62,900
Delivery and installation4,700
Furniture total67,600
Training-room videoPackage9,800
Meeting-room video2 × 4,2008,400
Technology installation and setup2,400
Technology total20,600
One-time total67,600 + 20,60088,200
RoomFlow6 rooms × 45 a month270 a month
Managed print5 devices × 138 + secure fax 25715 a month

The one-time total of 88,200 dollars sat inside Gareth's figure of about 100,000 dollars for furniture and technology, including a contingency. Maya noted that she did not know the size of the contingency, so she could not tell how much room was left.

The training value case

The training technology is the part of the solution that behaves like an investment: an up-front cost followed by savings. Maya built its value case from the figures Simone had pulled from Wheatland's records in discovery.

Annual benefits and running cost of the training technology.
LineBasisPer year (dollars)
Travel to training avoided14,400 × 0.75 (a quarter of trips still needed for hands-on skills)10,800
Hotel room rental avoided4 sessions × 900, held in the new training room3,600
Total annual benefit14,400
RoomFlow subscription270 × 123,240
Net annual benefit14,400 − 3,24011,160

Worked problem

Payback and net present value

The training technology costs 20,600 dollars and produces a net benefit of 11,160 dollars a year. Wheatland borrows on its line of credit at 6 in 100, which Gareth asked Maya to use as the discount rate. What are the payback period and the five-year net present value?

Show solution
  1. \[\text{Payback} = \frac{20{,}600}{11{,}160} \approx 1.85 \text{ years} \approx 22 \text{ months}\]
  2. Present value of each year's benefit at 6 in 100: 10,528; 9,932; 9,370; 8,840; 8,339. Total 47,009.
  3. \[\text{NPV} = 47{,}009 - 20{,}600 = 26{,}409\]

Answer: Payback in about 22 months and a five-year NPV of about 26,400 dollars at Wheatland's own borrowing rate.

Present values of the training technology's net benefits at 6 in 100.
YearNet benefitDiscount factor 1 ÷ 1.06ⁿPresent value
111,1600.943410,528
211,1600.89009,932
311,1600.83969,370
411,1600.79218,840
511,1600.74738,339
Total55,8004.212447,009

Testing the assumptions

The figure Rob questioned hardest was the 75 in 100 of trips avoided. It was Maya's estimate, based on Simone's comment that most orientation is classroom content but some skills, such as safe lifting and using a mechanical lift, must be taught in person. Rob's rule from SLS-222 is that every estimate in a value case gets a low and a high case, so the customer can see how much the conclusion depends on it.

Sensitivity of the training value case to the share of trips avoided.
CaseTrips avoidedNet annual benefit (dollars)PaybackFive-year NPV (dollars)
Low50 in 1007,560About 33 monthsAbout 11,200
Expected75 in 10011,160About 22 monthsAbout 26,400
High90 in 10013,320About 19 monthsAbout 35,500
A horizontal bar chart of five-year net present value under three cases: low about 11,200 dollars, expected about 26,400 dollars and high about 35,500 dollars. A vertical line at zero shows that all three cases stay positive.
Five-year NPV of the training technology in the low, expected and high cases. Even the low case is positive.

Even in the low case, where only half the trips are avoided, the investment pays back in under three years and has a positive NPV. That is the sentence Maya planned to give Gareth: the case does not depend on her estimate being right.

The printing value case

Managed print is different. It has no up-front investment; it replaces one set of monthly costs with another. SLS-222 taught that forcing an ROI onto a decision like this produces a confusing number, so Maya compared five-year totals instead.

Worked problem

Five years of printing, today against the proposal

Wheatland pays 640 dollars a month in printer leases, about 410 dollars a month for toner and service on the owned printers, and 135 dollars a month for three fax lines. Ridgeline's proposal is 715 dollars a month. One existing lease would have 7 months left at 160 dollars a month when the devices are replaced, and Wheatland would buy it out. Compare five-year costs.

Show solution
  1. Today: 640 + 410 + 135 = 1,185 dollars a month.
  2. \[1{,}185 \times 12 = 14{,}220 \text{ dollars a year}; \quad 14{,}220 \times 5 = 71{,}100\]
  3. \[715 \times 12 = 8{,}580 \text{ dollars a year}; \quad 8{,}580 \times 5 = 42{,}900\]
  4. Lease buyout: 7 × 160 = 1,120 dollars, so the proposal costs 42,900 + 1,120 = 44,020 dollars over five years.
  5. Difference: 71,100 − 44,020 = 27,080 dollars.

Answer: About 27,100 dollars lower over five years, or about 5,640 dollars a year before the one-time buyout, while also meeting all four of Joanne's privacy requirements.

Maya also listed, but did not count, the staff time spent on paper jams and faxes, which Simone estimated at about seven hours a week across the three offices. At 32 dollars an hour that would be about 11,600 dollars a year, but the staff would still be paid, so Rob agreed it was soft value: real, worth mentioning, and kept out of the totals.

The assumptions register

Maya's assumptions register for the value case.
AssumptionValue usedSourceConfidence
Training trips per year60Wheatland mileage claims, 2025-26High
Cost per trip240 dollarsMileage plus 2.5 hours at 32 dollarsHigh
Share of trips avoided75 in 100 (tested at 50 and 90)Maya's estimate from Simone's descriptionMedium
Hotel sessions avoided4 a year at 900 dollarsWheatland invoicesHigh
Current printing costs1,185 dollars a monthWheatland lease and service invoicesHigh
Discount rate6 in 100Gareth: line of credit rateHigh
Staff time on jams and faxes7 hours a week (not counted)Simone's estimateLow
Rubric for the solution and value case, with Maya's scores.
CriterionPointsFull points whenMaya
Traceability5Every component traces to something the customer said; untraced items removed4
Pricing3Prices complete, correct and before taxes3
Investment measures4Payback and NPV correct at the customer's rate4
Sensitivity4Low, expected and high cases for the key estimate4
Assumptions4Every assumption sourced, with hard and soft value separated4
Total2019

Maya lost a point on traceability for the laptop leasing she had added, even though she removed it after Rob's question.

Reflection

  • Which component of your solution was hardest to trace to something the customer said?
  • If your key estimate were wrong by half, would your case still stand?
  • Which value did you decide was soft, and why?

Checking the design with the people who will use it

As the mutual action plan required, Maya sent the solution outline to Simone and Trevor on January 26, without prices, and asked each of them to mark anything that was wrong or missing. Sending a design for checking before the presentation has two purposes. It catches mistakes while they are cheap to fix, and it gives the people who will live with the solution a stake in it.

Comments on the solution outline and Maya's responses.
ReviewerCommentMaya's change
TrevorRoomFlow and the video bars must sign in through Wheatland's email accountsConfirmed both support single sign-on; added a setup day with Trevor
TrevorStaff building cards are proximity cardsConfirmed the printers' badge readers accept the same cards, so no new cards are needed
SimoneThe training room also hosts the monthly all-staff meeting by videoRaised the training-room camera and microphone specification already included; no price change
SimoneTwo schedulers work part-time and share a deskKept 18 workstations; noted desk-sharing in the layout
Deshawn (through Simone)Monitor arms must hold two 27-inch screensConfirmed the arm rating

None of the comments changed the price, but two of them would have caused trouble on installation day if they had been missed. Trevor's point about proximity cards would otherwise have surfaced only when the first printer refused to release a job.

Offering options

SLS-222 taught that a single take-it-or-leave-it proposal forces the customer into a yes or no, while a small set of honest options lets the customer choose the level of investment. Rob asked Maya to prepare three options for the presentation, each complete in itself.

Three options for Wheatland, before taxes.
OptionIncludesOne-time (dollars)Monthly (dollars)
A: Move essentialsAll furniture, delivery and installation67,600None
B: Training and bookingOption A plus training-room and meeting-room video and RoomFlow88,200270
C: CompleteOption B plus managed print across three sites88,200985

Option C has the same one-time price as option B because managed print has no up-front charge; it adds 715 dollars a month, which is less than Wheatland pays for printing today. Maya planned to recommend option C and to explain why, while making sure that options A and B were genuine choices rather than decoys. SLS-222 warned that an option designed only to make another look good is a manipulation that buyers often recognize.

The case in one paragraph

Before any presentation, Rob asks sellers to write the whole value case in one paragraph that the executive sponsor could repeat to the board. Maya's version for Rachel read: "For about 88,000 dollars, Wheatland gets a head office designed for its schedulers and a training room that branch staff can join by video. Using Wheatland's own figures, the training technology pays for itself in about two years and keeps paying after that, even if only half the trips are avoided. Replacing the printers costs less than today, protects client information and is installed on the same schedule. Ridgeline's lead time leaves seven weeks of slack before the move." Rob changed one phrase: "pays for itself" became "recovers its cost", because a board member might read "pays for itself" as a promise rather than an estimate.

Common mistakes

  • MistakeAdd everything the customer might buy.

    InsteadPropose what traces to the customer's problems; keep the rest as options or future ideas.

  • MistakeUse the seller's discount rate.

    InsteadUse the customer's rate, such as its cost of borrowing.

  • MistakeEvery part of the solution needs an ROI.

    InsteadUse payback and NPV for investments; compare totals for cost replacements.

  • MistakeA single expected case is enough.

    InsteadShow low and high cases for any estimate the conclusion depends on.

Summary and key terms

  • The solution design traces every component to a problem, constraint or requirement Wheatland stated; laptop leasing failed the test and moved to future ideas.
  • Standard prices total 88,200 dollars one-time, plus 270 dollars a month for RoomFlow and 715 for managed print.
  • The training technology pays back in about 22 months with a five-year NPV of about 26,400 dollars at Wheatland's 6 in 100 rate, and stays positive even if only half the trips are avoided.
  • Managed print costs about 27,100 dollars less than today over five years and meets Joanne's privacy requirements.
  • The assumptions register sources every figure and keeps soft value out of the totals.
Solution design
A description of what a seller will supply and why each part answers a customer need.
Traceability
The link between each component of a solution and something the customer said.
Value case
A quantified argument for a purchase, built from the customer's data and stated assumptions.
Sensitivity analysis
Testing how a result changes when a key assumption is lower or higher.
Soft value
A real benefit that does not directly change the customer's spending, such as staff time saved.

Practice problems

Work each problem on paper first, then reveal the answer to check.

  1. Why did laptop leasing come out of the solution?

    Show answer

    No one at Wheatland had mentioned laptops, so it did not trace to a stated need.

  2. If trips avoided were 60 in 100, what would the net annual benefit be?

    Show answer

    14,400 × 0.6 + 3,600 − 3,240 = 8,640 + 360 = 9,000 dollars.

  3. Why compare five-year totals for printing instead of calculating an ROI?

    Show answer

    There is no up-front investment; it replaces one monthly cost with another.

Lesson quiz · 5 questions

Score 60% or more to complete this lesson.

Take the quiz